| ||Full Review||Ratings (306)
||Give your Rating|
|5.0 classic||bloodshy :) | October 4th 19|
Almost perfect but suffers a bit from too much try-harding.
12 Bumps | Bump
|4.0 excellent||Bhurke | October 4th 19|
Will probably love this, Poppy’s gonna do a reverse-BMTH at this point
Update: yea it’s good
7 Bumps | Bump
|4.0 excellent||neekafat CONTRIBUTOR | January 11th 20|
wtf this is just Babymetal for people who don't like anime
6 Bumps | Bump
|2.5 average||Johnny[Well] STAFF | January 10th 20|
Weeb pop for distractible metalheads who thought they were over nu metal. When Grimes
plundered the kawaii-niverse to chalk up cheap points for 'innovation' with lazy U.S. critics over
Art Angels, she must have thought it was common sense to leave out the Babymetal. Nice 1-
upmanship, Poppy. Pretty inoffensive, a few cool left-turns, and an overall decent run of dumb
6 Bumps | Bump
|4.5 superb||JakeStallion | January 9th 20|
Sounds like a natural progression from the direction she was headed on the Choke EP. She shows a clear appreciate of the nu-metal/alt-metal sound of the late 90s/early 2000s with enough fresh ideas and weird Poppy flare to ever keep it from sounding like a ripoff. This is fantastic.
2 Bumps | Bump
|2.5 average||Robert Garland CONTRIBUTOR | January 9th 20|
Is it weird that I'm more than just on board with this?
2 Bumps | Bump
|2.0 poor||NickLizard49 | January 10th 20|
The only good thing about this record is that it brings "weeird" sounds to pop lovers and random listeners. Most of the album is bland pop with boring melodies, sometimes with bland edgy guitars, sometimes with bland low quality industrial sounds. Sometimes the transition between hard and soft or viceversa is just hilarious, sometimes it suits well. Overall not an horrible achievement, but nothing good either.
1 Bumps | Bump
|0.0 ||Xenophanes STAFF | January 10th 20|
Not very good but better than it has any right to be.
1 Bumps | Bump
|3.5 great||Quattro Bajeena CONTRIBUTOR | January 10th 20|
Even for Poppy the move into metal was a turn of unexpected turn of events, one that she's
masterfully manipulated into a victory. She built on the rejection of expectations with a
very solid set of songs that delve heavily into nu-metal, metalcore, and industrial metal
territory, very much seizing upon the late 90's revival zeitgeist that's permeated the underground
metal scene while also infusing the music with her typical pop infectiousness and trademarked
1 Bumps | Bump
|4.5 superb||brandiblitz142 | October 4th 19|
Wow, actually was impressed with the album. Also, "Don't Go Outside" was very good.
1 Bumps | Bump
|3.0 good||Blazewire | July 2nd 20|
I Disagree is a fun but unbalanced album. There are an interesting mix of influences present, from the obvious pop, to arena rock, industrial metal stomp and Babymetal. I'm all for experimental albums with plenty of influences, it's just for me some of the songs don't land. I feel if the songs were more focused to a particular style I would have enjoyed it more. I'm very intrigued to see what Poppy does next. Songs to check out: Concrete, and I Disagree
|4.0 excellent||ChoccyPhilly | June 11th 20|
Album title accurately personifies my exact response to whenever this album is brought up
in conversation to normies
|3.5 great||davezillaMP3 | May 25th 20|
Pretty damn great Kawaii Metal album, even if i am not AS hot on it as I was when it first came out (for reference, my OG. score of this was a 5). this is a high Great that is a hair short of being an Excellent.
|4.0 excellent||GoldenGuy444 | May 2nd 20|
Absolutely audacious. Especially that opening track, just so many different genres clashing together. It does work though, and for a majority of the album it rides the fine line between sweet and rough very well.
|3.5 great||cjbizzlebizzle | March 18th 20|
Poppy is just something I would expect to dislike if someone were to describe her image and music to me but in the end it doesn't take long to enjoy this album. The first 60 seconds go from whispering over a siren to like two bars of a stereotypical dissonant lead over breakdown rhythm to an uptempo dream pop chorus right back into the nu metal breakdown. The album continues with these eclectic, energetic ups and downs and in the end it is kind of a wild ride full of humor and a great mix of the dark heavy nu metal and glistening, shiny, over the top pop elements. Perhaps the best thing here are the transitions between both worlds, at times flawlessly morphing from the metal into the pop. It feels like this album shouldn't work but in the end most of the tracks are catchy and display above average songwriting to be able to blend heavily contrasted styles.
|3.0 good||ellagos | January 14th 20|
Feels gimmicky at its most metal moments thanks to some lifeless performances but the more melodic songs are good and an indicator of where Poppy should move to next.
|3.5 great||Mitch | January 14th 20|
I guess this is the next logical step for her to go. Concrete is easily the best song on here, kinda dips after that. Still thoroughly enjoyable though.
|3.5 great||Lucman | January 11th 20|
Well this slaps....wasn't expecting that at all.
|3.5 great||Toondude | January 11th 20|
what the fuck is this and why do I like it?
|4.0 excellent||Evangelancer | January 10th 20|
I am a metalhead, but secretly love Poppy, and have from the beginning (my wife and I almost used 'Lowlife' in our wedding). I was nervous about her crossover into metal, especially with BLOODMONEY and Concrete as the first singles, but the rest of this album absolutely nails the blend of pop and metal Poppy. Excellent production, good songwriting, even better than expected album structuring - this is good.
|2.5 average||rsxng | August 3rd 20|
|3.5 great||Boh | August 1st 20|
|4.0 excellent||Votex | April 10th 20|
|2.5 average||Coast | April 4th 20|
|5.0 classic||Greyvy | March 18th 20|
|4.0 excellent||Abraxas | February 29th 20|
|3.5 great||AdamE | February 24th 20|
|1.0 awful||T3KK3N | February 22nd 20|
|2.5 average||tellah | February 21st 20|
|4.0 excellent||Barnumj0 | February 20th 20|
|3.0 good||Mojito | February 13th 20|
|4.0 excellent||IzzyTomy | February 12th 20|
|3.0 good||Trey STAFF | February 4th 20|
|4.5 superb||Xirae | January 31st 20|
|2.0 poor||JS19 | January 30th 20|
|3.5 great||eirinn | January 30th 20|
|3.5 great||vult | January 30th 20|
|3.5 great||greg84 EMERITUS | January 26th 20|
|4.5 superb||Josh F. | January 25th 20|
|4.5 superb||Jimmer3 | January 23rd 20|
|2.0 poor||Lalka | January 17th 20|
|3.0 good||Dmax28 | January 16th 20|
|4.5 superb||Thiagao | January 15th 20|
|2.5 average||Krelkin | January 14th 20|
|3.0 good||shanks | January 14th 20|
|4.0 excellent||SoxRock | January 14th 20|
|3.0 good||Corney | January 14th 20|
|3.5 great||Moge | January 13th 20|
|3.5 great||Risodo | January 13th 20|
|3.0 good||bharry | January 13th 20|
|1.5 very poor||pengui | January 13th 20|
|4.0 excellent||Keira | January 13th 20|
|4.0 excellent||P0laris | January 12th 20|
|4.0 excellent||furpa | January 12th 20|
|1.0 awful||botb | January 12th 20|
|4.0 excellent||Maximo | January 12th 20|
|1.0 awful||Next | January 12th 20|
|2.0 poor||Elynna | January 12th 20|
|2.0 poor||Dewinged CONTRIBUTOR | January 12th 20|
|3.5 great||"Tab" | January 11th 20|
|4.0 excellent||Djang0 | January 11th 20|
|4.0 excellent||Faraudo | January 11th 20|
|3.5 great||jsaf7 | January 11th 20|
|4.0 excellent||GT3 | January 11th 20|
|1.0 awful||Simon K. STAFF | January 11th 20|
|3.5 great||Aeri | January 11th 20|
|4.0 excellent||alamo | January 11th 20|
|3.5 great||Blurbs | January 11th 20|
|4.0 excellent||scrappy | January 10th 20|
|3.5 great||chris. | January 10th 20|
|3.5 great||Steev | January 10th 20|
|4.0 excellent||RyanW | January 10th 20|
|3.0 good||Grumpy | January 10th 20|
Give Your Opinion on I Disagree