">
 

Bedouin Soundclash
Sounding a Mosaic


3.5
great

Review

by francesfarmer USER (49 Reviews)
July 22nd, 2006 | 25 replies


Release Date: 2004 | Tracklist


In order to fortify a proper reggae album, one band followed a book of rules that apparently was written by God. Of course like all religions the followers tend to object to many commandments expected of them in order to attain eternal happiness. Whether it be happiness, a haven, or dub, you would do well to make sure all is well and your life is a streaming fountain of good. Bedouin Soundclash is an agnostic band. Not speaking for the members themselves, of course I don't know them personally but their approach at the genre it appears they try to enforce is slightly flawed. Whilst screwing together a solid album with the dub norm of catches, hooks, and raspy singers, Bedouin still falls to the ever inducing musical drug that is pop. They took it unintentionally and without knowing of it. So instead of a dub explosion, this is a reggae-pop combo with a side of french-fries. The food representing the good influence brought upon these boys (since they are good) by their reggae predescessors. You can obviously tell upon listening to this record, Bedouin Soundclash knows their s***. That part of them speaks openly on Sounding A Mosaic and clearly shows the guys have hit the dub books before. The members of the band successfully paint a picture in your mind of flowing streams, coasts, sunsets, street life at night and all that other good stuff. But I have seen but one full score worthy painting and this album is not it. Doesn't even come close. But you know what it does? It doesn't care. Bedouin Soundclash don't give a flying eff if I don't like their music because they want to play it and chill, enjoy their living and career and paint more pictures.

Stacked up on eachother are the recurring ideals that Bedouin follows on their sophmore album, like...

1. Vocals that catch you like a kung-fu fist to a fly.
2. Repetitive instrumental, since everyone listens to Jay.
3. Um...lets sing this line again, just in a different song, backwards.


Yes. Sounds generic? Well yes and no. I'll tell you that when listening to SAM expect no difference from sing and song. Jay likes to tilt the limelight twoards him alot and at the same time relys so much on his backing on certian songs. I mean, songs like 'Jeb Rand' and 'When The Night...' would sound perfectly fine if there were no instrumental whatsoever. Truf. But then we come to tracks like 'Gyasi Went Home' and 'Criminal', Jay steals your ears while playing guitar and cueing bass and drums at critical points to keep your attention. SAM does nothing short of and will probably be stuck in your CD player for a solid week. As the instruments warp into a beautiful beast with Jay's vocals, it is imperitive to remember that reggae is a longshot away from what Bedouin have created. Bob Marley or Peter Tosh had great voices, but they didn't steal the show. Bob Marley is nothing without his Wailers. Peter Tosh is nothing without his...uhm, marijuana. But yet both of those artists liked to share. Mr. Malinowski was absent a few times too many in kindergarten.

So if this band really is what I'm saying it is, then what similarities does it recognize from real pop music? Not sharing the spotlight is uncommon amongst redeemable pop bands. Not saying Bedouin isn't that. You can listen to this over and over and over. I guarentee, if you find any passing interest in this album then it seems quite the impossible to avoid it for a while, or forever. Good pop music doesn't get old and is always loaded. The barrel always delivers. Catchy? Yes. Short? Yes. Emotion provoking? ....Maaaaaybe. Perhaps Bedouin just didn't feel the feeling that Marley used to get? Can't 'ya smell that smell, Jay? Guess not. But not all pop is heart-wrenching ballads as much as it is general enjoyment. Classify them under that. Bedouin Soundclash doesn't make revolutionary music. They have texture and substance and a good sixteen tons of potential sitting up their sleeve, and great song-writing...but why am I speaking these words? Have you heard them before? Of course. Revolutions are an overthrow, not a rehash of the past. It doesn't seem as much as they're trying to ressurect the reggae dub scene, Bedouin was hip enough to score a spot on the Warped Tour. Now thats saying something when speaking of your music. But Don't get the wrong idea about Bedouin's work. It isn't an indie attempt closely and obviously laced with MTV. This album is a television dropout. Coverage is unlikely because for the most part people don't want to accept a sound like this, a personification of a genre with such great potential power that they choose to ignore it. Now, that would be a mortal sin when it comes to Soundclash.

Eager for attention the record flows through your ears, gets out of the water and hops its way up Catchy Hill to your mind. There aren't any means to describe this album that require negative assumption, or a declaration stating that it isn't fun. If a person tells you that they think Bedouin Soundclash is a boring act, please do the rest of the music world a favor and launch a blow directed at their face. "Boring" is if you yourself are bored, and can't enjoy the music to its full esteem. Walk into the canvas collection room expecting nothing other than what you want to hear, stuff that would both look and sound good live, and music that won't leave you deprived of the reggae genre despite its lacking in that department. Inside the music is a message that screams out happiness...its just laced with it. Happy feelings come with the record. Listening to it on the drive home from the store at which you bought it is one of the several activities that may trigger ultimate satisfaction among yourself. Either that or take a walk with it, show it to a significant other or read to it. Picture in your head what they may sound like live. You want to Sound a Mosaic, as the title suggest. Paint a picture in your mind's eye that satisfies your wants with the album. Then it'll work.

Now despite the earlier description, Bedouin may still not seem like your usual new sound. Reggae hasn't made any full-blown explosion in recent years amongst the modern youth, which is you most likely, and most likely, you haven't heard what it would sound like if sent through pop's repair line. If you'd like something new that isn't extremely experimental and forcing it's way into your brain then Bedouin Soundclash is for you. Purchase Sounding A Mosaic before you get into the less accessible of the two albums. The first is the excitable freshman who can sing his heart out and place himself in your heart with a ballad at the end. SAM is the moody fifteen year old with new ideas and experimentation galore, in his room with his friends. Don't act on impulse and get anything you see, SAM is your friend. The origin of the band is your little brother, with immense talent. You'll take him for a walk like your mom says after you finish eating in your room, listening to what you desire to hear. Oh, and after the painting is finished. It may take a while, and perhaps your little brother could help give you some ideas? He isn't that much better than you, SAM, y'know.

Credits:

Vocals/Guitars: Jay Malinowski
Bass - Eon Sinclair
Drums/Back Vocals: Pat Pengelly



Recent reviews by this author
Devin The Dude Landing GearThe Game LAX
Immortal Technique The 3rd Worldmaudlin of the Well Bath
Nick Drake Pink MoonLeftover Crack Fuсk World Trade
user ratings (136)
3.9
excellent
other reviews of this album
BuddahFist (5)
...

DesolationRow (4.5)
...



Comments:Add a Comment 
kno_kontrol
July 23rd 2006


448 Comments


I'll be honest, I couldnt read this review. Lame forced attempts at humor+beastly paragraphs=yawn.

This album is great, musicianship is pretty top notch, especially the drumming and the bass. I love the vocals too.

The Sludge
July 23rd 2006


2171 Comments


Saw them live, kind of bland if you ask me.

When the Night Feels Like My Song rawks though.

Zesty Mordant
July 23rd 2006


1196 Comments

Album Rating: 4.5

kick-ass album. "Living in Jungles", "Jeb Rand" and "Rude Boy Don't Cry" are my favorites.

Cygnus Inter Anates
July 23rd 2006


721 Comments


This went on for way longer than it should have, taking into consideration how it was written (boring).

francesfarmer
July 23rd 2006


1477 Comments


I don't recall trying to be funny when writing this...

francesfarmer
July 23rd 2006


1477 Comments


But I like french fries. Its not a funny thing, there shouldn't have been anything remotley humourous about this review...maybe I should stop writing after work.

Two-Headed Boy
July 23rd 2006


4527 Comments

Album Rating: 4.5

Really good review. These guys have grown on me a wee bit, but nothing extravagant still.

kno_kontrol
July 23rd 2006


448 Comments


dude, your review is brilliant now that I actually read it. I am merely a heathen compared to your writing ability.This Message Edited On 07.23.06

francesfarmer
July 23rd 2006


1477 Comments


At least I don't write generic trash. You sir don't have the right to call other people's reviews bland.

Cygnus Inter Anates
July 23rd 2006


721 Comments


And what makes you think that you have the right to tell someone that they can't have an opinion?

francesfarmer
July 23rd 2006


1477 Comments


I never really did. But the stuff that he writes is nothing I haven't read 5 thousand times before, so if he would like to insult somebody elses review I'd suggest that he first writes something actually good enough to enjoy. I'm not putting myself on a pedestal, but he really just isn't that good.

Cygnus Inter Anates
July 23rd 2006


721 Comments


[quote=francesfarmer]I never really did.[/quote] Yes you did, unless you somehow can't comprehend your own writing.

[quote=francesfarmer]But the stuff that he writes is nothing I haven't read 5 thousand times before, so if he would like to insult somebody elses review I'd suggest that he first writes something actually good enough to enjoy.[/quote] Yes because we all know that if you can't write a good review in someone elses opinion, you shouldn't really be voicing your opinion on a review because you aren't qualified. Totally. And how is "incredibly bland" and insult?


francesfarmer
July 23rd 2006


1477 Comments


Opinion can canceled out when your talking about writing basics, which is the rulebook he follows in his reviews. And if incredibly bland isn't an insult, I think your having trouble comprehending the writing.

Cygnus Inter Anates
July 23rd 2006


721 Comments


Sputnikmusic is a site that's whole premise is based around opinions, whether or not you agree with them or not. Saying that someones' opinion can be "canceled out" because of their writing abilities is ridiculous. Making you should take into consideration what people say about your review instead of shooting off a bunch of nonsense about them not having the right to criticize. Maybe you'll learn something.

And if someone came up to you on the streets and said "Sir, your writing is incredibly bland", would you take offense and do something? If so, that's also pretty ridiculous.

francesfarmer
July 23rd 2006


1477 Comments


Not somebodies opinion, but opinion becomes pointless when the subject shifts to throwing things around like 'your writing is incredibly bland'. That isn't constructive criticism and nobody will learn a thing from that. If your telling me to learn something, then what in hell do you expect me to learn? To not write bland reviews? That argument cancels itself out when it comes back to your statement on opinion. If somebody says your writing is bland, then that doesn't mean a thing but a petty insult. Now if somebody critiques you in a way to flag necessary improvement points then thats good, but something like that makes no sense to me and is by default a useless claim.

kno_kontrol
July 23rd 2006


448 Comments


d00d, I said liek i rered the review and it roxx soxx

francesfarmer
July 23rd 2006


1477 Comments


Generic doesn't mean to me the same thing as bland, Iluvatar. Generic is something you should take into consideration, read your reviews and discover that you've been writing what everybody else has. And improve upon it. Bland is just...blah. Its boring crap, doesn't matter how different or unique it is. Anything can be bland. It doesn't mean anything.

Cygnus Inter Anates
July 23rd 2006


721 Comments


Jah would not approve.

francesfarmer
July 23rd 2006


1477 Comments


This is reggae, huh...

francesfarmer
July 23rd 2006


1477 Comments


I'm a prick when it comes to that. Just ignore me.



You have to be logged in to post a comment. Login | Create a Profile





FAQ // STAFF & CONTRIBUTORS // SITE FORUM // CONTACT US

Bands: A B C D E F G H I J K L M N O P Q R S T U V W X Y Z


Site Copyright 2005-2019 Sputnikmusic.com
All Album Reviews Displayed With Permission of Authors | Terms of Use | Privacy Policy