Steve Hackett and Steve Rothery
The Roaring Waves


4.0
excellent

Review

by e210013 USER (338 Reviews)
September 17th, 2026 | 9 replies


Release Date: 08/28/2026 | Tracklist

Review Summary: A very interesting release. And a very honest one.

“The Roaring Waves” is an album of Hackett & Rothery. The line up on the album is Steve Hackett, Steve Rothery, Riccardo Romano, Daniele Pomo and Leon Parr.


“The Roaring Waves” is a collaborative album by two influential names in the European prog scene, Steve Hackett and Steve Rothery. As we know, Hackett was the main guitarist of Genesis and Rothery is the guitarist of Marillion. As we also know, Marillion was the band most close to Genesis of all British prog bands that appeared in the 80’s. So, we can say that Rothery is, somehow, the heir of Hackett on guitars. So, we can not be surprised by this collaborative effort.

Although the initial idea emerged around 2015, “The Roaring Waves” took nearly a decade to be written and recorded. The sessions were split between the Racket Club (Marillion’s studio) and the home studios of both musicians. The strong connection between both solidified on stage when Rothery joined Hackett at the Royal Albert Hall in 2024 to play “Fly On A Windshield”, one of the most famous tracks of the album “The Lamb Lies Down On Broadway” by Genesis.

So, “The Roaring Waves” is the first instrumental collaborative project between two of the most iconic guitarists in the progressive rock. The album is a profoundly cinematic, atmospheric and a melodic work, entirely inspired by the power, mysteries and nuances of the sea, beautifully paced conversation between two master guitarists. Instead of a flashy “speed trial” or shred-fest competition, the album prioritizes compositional patience, atmospheric depth, and melodic trade-offs. Hackett’s angular, classical-tinged and experimental approach, merges seamlessly with Rothery’s emotional soaring sustain. Having decided to completely forgo vocals and lyrics, the album gives the listener a true complete imaginative freedom through textures that blend progressive rock, classical music, ambient and electronic textures.

“The Storm” is the dramatic opening of the album. It begins by placing the listener in the midst of a storm, with the guitars intertwining to create the tension and force of a storm at sea. This is a beautiful, wild and cinematic piece that delights the listener, a track that serves more as an introduction to the album than in a particularly loud announcement. “Sandsend” is a more restful and contemplative track, where the tension eases, evoking a sense of isolation, a cool beauty and serene atmospheres. It veers a measured rhythm, toward elegant and melancholic atmospheres reminiscent of Pink Floyd, letting the guitars literally sing in unison. At under five minutes, the track is correspondingly compact. “Red Dragon” is the shortest track on the album where Hackett introduces the sitar guitar to give the composition a mystical and an oriental sound. It brings a touch of world music to the otherwise rather watertight soundscape with folkloric influences, bagpipes and sitar sounds. This is a more playful and less polished piece than its predecessors. The title track “The Roaring Waves” is probably the most compelling moment on the album. It begins with a beautiful flourish of classical guitar by Hackett. It’s one of the album’s highlights, the real swell. Slowly, the swelling dynamics, guitars giving each other space, and precisely that blend of melancholy and pathos for both Steves, a real classic prog moment. “K-129” is one of the most experimental and intriguing tracks on the album. Electronic soundscapes and dark guitars create a very own feeling. Once again, this rhythmic framework is layered over the two guitarists in a largely improvisational style. It stands out paying homage to the “Kosmische Musik” and the Berlin School of the 70’s. It reminds me of “Gento”, by Bisocope of last year, the project of Rothery and Thorsten Quaeschning of Tangerine Dream. For me, it’s one of the strongest tracks on the album. “The Black Sea”, described by the authors as a dark adventure, was chosen as the lead single of the album. It’s one of the album’s great melancholic beauties. Rothery’s warm guitar meets Hackett’s finely crafted timbres. This is precisely where it becomes clear why this collaboration makes any sense at all. “Pacific Coast Highway” departs from the gray and icy atmosphere of the previous tracks, an unexpected track. Here, the music gains rhythm and movement with Hackett playing harmonica and slide guitar, evoking a high-speed car trip along the sunny California coast. It’s a lighthearted, road-movie-esque jam with plenty of vocals at the end of it.


Conclusion: “The Roaring Waves” is a dialogue between two musicians who respect and listen to each other, and who have acquired the wisdom of guitarists who have nothing left to prove. It’s, therefore, a mature, profound and extremely refined work. “The Roaring Waves” remains above all an album on which two guitarists thankfully dedicate themselves not to themselves, but to the respective piece and its shared concept. Hackett and Rothery harmonize superbly with each other, instead of getting lost in an endless competition for the more spectacular solo. Compared with the album “GTR” of Hackettt and Howe, this is a much better work. I know, those were the 80’s. But I don’t know if it’s an excuse.


Music was my first love.
John Miles (Rebel)



Recent reviews by this author
Marillion Script For A Jester's TearAnthony Phillips 1984
Tony Banks The FugitiveSteve Hackett Spectral Mornings
Steve Hackett The Tokyo TapesArea 1978 Gli dei se ne Vanno
user ratings (3)
3.8
excellent

Comments:Add a Comment 
e210013
September 17th 2026


6733 Comments

Album Rating: 4.0

When I knew that Steve Hackett and Steve Rothery were going to release a collaborative album, I became very enthusiastic. I had the hope that it could be a very interesting thing. And, mandatory, it came to my mind the project with Rothery and Thorsten Quaeschning of Tangerine Dream, "Gento" by Bisocope, released last year, which was great, despite being different projects. However, I have some suspicions because the project GTR with Hackett and Steve Howe, (only now I noticed that they're all Steves, lol), was a bit of a deception to me. Of course it was made in the 80's, the bad times to prog. Still, I kept some suspicions till I listened to this one. Thank God, I was wrong. This is an excellent work, very balanced and where we can see the share between both. Of course it isn't a masterpiece, but I think no one expected that, realistically. But this is a very honest work where we can see that both musicians share the music and respect with each other, neither seeking to outdo the other, on the contrary, complementing each other.

So, do me a favour. Give it a spin.



LouBreed
September 17th 2026


842 Comments


Great that you did a review for this album! I like that it leans more into post-rock and guitar ambient rather than going fully into seventies prog territory. In places, it reminds me of Jim Matheos guitar ambient project Tuesday The Sky (namely its first s/t album). In my opinion, when you do a sea-themed album the two main options are to either go all stormy or to apply a more atmospheric "ebb-and-flow" approach, and here the Steves chose the second option, even though the album is titled "The Roaring Waves." A great work, personalities and styles of both collaborators are expressed here very clearly and blend together extremely well

e210013
September 17th 2026


6733 Comments

Album Rating: 4.0

Thanks, Lou. Somehow, you're responsible for this review. It was you that asked for it.

Besides this is a great day for me in terms of prog, here on Sputnik. Two reviews about two great albums, yours about Arena and mine about both Steves. Nice.



LouBreed
September 17th 2026


842 Comments


Yep, I could have written a review myself, but I was hoping that you'd do it. You're right that my review for Gento is fine, but it was one of the hardest to write. With Arena it's easier, because I've been listening to that band since at least 2011, their albums are like old friends to me. Provisionally, there's going to be an Arena review every midweek until I cover the remainder of their discography, unless unfavorable life circumstances will prevent or discourage me from writing and publishing.

e210013
September 17th 2026


6733 Comments

Album Rating: 4.0

Nice. Go ahead, pal. I hope that unfavorable life circumstances from you or from your country willn't prevent you to do that.

LouBreed
September 17th 2026


842 Comments


As long as I'm alive and well, I will at least be reading your reviews and we'll be talking about prog some more (although you are mostly focused on Genesis -related releases, which are not my forte. I am fairly well-versed in Peter Gabriel and especially Steve Hackett body of work, and I've heard some of the most popular songs by Phil Killins of course, but that's about it).

Also, I hope someone from the mods will notice, there's a duplication of the artist page (my fault): https://www.sputnikmusic.com/bands/Hackett-and-Rothery/185687/ - this one is redundant and should be removed

e210013
September 17th 2026


6733 Comments

Album Rating: 4.0

I think it's better you say that to the staff of the site and ask them to delete the duplicate of it.

zakalwe
September 17th 2026


42557 Comments


Nice one yet again e.

I gave this a listen the other week and found it very enjoyable

e210013
September 17th 2026


6733 Comments

Album Rating: 4.0

Thanks, zak. This is really a very enjoyable album.



You have to be logged in to post a comment. Login | Create a Profile





STAFF & CONTRIBUTORS // CONTACT US

Bands: A B C D E F G H I J K L M N O P Q R S T U V W X Y Z


Site Copyright 2005-2023 Sputnikmusic.com
All Album Reviews Displayed With Permission of Authors | Terms of Use | Privacy Policy