Elbow
Build A Rocket Boys!


4.5
superb

Review

by donovr USER (8 Reviews)
May 17th, 2011 | 20 replies


Release Date: 2011 | Tracklist

Review Summary: Elbow's newest record sounds like a complicated version of Coldplay.

Looking Back

While I am still considered young, I've spent enough time on earth to have memories both of joy and regret. Looking back at the route my life encountered, my memories flicker like a vintage slideshow. No matter the circumstantial drama that inhibited my joy, the filters in my mind’s eye soften these images. In a way, some of my simplest memories slip into poetic imagery.

In a similar way, Elbow’s latest record, Build a Rocket Boys, finds lyricist Guy Garvey painting evocative pictures of his youth. The record centers on themes of childhood, looking back through the memory with rose-colored glasses, and remembering what it meant to be young.

To The Music

The album begins with “The Birds,” an infectious tune anchored by a unique chord progression on the piano.

Garvey sings,
“The birds / Are the keepers of our Secret / As they saw us where we lay / In the deepest grass of springtime / In a reckless guilty haze”
Citing this memory from “bird’s eye view”, the album begins by pointing the listener to an introspective position. Musically, as the tune builds, the band links multiple sections together into a final chorus of sound.

The record continues with “Lippy Kids.” As a delayed keyboard rhythmically echoes the piano melody, Garvey mimics the notes as he sings:
“Lippy kids on the corner again / Lippy kids on the corner begin settling like crows / Though I never perfected the simian stroll / The cigarette senate was everything then / Do they know those days are golden / Build a rocket boys”
As if in lamentation, Garvey urges these burnouts to make something of their life. These kids have unlimited potential and could do much more than “hanging out.”

Vocals Meet Piano

Additionally, this song exhibits Garvey’s trend throughout the album to follow the piano chords and melodies. It is pretty clear that Elbow’s creative process for vocal melodies begins with a piano. Considering that I begin in the same spot, I can’t fault the band for writing piano-based melodies. It is curious, however, that the band kept the piano melodies in the mix as if they exist as a crutch helping Garvey sing the proper notes.

Better Days

On top of framing the songs through memories of youth, Garvey expresses a desire to go back to those simpler days. Almost as if his current life is a prodigal son compared to the way things were, he sings in “Open Arms,”
“Tables are for pounding here / And when we’ve got you surrounded / The man you are will know the man you were / And you’re not the man who fell to Earth / You’re the man of La Mancha / But we’ve love enough to light the street / Cause everybody’s here / We’ve got open arms for broken hearts / Like yours my boy / Come home again”
Ultimately, the plea to “come home again” thematically dominates this record.

Build a Rocket Boys presents some excellent songs. On top of the ones already mentioned, “Neat Little Rows,” “The Night Will Always Win,” and “The River” highlight the best of this record.

A Complicated Version of Coldplay

While the musicianship on the album is not highly technical, the composition and production of Build a Rocket Boys offers the listener countless intricacies as listens mount. With unique chord progressions and full-sounding instrumentation, Elbow’s sound resembles a more complicated version of Coldplay and supports the thematic elements of the record nicely.

Just as my memories flicker in positive-filtered hue, Build a Rocket Boys reminds me of the way things were, the way I wished things would be, and, ultimately, the way life was and is good. If you are a fan of “Brit-pop” or just like well-crafted tunes, I recommend this album.

Originally published at wherepenmeetspaper.blogspot.com



Recent reviews by this author
The Civil Wars Barton HollowRadiohead The King of Limbs
William Fitzsimmons Gold In The ShadowMike Farris Salvation in Lights
Sigur Ros Heima (DVD)Cary Brothers Who You Are
user ratings (156)
3.4
great
other reviews of this album
defjaw83 (4)
Looking back is for the birds...



Comments:Add a Comment 
descendents1
May 18th 2011


702 Comments


The Sun doesn't circle the Earth.

The Earth doesn't even circle the Sun. It's an elliptical orbit. Sigh no one cares.

rasputin
May 18th 2011


14967 Comments


lol

donovr
May 18th 2011


25 Comments

Album Rating: 4.5

Thanks for the constructive criticism.

liledman
May 18th 2011


3828 Comments


nice summary

descendents1
May 18th 2011


702 Comments


I didn't vote, nor did I read your review after the first sentence.

foreverendeared
May 18th 2011


14720 Comments


troll review sighting

Deviant.
Staff Reviewer
May 18th 2011


32289 Comments


Can't say that I am a fan of this format of yours

defjaw83
May 18th 2011


1805 Comments

Album Rating: 4.0 | Sound Off

Was intrigued to see if this review is better than mine. First sentence was reassuring

defjaw83
May 18th 2011


1805 Comments

Album Rating: 4.0 | Sound Off

It is curious, however, that the band kept the piano melodies in the mix as if they exist as bumper rails in a bowling alley for the vocals to focus on the pins without falling in the gutter.




call me thick but I don't understand this

rasputin
May 18th 2011


14967 Comments


Was intrigued to see if this review is better than mine. First sentence was reassuring


at least this review isn't dull

defjaw83
May 18th 2011


1805 Comments

Album Rating: 4.0 | Sound Off

Ok man

rasputin
May 18th 2011


14967 Comments


okay

defjaw83
May 18th 2011


1805 Comments

Album Rating: 4.0 | Sound Off

mmkay

descendents1
May 18th 2011


702 Comments


Here's some constructive criticism:

Focus less on trying to make your writing "pretty" and focus more on the points you are trying to get across. You become a better review writer (in the beginning, at least) by effectively describing the album, not by experimenting with style. Do that later. Stick with simplicity for now and you'll improve naturally.

Edit: You really should go back and change your first sentence. It isn't bad just because it's unscientific, it doesn't even make sense. People will read your first sentence and immediately neg you. Still haven't voted... Maybe consider a re-write? Your framing of the paragraphs didn't bother me, it's your writing that was poor. Like I said, focus on getting points across directly and cleanly.

ConsiderPhlebas
May 18th 2011


6157 Comments


So many whimsical kids on this site

defjaw83
May 18th 2011


1805 Comments

Album Rating: 4.0 | Sound Off

nice avatar Phlebas. He's the best character in GOT by a mile

donovr
May 18th 2011


25 Comments

Album Rating: 4.5

It seems like the issue at stake is the use of metaphorical language. I understand your points, some of it is rather sloppy. I'll see if I can redraft it to make more sense.

Steoandnoodles
May 18th 2011


2832 Comments


It's an interesting format. =)
I think you could work on the quotations a little though (they're kind of jumbled about) but I like the idea of giving the sections of your review 'headings' so to speak.

defjaw83
May 18th 2011


1805 Comments

Album Rating: 4.0 | Sound Off

It's not a bad review really but that first sentence has to go

donovr
May 18th 2011


25 Comments

Album Rating: 4.5

I tried to simplify the metaphors. Hopefully, that clears up some of the rancor around the review.



You have to be logged in to post a comment. Login | Create a Profile





STAFF & CONTRIBUTORS // CONTACT US

Bands: A B C D E F G H I J K L M N O P Q R S T U V W X Y Z


Site Copyright 2005-2023 Sputnikmusic.com
All Album Reviews Displayed With Permission of Authors | Terms of Use | Privacy Policy