The Menzingers - Some of it Was True User Opinions

The Menzingers Some of it Was True

dig it

3.0
good

Release Date: 2023
Tracklist

Full Review

Ratings (106)

Give your Rating

3.5 great	didnt ask to be staff, was made staff anyway, then got demoted for not doing staff stuff \| January 2nd 24
Apparently, the quest for the answer to Menzingers' defining question in their latter career, "What are we gonna do now that our 20s are over?" is a resounding "We'll go back to writing the same things we've done before our 20s." 1 Bumps \| Bump

2.5 average	grandfather \| October 13th 23
Mid as hell, but there are some stellar vocal melodies throughout (as expected) and they make it worth a listen or two. Production feels like it aimed for big-budget but missed the park, which hampers it a bit. 1 Bumps \| Bump

2.5 average	https://jomageddon.wordpress.com/2025/06/28/sputnikmusic-staff-exodus/ https://jomageddon.wordpress. \| October 13th 23
the mehnzingers 1 Bumps \| Bump

2.8 good	Erwann S. EMERITUS \| October 23rd 23
The Menzingers go full heartland, and it's aight but not really good either - gonna jam On the Impossible Past one more fucking time. Bump

2.0 poor	thosemadsounds \| October 14th 23
starts with one of the catchiest songs they've ever written and then just goes downhill from there and settles into mediocrity. some good moments here and there, but very few great ones. Bump

4.5 superb	Jarnii \| October 13th 23
Songwriting tops almost everything on hello exile. I'm actually really digging the americana feel on this album Bump

3.5 great	Rawrz \| October 13th 23
Band stays consistent with another great album. Not an all timer like On The Impossible Past or After The Party but on pat with the rest of their output. Bump

2.5 average	TT \| October 6th 23
Bump

0.0	matbla00 \| October 3rd 23
A new album? I?m dreading they?re taking the boring slash good enough for background music direction. Bump

4.0 excellent

JTFly17 | September 25th 25

3.5 great

5am | September 10th 25

3.0 good

roofi | June 15th 25

2.5 average

BeneMaja | May 7th 25

2.5 average

Zeiu | May 2nd 25

2.5 average

MarkTheDead | April 24th 25

3.5 great

IAmEveresttt | March 31st 25

3.0 good

guamman64 | October 12th 24

3.0 good

UrukHai | October 4th 24

4.5 superb

ThisMemory | September 9th 24

2.0 poor

IdlyIdeological | July 17th 24

2.0 poor

SheWatchedTheSky | June 19th 24

3.0 good

EoinCofa | June 3rd 24

3.0 good

crankstrap | February 13th 24

2.5 average

Groundking | February 7th 24

3.0 good

STDandALK3 | February 6th 24

3.0 good

HarlequinRolodexMak2 | January 28th 24

2.0 poor

Illume | January 9th 24

3.5 great

McGuire95 | January 9th 24

2.5 average

TheSupernatural | December 24th 23

2.0 poor

alamo | December 12th 23

3.5 great

To me, Green Day in and of themselves are almost a cringe proposition in and of themselves | November 26th 23

2.5 average

Potatodinner | November 20th 23

3.5 great

aaronrkc | November 20th 23

2.0 poor

Pangea | November 16th 23

3.5 great

XXMurdaBeatzXX | November 13th 23

2.5 average

Whatsarahsaid | November 8th 23

2.5 average

btrfs | November 8th 23

2.5 average

Matty CONTRIBUTOR | November 7th 23

3.0 good

AngryJohnny | November 6th 23

3.5 great

Minushuman24 | November 5th 23

3.0 good

Monsterpoptart | November 5th 23

2.5 average

hadriel | November 3rd 23

4.0 excellent

Rickey Henderson | November 3rd 23

3.0 good

Mutantsnowstorm | October 26th 23

2.5 average

Peter Tanner | October 26th 23

2.5 average

AmbushReality | October 25th 23

3.5 great

mrManxxx | October 25th 23

2.5 average

Frank - the rater of 3.5 | October 24th 23

3.0 good

DavidPrincipe29 | October 24th 23

2.0 poor

ironzeppelin789 | October 24th 23

2.5 average

ArrestedImpulse | October 24th 23

3.0 good

ArtBox | October 24th 23

2.5 average

WillFromAmerica | October 23rd 23

2.5 average

Thy Supreme Vomit Kommander, Nicholas von Nuclearpiss | October 23rd 23

3.0 good

lucazade22 | October 22nd 23

3.5 great

maheck | October 21st 23

3.5 great

inherentkev | October 21st 23

2.5 average

El Olam | October 18th 23

2.5 average

Trebor. EMERITUS | October 18th 23

3.0 good

Anthracks | October 18th 23

2.5 average

NorwichScene | October 18th 23

3.5 great

ErocktheGreatest | October 18th 23

2.5 average

nicktheman1 | October 18th 23

2.0 poor

tectactoe | October 18th 23

3.0 good

Nbehre11 | October 18th 23

3.0 good

kroglor | October 17th 23

3.0 good

jmh886 | October 17th 23

3.5 great

BasicMusicTaste | October 17th 23

3.0 good

mallen- | October 17th 23

3.5 great

BeeRyan | October 16th 23

3.5 great

drasticaction74 | October 16th 23

3.0 good

Sunnyvale EMERITUS | October 16th 23

2.0 poor

No joke names, please, or you will have a temporary ban. | October 16th 23

2.5 average

J | October 16th 23

3.0 good

LotionLord | October 15th 23

3.5 great

zzf1918 | October 15th 23

3.0 good

Steven P. | October 15th 23

3.5 great

mikep87 | October 15th 23

3.0 good

Spooncubus | October 15th 23

3.0 good

Sowing STAFF | October 15th 23

3.5 great

buttgrinder | October 15th 23

2.0 poor

jtswope | October 14th 23

3.5 great

KManoc1 | October 14th 23

4.5 superb

TriangularDuck | October 14th 23

3.0 good

Lassie | October 14th 23

2.5 average

AxeToFall93 | October 14th 23

3.0 good

OverSlyZed91 | October 14th 23

3.0 good

BlackFugazi | October 14th 23

4.0 excellent

tom79 | October 14th 23

2.5 average

Edgy rap-rock. Not my thing at all. Feel free to move to Venezuela if Capitalism bothers you idiots | October 14th 23

4.0 excellent

Channing Freeman STAFF | October 14th 23

2.5 average

Eldar777 | October 13th 23

2.5 average

BigBoofZone | October 13th 23

3.0 good

bellovddd | October 13th 23

4.5 superb

RoyRogersMcFreely | October 13th 23

4.5 superb

GodForbid | October 13th 23

2.5 average

Bilbodabag | October 13th 23

3.0 good

I have an awful memory of a high school ex sitting on my baby blue vinyl of The Dusk In Us lmao EMERITUS | October 13th 23

2.5 average

JacobsLadder | October 13th 23

2.5 average

Jack Mancuso EMERITUS | October 13th 23

4.0 excellent

ZombieParty | October 13th 23

3.0 good

Luna | October 13th 23

2.0 poor

itsalargeboat | October 13th 23

3.0 good

Zac124 | October 13th 23

3.5 great

jesper EMERITUS | October 13th 23

3.5 great

Mr Snrub | October 13th 23

3.0 good

Slothy Seconds | October 12th 23

Give Your Opinion on Some of it Was True

You have to be logged in to rate this album Login | Create a Profile

STAFF & CONTRIBUTORS // CONTACT US

Bands: A B C D E F G H I J K L M N O P Q R S T U V W X Y Z

Site Copyright 2005-2023 Sputnikmusic.com
All Album Reviews Displayed With Permission of Authors | Terms of Use | Privacy Policy