Between the Buried and Me
Colors II


3.5
great

Review

by Brendan Schroer CONTRIBUTOR (184 Reviews)
September 2nd, 2021 | 32 replies


Release Date: 08/20/2021 | Tracklist

Review Summary: All the amazing chops and excellent riffs of the original, just without the same emotional weight and focus.

Colors II is a loaded album title if I’ve ever seen one. 14 years down the line, it seems our friendly neighborhood prog-tech-core-death-etc. band has seen fit to draw from the well of their breakthrough masterwork; and really, why shouldn’t they? Colors remains one of the most acclaimed metal albums of the 2000s, practically redefining what it meant to be a progressive metal band going forward. Between the Buried and Me’s penchant for creative musical set pieces and genre-bending craziness really hit a stride on the landmark record; however, as with any album that garners that much adoration, there will always be that lingering pressure to top it. But let’s be real here: 2021 Between the Buried and Me is quite different from 2007 Between the Buried and Me. So much has changed, whether that be the inclusion of even more off-the-wall avant-garde elements or the growing prominence of vocalist Tommy Giles as a keyboardist. But I think the reason for Colors II being a loaded title is fairly obvious; it’s a title intended to cause excitement for fans - especially longtime ones - but that could quickly turn into crushing disappointment if Colors’ level of quality isn’t at least somewhat met.

On a surface level, Colors II does seem to provide exactly what it should: a highly enjoyable followup to Colors that mirrors it stylistically. The same techy riffs, blazing solos, crazy genre experiments, atmospheric synth excursions, and juxtaposition of clean and growled vocals… they’re all still here. And if stuff like that is your criteria for loving the record, I can’t blame you. “Monochrome” is a pretty dead giveaway that there will be references to the original album, the song taking on a similar “piano intro to extreme metal” crescendo to “Foam Born A: The Backtrack” which opens Colors. On the other hand, there are a few experiments that really surprised me, as they likely wouldn’t have found a place on the original record at all; the hardcore punk elements of “Fix the Error” and random fife-driven folk breaks in “Never Seen/Future Shock” immediately come to mind. Meanwhile, you’ll find more familiar territory with songs such as the chugging extreme-yet-melodic approach of “The Double Helix of Extinction” or the “White Walls”-esque rolling drums and complex web of riffs that comprise closer “Human is Hell (Another One With Love)”.

The performances, as you’d expect at this point, are fantastic. The members really haven’t lost a beat since the original Colors in regards to playing such complex and technical material with grace and confidence. Paul Waggoner and Dustie Waring remain a formidable guitar duo, whether it be navigating the crazy rhythm parts of the Dream Theater-esque intro to “Prehistory” or the beautiful - and vaguely jazzy - chords found on “Stare Into the Abyss”. Waggoner is particularly noteworthy for some of the striking leads he pulls off on this record, especially in the fantastic… uh, Latin circus section(?) (that’s probably the best way I can describe it) at the end of “Revolution in Limbo”. And obviously Dan Briggs and Blake Richardson still bring the thunder on the low end of things. However, the member who deserves the most recognition for Colors II is definitely Tommy Giles. He’s often the member who garners the most criticism from both fans and detractors, but he sounds so much better here than he did on the original Colors. His growls have stayed largely the same, but you can tell his cleans have come a long way - both in technique and confidence behind the mic. Plus, on songs like “Prehistory” and “Never Seen/Future Shock” his way of hamming up the more theatrical bits is just so fun.

Unfortunately, there’s one thing holding Colors II back from the heights of its predecessor, and I think it’s a pretty big one. That being: the glue that holds everything together. The original Colors was unapologetic about having wild flights of fancy and not giving a fuck what direction the music was going, but there was always some centralized location the music could come back to. And that was usually in the form of a cathartic release, whether it be the beautiful “feed me fear” section of “Informal Gluttony” or the soaring Pachelbel-esque melody that rears its head twice on “Ants of the Sky”. Not only were these moments anthemic and memorable, but they were also a great way of ensuring the more technical and crushing sections didn’t kill the record’s focus. More importantly, the music would have simply become riff salad without these moments of restraint, and that’s where Colors II all too often hits a wall. 79 minutes is already a beefy album length to begin with, and there simply isn’t enough focus to maintain that runtime. This is particularly felt in “Human is Hell (Another One With Love)”, which just meanders on without much of a reason for being 15 damn minutes long. Even the pleasant soft section that builds up the song’s conclusion is just kinda… there. Sure, there are a few potentially anthemic moments on the record, such as the “monotonous drought” section from “Revolution in Limbo”, but the album really could have benefitted from more of these segments.

With all of that said, I think Colors II can be enjoyed more for its craftsmanship than as an emotional journey. The compositions and diverse arrangements are still a lot of fun and the performances are incredibly solid, but the album often comes off as a jumbled mess when compared to its predecessor; it doesn’t help that so many parts mirror that record as well, thus constantly inviting further comparison. But then again, that’s what happens when you brand it as a sequel, right? The callbacks were inevitable. However, given a lot of the amazing material that’s here, it’s just a shame that I don’t feel much of anything when listening to it like I did with the original Colors. Still, it’s worth a listen for its abundance of great riffs and impressive technical acumen, so don’t miss out on it if you’ve enjoyed Between the Buried and Me’s more recent work.



Recent reviews by this author
Dream Theater A View From The Top Of The WorldSteely Dan Everything Must Go
Myles Oliver ForcefieldSteely Dan Two Against Nature
Phoebe Bridgers Stranger in the AlpsLil Nas X Montero
user ratings (486)
3.9
excellent
other reviews of this album
Robert Garland STAFF (2.5)
I can't see, I can't see, I'm going blind...

Scheumke (4.5)
Reliving the heydays...

theblacklodge (3)
Pretty fancy....



Comments:Add a Comment 
DivergentThinking
Contributing Reviewer
September 2nd 2021


11720 Comments

Album Rating: 3.5 | Sound Off

Yeah, sorry to my European friends, but I'm sticking with the Colors spelling instead. lol

FabiusPictor202
September 2nd 2021


1978 Comments

Album Rating: 2.5

"Unfortunately, there’s one thing holding Colors II back from the heights of its predecessor, and I think it’s a pretty big one. That being: the glue that holds everything together."



[2]



the lack of unity or glue or cohesion or whatever you want to call it really started on Coma, then continued on Automata I and II, and is still quite prevalent on this release unfortunately, it's basically my biggest problem with them at this point in their careers, that and what feels like a complete lack of seriousness oh and bland takes on recycled lyrical themes about sOciEtY

Relinquished
September 2nd 2021


46996 Comments

Album Rating: 3.0

that glue is from rose tinted glasses

FabiusPictor202
September 2nd 2021


1978 Comments

Album Rating: 2.5

maybe, though it looks like you liked this even more than I did despite its glue lack

DivergentThinking
Contributing Reviewer
September 2nd 2021


11720 Comments

Album Rating: 3.5 | Sound Off

Considering I only started listening to BTBAM around 2016 or so, I wouldn't say my glasses are quite rose-tinted yet. Colors is genuinely one of my favorite prog metal albums, and no nostalgia or overplay plays into that :]

Parallels
September 3rd 2021


9623 Comments


"Yeah, sorry to my European friends, but I'm sticking with the Colors spelling instead"

It is the name of the album, after all.

Mind pos'd

Dewinged
Staff Reviewer
September 3rd 2021


26046 Comments


Good review man, you may want to check that summary again though:

" just without with same emotional weight and focus"

Digging: Blackwater Holylight - Silence/Motion

DivergentThinking
Contributing Reviewer
September 3rd 2021


11720 Comments

Album Rating: 3.5 | Sound Off

Oh shit, good catch! Thank you

FadedSun
September 3rd 2021


2794 Comments


I was around for the Colors release, and was listening probably the week it dropped. Obsessively so. This many years later, there's no way this was going to draw me back in. My music taste changed a lot over that time, and I'm not into bands like this much anymore. I gave it a shot, but I didn't dig it, so I won't even rate it.

Relinquished
September 3rd 2021


46996 Comments

Album Rating: 3.0

oof yea you joined early



you must remember rasputin ripping on colors back then

DivergentThinking
Contributing Reviewer
September 3rd 2021


11720 Comments

Album Rating: 3.5 | Sound Off

I hadn't even heard of BTBAM back in 2009 when I joined. Kinda surprising too, because I mostly hung out with a prog metal crowd at high school, but everyone was too busy jamming Dream Theater and Opeth. I didn't hear about the band until around 2015 or so, well after I left that friend circle

FabiusPictor202
September 3rd 2021


1978 Comments

Album Rating: 2.5

Only bitch ass mfs couldnt see the potential of colors back then

FabiusPictor202
September 3rd 2021


1978 Comments

Album Rating: 2.5

I saw them I think it was 08 they opened up for COB and were with BDM, those were good days when metal was still relevant

DivergentThinking
Contributing Reviewer
September 3rd 2021


11720 Comments

Album Rating: 3.5 | Sound Off

I saw COB with Devin Townsend, Septic Flesh, and Obscura back in 2011, and that was my very first show... really fun time, with the exception of the fact that I had food poisoning and threw up like crazy.



I still moshed though!

FabiusPictor202
September 3rd 2021


1978 Comments

Album Rating: 2.5

nice

FabiusPictor202
September 3rd 2021


1978 Comments

Album Rating: 2.5

my first show was 04 madly in anger with the world tour metallica with godsmack opening lmao they were awful

Gestapo
September 3rd 2021


1431 Comments


godsmack bops this band does not

CottonSalad
September 3rd 2021


662 Comments


Can we make this a first show thread?

Killswitch Engage, taste of chaos 2004 (lol)

DivergentThinking
Contributing Reviewer
September 3rd 2021


11720 Comments

Album Rating: 3.5 | Sound Off

Yeah, I wouldn't mind having this as the concert thread, lol

DivergentThinking
Contributing Reviewer
September 3rd 2021


11720 Comments

Album Rating: 3.5 | Sound Off

"my first show was 04 madly in anger with the world tour metallica with godsmack opening lmao they were awful"



Considering that was right after St. Anger, I'm not too surprised that they were bad at the time



You have to be logged in to post a comment. Login | Create a Profile





FAQ // STAFF & CONTRIBUTORS // SITE FORUM // CONTACT US

Bands: A B C D E F G H I J K L M N O P Q R S T U V W X Y Z


Site Copyright 2005-2019 Sputnikmusic.com
All Album Reviews Displayed With Permission of Authors | Terms of Use | Privacy Policy