Rishloo   Living as Ghosts with Buildings as Teeth
4.1
excellent
Ranking: #7 for 2014

 Full ReviewRatings (435) Give your Rating

5.0 classicmanwithpineapple | December 14th 14

This is the most emotionally satisfying album I've ever heard. I can think I can safely say this is what Lateralus tried to be. The end of Dark Charade alone sounds like the wrath of god!

5 Bumps | Bump

5.0 classickdkade | January 21st 15

I just had to create an account here to give this one a five. I absolutely adore it. It's filled with amazing moments that remind me why I'm into music at all. rI'm not saying this album is without any flaws. On the other hand I believe that while all of those flaws get easily lost among the really solid and beautiful stuff, an album deserves a perfect score. And hell, this is one of those albums from where I stand.

1 Bumps | Bump

5.0 classicNPE | December 10th 14

This is such a great album! I thought that nobody would be able to top Sound Awake or 10000 Days, but they did it - with ease! I do not know how many times I have listened to this album since yesterday, I just know that it does not tire and stays great. WOW!!!

1 Bumps | Bump

5.0 classicSach360 | December 10th 14

Pretty damn amazing. At first I felt the album was a little short, though at 50 minutes it's a testament to how cohesive this album is as it feels like it's over much faster.

1 Bumps | Bump

4.0 excellentRowan5215 EMERITUS | December 10th 14

Dark Charade blew me through a couple of doors and into next week. Holy Drew, how in the name of Maynard do you do it

1 Bumps | Bump

0.0 zetsumeisama | April 4th 19

Favorite Tracks: Landmines, Just a Ride, The Great Rain Beatle.

Bump

4.5 superbChrysisure | March 31st 16

A massive step-up from their earlier discography; they've cultivated a sound which displays their remarkable musicianship and emanates an aura that is utterly captivating.

Bump

4.5 superbBritch2tiger | July 4th 15

As much as I enjoy the various changes in vocal delivery appearing in each Rishloo album, I can't help feeling this album was a tad anti-climactic compared to their prior two albums. Living As Ghosts is the closest this band has created music to embody their shoegaze influences. The sound reminds me of My Bloody Valentine's Loveless. Not completely implying that is a bad quality, it just makes me wonder what could've been done different to make this shoegaze stand out by (certain) comparison. Another quality I liked was the attempt at lengthening their songs. Where I normally find most lengthy prog songs to be pretentious, this is one of the few albums w/ songs I could enjoy from start to finish from all parts involved making this music. This is an easy 4/5, but ranking this a 4.5/5 rating may be a tad generous. But SCREW IT, this album is still AWESOME!

Bump

4.5 superbAmerica's Favorite Hemophobe! ♦ | May 19th 15

Oozing with talent and ambition. This album delivers, firing on all cylinders.

Bump

4.5 superbpornogrindtheater | December 25th 14

Still hoping that one day people stop comparing Rishloo to Tool. At this point, they're fucking hugely different bands.

Bump

4.0 excellentthestop5 | December 22nd 14

8/10

Bump

4.5 superbthosava | December 10th 14

I love all their earlier albums, and in time i know i will love this one too. This album feels like their most consistent to date. The great rain beatle, landmines, dark charade and winslow are spectacular!

Bump

5.0 classiccristane | December 10th 14

Absolutely fantastic. After the breaking up and reuniting, they haven't lost a beat. Their best album yet.

Bump

4.5 superbDrpibb | December 10th 14

This album feels much more personal than any of their previous albums have.

Bump

4.5 superbAlex C. | December 10th 14

2014 has been a bleak year - Rishloo luckily play the role of prog saviours and some damn fine intricate and meaningful music too.

Bump

4.0 excellenttur1smo64 | June 21st 25
4.0 excellentSagacious13 | April 3rd 25
4.5 superbfaustuscopernicum | March 22nd 25
3.5 greatGod of terror, very low dost thou bring us, very low hast thou brought us | January 21st 25
4.0 excellentis lifelover the love of my life | August 22nd 24
4.0 excellentAeternal | May 29th 24
5.0 classicmeganeura | April 20th 24
4.0 excellentToolock | February 25th 24
4.5 superbPikazilla | September 17th 23
5.0 classicmechanical | September 17th 23
4.0 excellentnylonhair | August 16th 23
4.0 excellentjustsomelad | July 25th 23
4.0 excellentInnobblidobli | June 6th 23
4.5 superbFanCrazedPanda | June 6th 23
4.0 excellentunchange2change2 | May 12th 23
4.0 excellentShwany | January 13th 23
4.0 excellentScornfyre | December 1st 22
5.0 classicStunDamage | September 30th 22
4.0 excellentsolrage | September 15th 22
4.0 excellentHiyabootchie2 | September 2nd 22
3.0 goodMatyMasaryk | July 11th 22
3.5 greatYankeeDudel | July 7th 22
4.0 excellentZakusz | June 3rd 22
4.0 excellentRolling Girl | March 5th 22
4.0 excellentstyxswatz | February 10th 22
5.0 classicgozeneboshi | November 21st 21
5.0 classicMarlonBrandoEyes | November 9th 21
4.5 superbmax13x | August 13th 21
4.0 excellentUniverseCalling | June 29th 21
2.5 averagechwe | June 16th 21
4.0 excellentbirdistheword | April 24th 21
4.5 superbOobaloo | April 8th 21
4.5 superbGreenyQueeny | April 1st 21
3.5 greatSupernatural103 | March 19th 21
2.0 poorClaystation | February 26th 21
3.5 greatCHINDI | February 15th 21
2.0 poorwojodta | February 15th 21
4.5 superbJuuso | February 7th 21
4.0 excellentBenjamin Jack EMERITUS | January 12th 21
3.5 greatBlazinBlitzer | November 8th 20
5.0 classicShadowOfTheCitadel | November 3rd 20
2.0 poorElynna | October 20th 20
4.5 superbSyzygy23 | October 7th 20
4.0 excellentfantalas | August 22nd 20
4.0 excellentunchange | August 20th 20
4.0 excellentLettuceInAmbers | August 19th 20
4.0 excellentaalqui | August 9th 20
4.0 excellentMiloslaw Archibald Rugallini EMERITUS | July 20th 20
4.0 excellentterriblekonrad | July 18th 20
4.0 excellenti guess i'll just do it all again differently the next time. | May 27th 20
4.0 excellentfrippuccino | May 26th 20
4.0 excellentSilentDowncoming | May 22nd 20
4.0 excellentRanzki | May 1st 20
4.0 excellentkonsmake | April 30th 20
5.0 classicAnomiaProductions | April 11th 20
4.5 superbMomozitos | April 9th 20
3.5 greatMacck | March 30th 20
2.5 averageChrysoar | March 30th 20
3.5 greatSpag | March 15th 20
3.0 goodWolfe | November 22nd 19
4.0 excellentFlomink | November 22nd 19
4.0 excellentLOGOS | November 18th 19
5.0 classicArtCav77 | September 28th 19
4.5 superbsnakesc | September 19th 19
4.0 excellentFakeOne | September 14th 19
4.0 excellentmonocaust | September 12th 19
3.0 goodFlakMT | September 7th 19
4.0 excellentEpicurean | September 3rd 19
4.0 excellentCthulhuFhtagn | August 25th 19
4.0 excellentPickleVai17 | August 13th 19
4.0 excellentTheWalkinDude | August 12th 19
4.0 excellentRisodo | August 7th 19
3.5 greatgerbothgely | July 19th 19
3.5 greatJ.C. van Beekum | July 17th 19
3.0 goodloves uplifting twinkly bs | July 12th 19
4.0 excellentstargazer76 | June 24th 19
3.5 greatmakkusu92 | May 23rd 19
4.5 superbDune1 | May 19th 19
3.5 greatEoinCofa | May 3rd 19
4.0 excellentSpicyPikachu1 | April 24th 19
4.5 superbRichRamp | April 12th 19
4.5 superbmariapaikoy | April 9th 19
3.0 goodDolving999 | March 24th 19
4.0 excellentMindlessIdiot | March 14th 19
4.0 excellentEarlgrey79 | March 5th 19
4.0 excellentRelinquish | March 3rd 19
4.5 superbntinkster | February 28th 19
3.5 greatFrooTxLuPs | February 26th 19
4.0 excellentSputnik's Go-To Doom/Stoner/Sludge Guy | February 18th 19
3.5 greatCamation99 | February 17th 19
4.5 superbStonedManatee | February 16th 19
3.5 greatAranox | February 12th 19
3.5 greatSlothy Seconds | January 18th 19
4.5 superbourbloodyhands | January 15th 19
5.0 classicFurtherDown | December 22nd 18
2.0 poorFullOfSounds | December 15th 18
4.0 excellentBerryGarlicia | December 11th 18
4.5 superbTheMightyScoop | December 10th 18
4.5 superbDDconjoined | November 25th 18
4.0 excellentGreengo | October 25th 18
4.0 excellentpiratejokern | October 16th 18
4.5 superbHewitt | September 30th 18
5.0 classicashen386 | September 29th 18
5.0 classicReini Eden | September 18th 18
4.0 excellentFreedom | September 10th 18
3.5 greatAbraxas | August 27th 18
4.0 excellentariich | August 18th 18
4.5 superbADrunkenSkunk | August 16th 18
3.5 greatKlingel0905 | July 20th 18
3.0 goodUndyingMind | June 24th 18
4.5 superbgib91688 | June 6th 18
4.0 excellentgreymatter68 | May 31st 18
4.0 excellentultrainstinctgranny | May 28th 18
3.0 goodProgRockIsBetter | May 22nd 18
4.0 excellentNoam Chomsky | May 20th 18
4.0 excellentstealjohnny | May 10th 18
4.5 superbalarm | May 1st 18
4.0 excellentJDubb | April 29th 18
3.5 greatVerlix | March 22nd 18
3.5 greatgilly | March 14th 18
4.0 excellentXavier | March 12th 18
4.0 excellentMouzred | March 9th 18
5.0 classicfranticj3 | March 6th 18
4.0 excellentmisha | March 2nd 18
5.0 classicBerryMcCokner | January 20th 18
4.0 excellentOreon | January 10th 18
4.0 excellentFugue | December 20th 17
4.0 excellenthesperus | December 20th 17
4.0 excellentStrills | December 19th 17
4.5 superbPantagrul | December 16th 17
4.5 superbMordekai | December 9th 17
4.0 excellentKostekK | December 3rd 17
4.5 superbC3llarD00r | November 5th 17
4.0 excellentsebchando | October 25th 17
5.0 classicteolaiho | October 18th 17
4.5 superbadios | October 8th 17
4.5 superbDrThodt | September 24th 17
5.0 classicSrpskiCekic | September 21st 17
4.0 excellentSlowlyFallingAwake | September 11th 17
4.5 superbArron | September 8th 17
4.5 superbtaomaokakao | September 1st 17
3.0 goodRobotE | August 25th 17
4.5 superbPhilbopeth | August 15th 17
3.5 greatJayM | July 15th 17
2.0 poorSplashAcademy | July 14th 17
2.0 poorbairdwilliams | June 5th 17
5.0 classicblob64 | May 19th 17
4.0 excellentwazooman | May 15th 17
3.5 greatEnoahBallard | May 6th 17
3.5 greatBeneMaja | April 26th 17
4.0 excellentsplaszu | April 20th 17
4.5 superbXXMurdaBeatzXX | March 31st 17
4.5 superbMeta123 | March 19th 17
4.0 excellentTakeToYourGuns | March 16th 17
3.5 greatTVparty | March 11th 17
3.5 greatPupvirtue | March 11th 17
5.0 classictcat84 | February 27th 17
4.5 superbWinndex | February 23rd 17
4.0 excellentnebula | February 22nd 17
4.0 excellentDaedus | February 8th 17
5.0 classiccd908 | December 14th 16
4.0 excellentSharpasglass | October 25th 16
4.5 superbTwiddlw | October 24th 16
5.0 classicRadex | October 16th 16
4.5 superbaudiosmurf | October 11th 16
3.5 greatxanderdake | October 9th 16
4.0 excellentMotoOnSputnik | October 7th 16
5.0 classicslut for crescendos | October 7th 16
4.5 superbguitaraussie823 | October 6th 16
4.0 excellentUnicornSlaya | October 4th 16
4.5 superbDominatus | September 28th 16
3.5 greatMathMetal09 | September 13th 16
5.0 classicIamhenryman | September 1st 16
5.0 classicKitkatman | August 30th 16
5.0 classicFloridasbest | August 30th 16
3.6 greatBenjamin Kuettel EMERITUS | August 29th 16
2.5 averagePattBraderson | August 19th 16
4.0 excellentBlackDahlia03 | July 30th 16
4.0 excellentbirdraptor | July 29th 16
3.5 greatRobert Davis | July 18th 16
5.0 classicJimtimson | July 17th 16
5.0 classicFredfredson | July 17th 16
5.0 classicRagnarmob | July 17th 16
3.5 greatfedericogambato | June 12th 16
4.0 excellentApsod | May 31st 16
3.5 greatobrelix | May 30th 16
4.0 excellentzuzek | May 30th 16
4.5 superbAphelion | May 22nd 16
4.0 excellentStereochrome1 | May 21st 16
4.0 excellentAnswerOnce | May 9th 16
5.0 classiciwaslost | May 3rd 16
4.5 superbBiff2210 | May 1st 16
2.5 averageHeppasodge | April 26th 16
4.5 superbbr4dl3yb34r | April 21st 16
3.5 greatseifer | April 16th 16
4.0 excellentSatelliteYears | April 10th 16
3.0 goodSpinningInsect | April 5th 16
4.0 excellentallvvarra | April 3rd 16
4.0 excellentlakiluki | April 1st 16
4.5 superbBeccaliz89 | March 30th 16
4.0 excellentmRA | March 6th 16
4.5 superbtherealvinniep | February 3rd 16
4.0 excellentJustinKing | January 24th 16
4.0 excellentDisconnected | January 23rd 16
4.0 excellentZloPseto | January 15th 16
4.5 superbMitch Worden EMERITUS | January 12th 16
3.5 greatjmh886 | January 7th 16
5.0 classicLibGyps | January 4th 16
3.5 greatchillin420 | December 28th 15
4.5 superbgiannis713 | December 28th 15
2.5 averagedbilidb | December 26th 15
3.0 goodTheCrocodile | December 22nd 15
4.0 excellentReflexion | December 4th 15
5.0 classicgeontes | November 30th 15
4.0 excellentjtswope | November 27th 15
4.0 excellentsbhargava1 | November 17th 15
4.5 superbRigwiz | November 7th 15
4.5 superbGMarques | October 29th 15
4.5 superbaggelosm | October 27th 15
4.5 superbfll | October 17th 15
4.0 excellentManiac! | October 9th 15
4.0 excellentKars Landman | October 1st 15
4.5 superbDigitalSchism | September 30th 15
4.0 excellentcloakanddagger | September 18th 15
3.0 goodmontekristoo99 | September 15th 15
5.0 classicThatsaFjord | September 11th 15
3.5 greatBradleyLayne | September 10th 15
3.0 goodkillians202 | August 25th 15
5.0 classicBenJones | August 24th 15
4.0 excellentAztreonam | August 20th 15
4.0 excellentPutinik | August 18th 15
4.5 superbPayneTiger777 | August 5th 15
5.0 classicJohnny Maccaroni | August 1st 15
3.5 greatstabbler | July 24th 15
4.0 excellentEscain | July 11th 15
4.5 superbvagskirito | July 9th 15
4.5 superbplatform4428 | June 29th 15
4.5 superbCubacabra | June 25th 15
4.5 superbRailTracer | June 21st 15
3.5 greatCarbonKhazi | June 19th 15
3.0 goodHydra12 | June 10th 15
2.0 poorPibblesBixley | June 4th 15
4.5 superbMahvJoss | June 3rd 15
3.5 greatDrZibuzzy | May 31st 15
4.0 excellentDantoni | May 31st 15
4.0 excellentOrtheore | May 16th 15
4.0 excellentdharqness | May 4th 15
4.0 excellentstonedinthemall | May 4th 15
4.5 superbtrvvve | April 29th 15
5.0 classicrufous | April 25th 15
4.5 superbALPHATAURUS | April 25th 15
3.0 goodSantet | April 21st 15
4.0 excellentDriveLikeJewhu | April 19th 15
4.5 superbStarchild9 | April 15th 15
4.0 excellenthamartia | April 13th 15
4.5 superbHyndez | April 8th 15
4.0 excellentlimestonemiler | April 6th 15
3.5 greatElitePumpkin | April 5th 15
4.0 excellentKerfuffleinaHussle | April 4th 15
3.5 greatVacantTool | March 31st 15
4.0 excellentXfingTheSullen | March 22nd 15
3.5 greatMajkl | March 22nd 15
4.0 excellentdeadcrown | March 22nd 15
4.0 excellentBeefcurtains | March 21st 15
5.0 classicIpop | March 21st 15
4.5 superbOfficialBlissfucker | March 19th 15
4.5 superbGuitarAussie | March 18th 15
4.5 superbFaraudo | March 18th 15
3.0 goodRabbitSeason | March 16th 15
4.5 superbparadoxical | March 11th 15
4.5 superbAndy1262 | March 11th 15
4.0 excellentDarkInfernal | March 7th 15
4.5 superblovecraftlives | March 6th 15
4.0 excellentfreakeye1112 | March 4th 15
4.5 superbkidthatplaysguitar91 | March 2nd 15
4.0 excellentTand0022 | March 2nd 15
3.5 greatRashandarei | February 25th 15
4.5 superbScaboodle | February 23rd 15
3.0 goodBrickAtticus | February 22nd 15
4.0 excellentConfessed2005 | February 21st 15
3.5 greatmemedfg | February 21st 15
4.0 excellentMazerus | February 19th 15
4.5 superbScenicRouteToSilence | February 18th 15
2.5 averageSirDrumsalot | February 17th 15
3.0 goodJethro42 | February 16th 15
3.5 greatMojito | February 16th 15
4.5 superbIraDeorum | February 15th 15
4.0 excellentProfessorVeerappan | February 13th 15
4.5 superbMotoMusic | February 10th 15
3.5 greatCoast | February 10th 15
3.0 goodCusmanX1 | February 8th 15
3.5 greatJokineAugustus | February 6th 15
4.5 superbunodostrescatorse | February 4th 15
2.0 poorNervousBreakdown | February 4th 15
4.0 excellentLaymi | February 3rd 15
2.0 poorRuneii | February 3rd 15
2.0 poorRadicalEd | February 3rd 15
3.5 greatXSebbyMcMuffinX | February 3rd 15
4.0 excellentblueparrot4 | February 2nd 15
4.5 superbhowdidwegethigh | January 31st 15
4.0 excellentExplosiveOranges | January 31st 15
3.5 greatMoltenBoron | January 29th 15
4.0 excellentcastlesfall | January 26th 15
4.5 superbFstrthnU | January 25th 15
3.0 goodFriday13th | January 25th 15
4.0 excellentNightragerz | January 24th 15
4.5 superbclockworkrat | January 23rd 15
3.5 greatBrian Meeth | January 23rd 15
3.5 greatimwithme | January 23rd 15
4.0 excellenthiyabootchie | January 23rd 15
3.5 greatalsid | January 22nd 15
4.0 excellentAdamKPeter | January 21st 15
4.0 excellentRumpelkombo | January 20th 15
3.5 greatSleepingGiant | January 18th 15
4.0 excellentZantera | January 18th 15
5.0 classicDathMasq | January 17th 15
3.5 greatNigtwig | January 17th 15
4.0 excellentTheFantasticDangler | January 16th 15
3.0 goodUlshad | January 16th 15
4.0 excellentianjulian | January 16th 15
3.0 goodMitch S. | January 15th 15
3.0 goodTheSpaceMan | January 14th 15
4.5 superbGriftGift | January 13th 15
3.5 greatStarsDie | January 12th 15
4.5 superbtrve | January 10th 15
5.0 classicpokemom | January 10th 15
4.0 excellentButteryBiscuitBass | January 9th 15
5.0 classicKomodog | January 8th 15
4.0 excellentInferis | January 8th 15
5.0 classicValtair | January 8th 15
5.0 classicTim00w | January 8th 15
4.0 excellentProle | January 8th 15
3.5 greatjearoslawve | January 8th 15
3.5 greatMiggl | January 6th 15
4.0 excellentpremmisseth | January 5th 15
4.0 excellentpeartnoy | January 3rd 15
4.5 superbblabony | January 2nd 15
4.0 excellentVeldin | January 2nd 15
4.0 excellentAdam | January 2nd 15
4.5 superbNickMinaj | January 1st 15
4.5 superbkpberry | December 31st 14
3.5 greatresident sputbirb with fancy hat | December 31st 14
3.0 goodTotengott | December 30th 14
5.0 classicNonApplicable | December 30th 14
3.5 greatxenocide. | December 30th 14
4.0 excellentThor | December 30th 14
4.0 excellentInsurrection | December 30th 14
4.5 superbtoomuchtestosterone | December 30th 14
4.5 superbtoutais | December 29th 14
4.5 superbDr7 | December 29th 14
4.5 superbauxilia | December 29th 14
3.0 goodchponge | December 28th 14
4.5 superbFortuneOfMan | December 28th 14
4.5 superbMythodea | December 27th 14
4.5 superbzombi666 | December 27th 14
4.5 superbcb123 | December 27th 14
4.0 excellentlukebeauch | December 26th 14
4.5 superbZeg | December 24th 14
4.5 superbKrimea | December 24th 14
5.0 classicSuperreallycool | December 24th 14
3.5 greatGreem | December 23rd 14
4.5 superbMKGaruda | December 22nd 14
4.5 superbLalka | December 22nd 14
5.0 classicTrampumpoolee | December 22nd 14
4.0 excellentBrabiz | December 21st 14
4.5 superbDeadwing42 | December 20th 14
5.0 classicPhilalethes | December 20th 14
5.0 classicRemedyForLove | December 20th 14
4.5 superbleycec | December 20th 14
5.0 classicamenra | December 19th 14
4.5 superbMasterJebbly | December 18th 14
4.5 superbFearThyEvil | December 18th 14
5.0 classicdanman777 | December 18th 14
4.0 excellentComeToDaddy | December 18th 14
4.0 excellentelephantREVOLUTION | December 18th 14
5.0 classicConsigliere | December 18th 14
3.5 greataltap1994 | December 17th 14
5.0 classicBorodziej | December 17th 14
5.0 classicdrossvirex | December 17th 14
3.5 greateloimayano | December 17th 14
4.5 superbThe1nOnlyDood | December 17th 14
3.5 greatThibs | December 17th 14
5.0 classicfordsoad | December 17th 14
4.0 excellentNorwichScene | December 17th 14
5.0 classicThisMemory | December 17th 14
3.5 greatdawija1017 | December 17th 14
4.5 superbgordodustin | December 17th 14
5.0 classicprototype | December 17th 14
4.5 superbSgtShock | December 17th 14
4.5 superbCeltics2448 | December 16th 14
4.0 excellenteaglefan1998 | December 16th 14
4.0 excellentprogsun | December 16th 14
4.5 superbwhoknewyou | December 16th 14
4.0 excellentHypochondria | December 16th 14
5.0 classicrgsquire | December 16th 14
3.5 greatInfiniteCake | December 16th 14
4.0 excellentPanzerchrist | December 16th 14
4.5 superbgurotesukku | December 16th 14
4.5 superbAnesthetize86 | December 16th 14
4.0 excellentKritikalMotion | December 16th 14
3.5 greatDunpeal | December 16th 14
4.5 superbJakeElPerro | December 16th 14
4.0 excellentAndress04 | December 16th 14
4.0 excellentYazz_Flute | December 16th 14
4.0 excellentZachTheMute | December 15th 14
4.0 excellentfr33convict | December 15th 14
4.0 excellentpachaim | December 15th 14
4.0 excellentDodenakker | December 15th 14
4.5 superbmortifierftw | December 15th 14
3.0 goodwasteofspace | December 14th 14
4.0 excellentGrantHenderson | December 14th 14
4.0 excellentignorethefashion | December 13th 14
4.5 superbVuvuzelaBzz | December 13th 14
3.5 greatVisionsFromTheDarkSide | December 13th 14
4.5 superbKrysis89 | December 13th 14
4.5 superbJackass | December 12th 14
4.5 superbArtVandelay2 | December 11th 14
4.0 excellentIgnimbrite | December 11th 14
4.5 superbKalopsia | December 11th 14
4.5 superbCrownOfMagnets | December 10th 14
4.5 superbNick Mongiardo | December 10th 14

Give Your Opinion on Living as Ghosts with Buildings as Teeth


You have to be logged in to rate this album Login | Create a Profile

STAFF & CONTRIBUTORS // CONTACT US

Bands: A B C D E F G H I J K L M N O P Q R S T U V W X Y Z


Site Copyright 2005-2023 Sputnikmusic.com
All Album Reviews Displayed With Permission of Authors | Terms of Use | Privacy Policy