Riverside
ID.Entity


3.5
great

Review

by Jeanfreddy Gutierrez USER (1 Reviews)
January 20th, 2023 | 8 replies


Release Date: 2023 | Tracklist

Review Summary: New neo-prog can breathe peacefully, there is a great hope

I was recently talking to a friend who asked me if I listen to music that wasn't rock or metal, and I told him about Björk, Latin rock, 90s electronica and even Rosal*a and Kali Uchis. He was a little disappointed because I couldn't name any neo-soul (except Alicia Keys) or pop (although I did say Justice), and I really have a hard time listening to music that doesn't focus on the instrumental, the musicality.

But I also told him that new progressive rock had a lot of these sensibilities, not just in choruses but sometimes in whole tracks. I thought of Sleep Token or even Leprous. And that's how I feel about this new Riverside album, which using influences from funk, electronic music, pop, enriches their progressive rock without taking the spotlight away from distorted guitars, bold rhythm patterns or intricate arrangements but, as Haken is also doing, adding sounds like wind instruments and 80's synth arrangements.

Riverside comes from Poland. Yes, Behemoth and Vader, pure black metal evilness, though for me also from Indukti's progressive metal, which I admire since 2015. And in this case we are again talking about progressive rock and a very innovative, refreshing and daring one, reminding me of Pain Of Salvation's latest works as well as some of Anathema and Katatonia's work, but instead of coming from dark places, having doom or gothic influences, I find this new album, ID.Entity of greater richness and diversity.

Riverside may sound light at times, but the guitars never stop playing, as I already said in a powerful and hard way, but also in combination with keyboards or with a bass that experiments with different colors, that commands, even leads. Steve Harris would like to have songs like that, that orbit so powerfully in the lower notes, but he would lack Flea's vision to achieve what is happening here, a return of the Poles to the adventure of what some have called neo-prog, what I was telling my friend, new sensibilities that are nourished by more and more different sources.

So in ID.Entity we find Hammond organs, rhythmic guitars, acoustic moments, emotional explosions that blow up bridges with drums and guitars, classic rock solos, psychedelia and again, some 80's pop, as heard in the opening Friend Or Foe? and in Self-Aware, where they also dare with some "white ska" a la Police.

It is also a sentimental album, with many moments of acoustic guitar and/or pianos, with whispered vocals, with some sadness and anguish, although it sounds contradictory to what I said at the beginning, but I also perceive joy, celebration or hope translated into more cheerful and fast songs, with enthusiasm.

Conceptually in an album of this time, in which the lyrics worry about the psychological consequences of the new digital identities, disinformation and post-truth in social networks, although it is not the strongest of the proposal.


user ratings (143)
3.5
great
other reviews of this album
Robert Garland STAFF (2.7)
Pearl-clutching at the fabric of the past....



Comments:Add a Comment 
Chippe
January 21st 2023


582 Comments


Nowhere near their first two albums. Still good though, with some fantastic moments as usual.

ksoflas
January 21st 2023


1511 Comments


Hearing it for the first time, so hyped!

TalonsOfFire
Emeritus
January 21st 2023


21029 Comments

Album Rating: 2.5

Why is it that the better the instrumentalists are in a band and more complex the music, the worse the lyrics and/or vocals have to be. I guess that's a law of life.

Trifolium
January 21st 2023


41141 Comments

Album Rating: 3.0

Hmmmm, will still listen but the single and Wasteland weren't my thing so I don't have high expectations. We'll see!

TheWatchman71
January 21st 2023


389 Comments

Album Rating: 3.0

I really wanted to finish this album and give it an easy 4 but there are just too may low points that really put a dent in my enjoyment of the album as a whole.

The biggest offender is The Place Where I Belong. I feels like it’s going for a similar funk feel as Steven Wilson’s Eminent Sleaze, and much like old SW – the lyrics here are truly awful, like really awful. Something else is off for me here as well, not sure if to describe it as the pacing, cadence or rhythm – but the vocals just sound awkward, like too many words are being forced into the lines. What is it with these prog groups when they try and say something insightful about the state of society, whether is social or political – the observations are expressed so crudely and cliched. The irony of the line “tell me something that doesn’t sound like you just finished high school” – because that’s exactly how the lyrics come across here. Web browsers, meditation apps, gender, race – it’s just all too trying, too obvious. And, finally – 13 minutes!! This should have been the central epic for the album but musically it just doesn’t give any kind of pay off, there is nothing building and then the final 4 minutes just finish with a nice and pleasant but ultimately unrewarding instrumental closedown. Tragic waste of 13 minutes in every way.

And, tell me what were they thinking with the beginning of Big Tech Brother – just so misplaced and worst of all the song is really good, but that intro just ruins everything. It’s easily my worst moment in Riverside’s discography. Some shitty, ironic, funny moment?? – just not needed.



TheWatchman71
January 21st 2023


389 Comments

Album Rating: 3.0

But as for the rest of the album:

I really enjoy the 80’s feel to Friend of Foe and it is intelligently used within the Riverside sound, and really adds another dimension to the sound. It works really well. I get an A-ha vibe which I have no issue with (they are one of my guilty pleasures – at least the first two albums anyway). Those sweeping synths and digital stabs really add to the atmosphere.

Landmine has a subtle Eastern Arabic kind of sound and that works fine for me. Not too obvious. But that robotic spoken word parts irritate the hell out of me.

Big Tech Brother, intro aside, starts with some weird keyboard horn type sound very reminiscent of ADHD but soon morphs into a classic Riverside heavy rocker. Such a great track – just delete the first 15 seconds!

Post-Truth continues with its very guitar-centric drive. Just Riverside doing what they do best. Same can be said of I’m Done with You – which really does feel like a lost track from ADHD with the organ parts.

I like the poppy, uplifting pace of Self-aware which is more in keeping with Love, Fear and the Time Machine, and even the “oh oh oh oh’s” don’t grate. In many ways the sound of it also sounds like it could have come from SONGS. But that’s only half the song as it slowly morphs into much darker, subtler textures and draws the album to a perfect end.



TheWatchman71
January 21st 2023


389 Comments

Album Rating: 3.0

So to draw this rambling to an end, there are so many hooks here into their past and not in any way derivative or just retreading old ground. Lots of additional elements here that work really well, and I think this is a vast improvement on Wasteland – and no doubt I will find peace with my misgivings to give this the 4 it deserves. In fact, replace Landmine Blast and The Place Where I Belong with the two instrumentals Age of Anger and Together Again – perfect!

Willie
Moderator
January 23rd 2023


20675 Comments

Album Rating: 3.3 | Sound Off

This is a nice return to form. Probably the best we could ask for from modern Riverside.



You have to be logged in to post a comment. Login | Create a Profile





STAFF & CONTRIBUTORS // CONTACT US

Bands: A B C D E F G H I J K L M N O P Q R S T U V W X Y Z


Site Copyright 2005-2023 Sputnikmusic.com
All Album Reviews Displayed With Permission of Authors | Terms of Use | Privacy Policy