The Guess Who
Greatest Hits



by Waterloo_Sunset USER (7 Reviews)
August 26th, 2006 | 9 replies

Release Date: 1999 | Tracklist

The Guess Who made their name in 1964 as the mysterious group that covered Johnny Kidd’s “Shakin’ All Over”. Originally called ‘Chad Allen and the Expressions’, Quality Records decided that by removing the name of the artist it would increase interest in the band. By hinting that the members were an amalgamation of artists from British invasion bands the ploy earned The Guess Who national fame.

This collection spans the numerous personnel switches from 1968 – 1974, and has been credited as the “clearest audio restoration” and most well produced collection of The Guess Who’s classic produced. It is actually extremely well produced considering the quality of the original recordings.

The Bachman Years –

The first six tracks of the collection date from the period in which Randy Bachman (later of Bachman - Turner Overdrive) was Lead guitarist. Bachman and Burton Cummings potent lyricism combined to create the ballad’s of These Eyes, Laughing, Undun and the heavier No Time and No Sugar Tonight/New Mother Nature. Cummings mellow keyboard styles set a great Jazz ambience for the first three tracks, and his vocals rarely receive the credit they deserve. In Undun Cummings vocals are particularly outstanding. Whereas Cummings steals all the plaudits from the first three tracks, Bachman’s lead guitar on No Time and No Sugar Tonight/New Mother Nature deserves a special mention. Combining great rock riffs to the smooth jazz vibes added an extra dimension to these tracks and provides the perfect sound to ‘mellow out’ too. The famous American Woman needs no descriptions; it was ironically the track which helped the band crack America. Initially started off as a jam session it illustrates each band member’s ability on their given instruments. If you haven’t heard the original song, it really is a must and a lot better than the Lenny Kravitz cover.

Winter/Leskiw era –

Once Bachman left, it was a tall order to pick a replacement, so in stepped Kurt Winters and Greg Leskiw. The following seven tracks depict the brief period of this lineup. Winters took up the lyrical void that was left by Bachman, and wrote Track 7 - Hand Me Down World as well as co-writing Rain Dance,Hang on to Your Life and Heartbroken Bopper. These tracks lost the Jazz essence were prominent in earlier tracks, but what Winter and indeed Leskiw brought to the band was an element of Blues Rock popular at that time. Comparisons can be drawn with Peter Green’s Fleetwood Mac sound. No track can illustrate that shift more than Cummings’ Share the Land. Winter’s solo’s in this song, Heartbroken Bopper, and Hang on to Your Life are nothing short of exceptional. Cummings’ vocals hit the usual high standards, and accompany the rock driven guitar riffs perfectly to form a formidable partnership. Albert Flasher and Rain Dance bring back Cummings keyboard as a central component of the songs, and are two rhythm and blues orientated tracks. My favourite track Heartbroken Bopper really is a masterpiece of a song. Starting off with some distorted feedback, before diving into yet more blues rock riffage, accompanied by Cummings gruff sounding vocals and a spellbinding Winters solo. It is the star of the collection.

Period of Mass Change –

1972 saw rhythm guitarist Leskiw leave the band along with Bassist Jim Kale, to be replaced with Donnie McDougall and Bill Wallace. The final four tracks with the exception of the final track come from this line up. Despite the few snippets of guitar soloing of Kurt Winters the protest song of Guns, Guns, Guns is fairly unremarkable. Cummings adds a good bit of a piano background, and despite the serious nature of the song against the Hunting of Canadian wildlife it is a fairly weak track. Follow Your Daughter Home is an interesting bit of experimentation the former Jazz/Rock, Blues-Rock band takes a stab at Reggae. Despite the potential pitfalls of this song, and slightly repetitive lyrical content it is a fairly upbeat and fun little number. Star Baby and Clap for the Wolfman are two more upbeat tracks the latter featuring legendary DJ Wolfman Jack, but lack the same dynamism of earlier tracks. The final song Dancin’ Fool includes Kurt Winter’s replacement Domenic Troiano on lead guitar. Cummings vocal range is once again is displayed after the quieter previous songs.

Overall, this is a must have for any Guess Who fan, or any fan of “Classic” Rock/Blues Rock. It contains all the big hits on one CD, that many other collections sadly cannot claim (many ignore the post-Bachman era for example). The production is solid, the clarity is crystal. All in all, it is a fun and enjoyable listen and a great introduction to a band that many have all but forgotten.

Recommended tracks:
Heartbroken Bopper
No Time
Share the land

Recent reviews by this author
Mother Love Bone Mother Love BoneNirvana Live! Tonight! Sold Out!!
Fleetwood Mac The Best of Peter Green's Fleetwood MacKISS The Very Best of Kiss
Buzzcocks Finest: Ever Fallen in LovePuddle of Mudd Come Clean
user ratings (11)

Comments:Add a Comment 
August 26th 2006


Very nice review, of one of Canada's best bands. I actually added this band to the site a couple months back, surprised they weren't here.

This has a lot of their best songs, most of which are on the firdst half.

Digging: Iron Chic - You Can't Stay Here

The Jungler
August 26th 2006


I've really only heard American Woman. I'm a classic rock noob.

August 26th 2006


Album Rating: 4.0

yeh i realized they werent on a few months ago, they really should be more well known esp over here (UK) everyones like The Guess Who???

John Paul Harrison
August 26th 2006


Nice review. No Sugar Tonight is a fantastic song.

The Guess Who validates Canada's existence as a country.

August 26th 2006


[quote=John Paul Harrison]The Guess Who validates Canada's existence as a country.[/quote]

I don't know why I still believe you ever will, but I rather thought this was your review.

Nice work, by the way.

August 26th 2006


Album Rating: 4.0

Thanks for those who gave the props, appreciated. Think tommorrow will do a Fleetwood Mac review stay tuned!

August 26th 2006


Album Rating: 4.0

Really cool review. I liked how you did it in sections like that.

I saw Randy Bachman a couple months ago, and he puts on a fantastic show, and tells all of the stories behind the songs as well.

August 28th 2006


Album Rating: 4.0

wow cool, seeing Bachman or Cummings in concert would be amazing... I'm not fussed which one, but if they put on a show together that be amazing. As for stories behind the songs... more bands should do that it well adds a new dimension to the songs when your listening to them

June 26th 2015


Album Rating: 3.5

undun is fucking fire

You have to be logged in to post a comment. Login | Create a Profile


Bands: A B C D E F G H I J K L M N O P Q R S T U V W X Y Z

Site Copyright 2005-2017
All Album Reviews Displayed With Permission of Authors | Terms of Use | Privacy Policy