by Shattered_Future USER (51 Reviews)
August 5th, 2006 | 7 replies

Release Date: 2001 | Tracklist

Many people don’t picture the Germans as a funny bunch. Call to mind, if you will, the stereotypical German: mustachioed, drunk, beefy, and rambling in the mother tongue that’s very harsh. Regardless, the Germans have managed to produce quite a few different bands over the years with varying degrees of success, from industrial legends Rammstein to power metal bands Galloglass and Edguy.

Edguy got their start around 1995, and have not slowed down since. Releasing album after album, they never got immensely successful, but they are still touring, writing, and causing general mayhem of all forms to this very day. Their latest album, Rocket Ride, came out just this year to much acclaim.

However, this review takes us back a few years, to one of Edguy’s legendary album releases: Mandrake.

Edguy - Mandrake

Released: November 27th, 2001on AFM Records

Tobias Sammet - Vocals
Jesn Ludwig - Guitars
Dirk Sauer - Guitars
Tobias “Eggi” Exxel - Bass
Felix Bohnke - Drums

Edguy is a power metal band at heart, but they aren’t the traditional kind. They manage to use more than just straight 16th notes. They call to mind almost a form of early era Helloween, with some rock music mixed in. There are some keyboards in this release, but they are kept to a minimum. Most of the music focuses on the 5 members.

Sammet is really the only member that stands out. He has a voice that you’ve heard thousands of times over if you listen to power metal, yet his voice has that factor that makes it instantly recognizeable as well. He writes very catchy vocal lines that you will have stuck in your head for days on end. With a mid to high ranged voice and great delivery, he is the heart and soul of the band as well, writing all of the music and lyrics on this album with occasional help.

And the rest of the band? Safe to say they won’t win “technical musician of the year” awards, but they are excellent. They work around their technical limitations and craft some excellent, catchy music with just enough interesting stuff going on to keep you hooked and not bored, which is not often the case with catchy music. There are a fair few solos in here, again, not extremely technical but still quite good.

One of the things I like about Edguy, though, is their ability to have some fun. I certainly know a fair few bands that can take a cue from them. They can have fun without seeming stupid or like a party band. For example, the song Save Us Now. It’s a catchy, fun song that you may not take as silly or funny. However, if you bother to analyze the lyrics, they’re all about someone named the “Highspeed Alien Drum Bunny” and his kidnapping of people to experiment on them with his drums and magic carrot.

Really, there is no way you can comment on that.

Now, out of the releases I’ve heard by Edguy, I do believe Mandrake is the best album they’ve released so far. It balances that perfect line between originality, catchiness, and fun, while still being serious. They include everything in here: some soft numbers, some heavy numbers, a 10 minute epic, and some shorter catchy songs. The band is at its peak here, with their style of fun and catchy yet still sort of complicated riffs, and Sammet’s voice keeps you hooked.

This is also a rather long album, with many of the songs being closer to or surpassing 5 minutes in length. I’ve always said, if you can write long songs while still managing to keep the listener hooked, it is a sign of a good writer.

Recommended Tracks:

Tears Of A Mandrake: The album opener, it’s a mini epic: over 7 minutes in length, showcasing some epic riffage and some interesting keyboard effects. Basically, this is what Edguy is all about.

Golden Dawn: Picking up the pace a bit, this one has some pounding double bass work and power metal trademark extra high vocals. Still, though, they keep it interesting and original throughout the 6 minutes.

All The Clowns: An upbeat, fun song, this one focuses more on catchiness than talent, but it’s still pretty cool. Extra props to Sammet for managing to include the phrase “Mr. Scary Face” in it. This was the single, if I’m not mistaken, and there’s a video for it somewhere.

Nailed To The Wheel: One of my personal favorites, it starts off very mellow. Some acoustic guitar, Sammet’s vocals, and not much else. About a minute in, the distortion kicks in, drums speed up, and we are launched headfirst into one of the heaviest songs Edguy has ever done. With some of the best solos on the album, lots of wah pedal, and chorus riffage that would make Jon Schaffer of Iced Earth proud, it is a force to be reckoned with. Don’t miss it.

The Pharaoh: I’ve noticed a trend in quite a few power metal bands; there is usually a song that carries two things with it: Egyptian lyrics and musical focus, and a long length, usually over 10 minutes. Edguy does not disappoint here, with a massive epic that will keep you entertained.

Save Us Now: Cheesy as all hell, with nonsensical lyrics and synths that could have come straight out of a porno movie, comic relief is to be had here. Eerily enough, the song is quite good. It’s quite catchy, there is some interesting guitar work, and the chorus has some really cool harmonized vocal lines.

Overall: If what you need is good, catchy, fun power metal, look no further than this release. It’s not completely original, or completely technical, but Edguy have hit a sweet spot, and you will find some of their more memorable tunes stuck in your head for a while.

Final Rating: 8.5/10

Recent reviews by this author
Norma Jean Polar SimilarSwallow the Sun Plague Of Butterflies
Jeff Loomis Zero Order PhaseMar De Grises Draining The Waterheart
Mono You Are ThereAlanis Morissette Flavors of Entanglement
user ratings (180)

Comments:Add a Comment 
August 5th 2006


Album Rating: 2.0

Pretty good review. Edguy is okay, I've heard Theatre of Salvation, I wasn't really blown away, but it was pretty good. I'll review it eventually.

This looks interesting, especially The Pharaoh. I'll look into it.

August 6th 2006


Album Rating: 4.0

Good review Mike.This Message Edited On 08.06.06

October 10th 2006


Well done, man. Pharaoh is probably my favorite Edguy tune. Great album, too.

October 30th 2006


Edguy do stand out as good at crafting catchy tunes. I saw them on tour with Into Eternity opening. The technical ability did not enter into it at all, Edguy was the headliner for a reason. They put on a great show. Mandrake is a stand out album. The production is good and the tunes are great. Nice review!

February 10th 2009


Album Rating: 4.0

Excellent album. I've always said that Edguy have the perfect amount of cheese, thoughtfulness, flash, of everything really. Great songwriting and intense vocals.

July 7th 2012


Album Rating: 4.0

Excellent review mate. Knowing Edguy's work for some years now everything u mention about the band is true and i support your views as well. This one along with Vain glory opera are my fav albums.

December 15th 2013


Album Rating: 4.5


You have to be logged in to post a comment. Login | Create a Profile


Bands: A B C D E F G H I J K L M N O P Q R S T U V W X Y Z

Site Copyright 2005-2019 Sputnikmusic.com
All Album Reviews Displayed With Permission of Authors | Terms of Use | Privacy Policy