Sonic Youth
TV Shit


2.0
poor

Review

by Zmev USER (64 Reviews)
October 2nd, 2006 | 11 replies


Release Date: 1993 | Tracklist

Review Summary: This Ep will rot your brains more than television. This Ep will rot your teeth more than not brushing them. Despite all this, its better than NYC Ghosts and Flowers.

When putting this 9 minute ep of seeming value and musical worth, the first thing that probably pops in your head or out of your mouth is "what the fuck is this"". Indeed it seems SY have tricked you, by not just straight up calling this one of the SYRs they have fooled you into thinking TV Shit is a cd that has musical value, catchy songs, and is about having good times.

Quite the contrary once it starts off with No II part one. A younger and angrier Thurston Moore takes the stage to deliver the introduction to this EP. "This song was written by the DC Youth Brigade 1981 its called No Part II, goes like this...NOOOOOO!!!!!!!!!!!". As stated this is not an original SY song, it is a cover of Youth Brigade's one second song, "No". Since expanding a one second song to 9 minutes takes some talent, each section will be reviewed separately, no paragraphs on mood or musicianship, because there just about isn't any.

Note: On this EP, SY are helped out by Yamatsuka Eye, leader and founder of Japanese noise rock band, the Boredoms. If you know what the Boredoms sound like this is pretty much it,

No II Part 1

The introduction to madness song, this contains the spoken part mentioned above, plus some loud noise. The noise in the background, representing instruments being played, is actually just the band freaking out completely on their instruments. It sounds sorta like guitars dipped in white noise, but not nearly as enjoyable as it sounds. After a short and merciful 51 seconds, the song ends and transcends to...

No II Part 2

The next song is a little more drawn out and expanded on than the first. It begins with a guitar filled background with some drums, overshadowing one of the members screaming "NOO!!!" into the microphone for about 15 seconds. The song ends, oddly, with a Johnny Cash sample of him singing a song with his wife, Me not being a big Cash fan I cannot identify the song, but the pleasantness of an artist actually trying ends too quickly leading to....

No II Part 3

This track blends into more of the technical structure that creates such flowing noise rock and...no, i can't hide it anymore. This track may be the best noise rock song, but as a song in general, it fails so hard. At this point you can tell the band is laughing at you for buying this, and even harder as you listen to it. There are some highlights though, some snazzy guitar playing blanket a screaming Thurston. Do I even have to tell you what word hes uttering" I thought not. Let's end this pain with....

No II Part 4

Another spoken live introduction, Thurston thanks the fans for coming and then announces the song as a Youth Brigade cover, and this song is basically No II Part 1, just somehow expanded to 3 minutes, and is louder. Featuring more mindless screaming and ear-breaking guitar noise, this track puts the EP to bed, and is usually the last track that is played before the disc is thrown away.

What a trip this CD is. The band brings you back to their roots but with even less construction in their "melodies" and a lot less thought put into the work. Unless you're an avid Sonic Youth fan (re: Eliminator) or unless you like noise rock very much, it might be best not to donate 9 minutes listening to this.

Oh yeah, and props to whoever changed the title to "Tv Poop"



Recent reviews by this author
Janet Jackson Rhythm Nation 1814DJ Shadow Bay Area EP
Butthole Surfers Rembrandt PussyhorseThe Chemical Brothers We Are the Night
Ween Friends65daysofstatic The Destruction of Small Ideas
user ratings (22)
Chart.
2.2
poor

Comments:Add a Comment 
Two-Headed Boy
October 2nd 2006


4527 Comments


Sounds....interesting....

Nice review BTW, this must be a pain to review.

Hatshepsut
October 2nd 2006


1997 Comments


Oh my I have this but have no interest in listening to it. Even moreso from the review..

Zmev
October 2nd 2006


983 Comments

Album Rating: 2.0 | Sound Off

I dunno bout that, its like one of those things you can listen to once just to be able to say youve listened to it. Not for novelty value though.

Two-Headed Boy
October 2nd 2006


4527 Comments


Haha just noticed the recomendations. Nice.

Serpento
October 2nd 2006


2351 Comments


This review made my day, as did the reccomendations. I never knew this side of Sonic Youth before...

Equus
October 2nd 2006


56 Comments


maybe you're blind in one eye?

Zmev
October 3rd 2006


983 Comments

Album Rating: 2.0 | Sound Off

Or perhaps hes just unfamilar with their earlier catalog.

AlienEater
October 4th 2006


716 Comments


I love the Boredoms and Sonic Youth, so I should probably get this.

wakeupdead
February 16th 2007


2228 Comments


Nice review, but you put No II (Part 3) twice on the tbt.

Zmev
February 18th 2007


983 Comments

Album Rating: 2.0 | Sound Off

Fixed.

SandwichBubble
May 3rd 2017


7797 Comments

Album Rating: 4.0

Imagine yourself 10 years in the future, where the last 2 ratings (including mine) for the SY/Yamatsuka collab EP are 4.0s. You've just crossed over into https://youtu.be/ny7uGEPgoXk?t=25s

Digging: Zu / Mats Gustafsson - How To Raise An Ox



You have to be logged in to post a comment. Login | Create a Profile





STAFF & CONTRIBUTORS // SITE FORUM // CONTACT US

Bands: A B C D E F G H I J K L M N O P Q R S T U V W X Y Z


Site Copyright 2005-2017 Sputnikmusic.com
All Album Reviews Displayed With Permission of Authors | Terms of Use | Privacy Policy