Do Make Say Think
You, You're a History in Rust


5.0
classic

Review

by Transient USER (4 Reviews)
March 29th, 2021 | 13 replies


Release Date: 2007 | Tracklist

Review Summary: Feeling right feels good but being right is best

It’s very difficult for me to talk about this album objectively because it’s been one of my favourite albums for a long while now. Do Make Say Think are a Canadian post rock collective with members who have played in Broken Social Scene and supported Feist in the past. They are well known for their take on post rock that eschews the traditional ‘build up / crescendo’ formula that most are familiar with, in favour of songs that are more varied in their structure and composition.

You, You’re a History in Rust was released in 2007 and came after the release of Winter Hymn Country Hymn Secret Hymn, their first release to gain wider traction in music circles. I think what really sets this album apart for me is how alive the music sounds – I’m not sure what wizardry went into the recording of this album but you can almost hear the creaking of wood, a gentle breeze, and the rustling of trees outside that make this album sound so wonderfully lived in. The timbre of the instruments is delightfully warm and the music sounds incredibly rustic and simple, despite the actual song writing being relatively complex. Looking at the list of musicians for this album beyond the usual (guitars, drums, horns, woodwind) it’s notable that there’s a vibraphone player, someone playing the marimba, and someone credited with playing the musical saw (thanks Jimmy Anderson, whoever you are), and it’s unconventional instruments like this that contribute to the unique sound that Do Make Say Think produce. I’ve read some un-verifiable information that this album was recorded in a barn and although I’m not sure if it’s true, it’s very easy to believe that this is the case on listening.

All of these instruments and the beautiful mastering wouldn’t mean anything without the actual song-writing talent that’s on display on You, You’re a History in Rust, however. There are only two tracks with vocals and lyrics; ‘A With Living’ and ‘In Mind’, both breath-taking songs in their simplicity. The relatively scarcity of lyrics makes these two songs stand out and rightfully so, the lyrics are poignant without being trite or overbearing and they’re married with music that shimmers with the tender tones of the multitude of instruments mentioned above. That’s not to say the tracks without vocals aren’t similarly gorgeous however, from the subdued gentle acoustic picking of ‘A Tender History in Rust’ that is overlayed with whistling and gentle humming, to the remarkable ‘The Universe!’, a track that reels from one delirious, cymbal crashing high to another. The whole album meanders, never seeming like it’s going nowhere but also never in any rush to get where it’s going to eventually end up and it makes for an intimate experience.

You, You’re a History in Rust isn’t the most adventurous Do Make Say Think album (Winter Hymn) or even the one with the best individual songs (The Other Truths), but it’s the album that to me is so conceptually consistent that I can’t help but think of it as my favourite. It’s an album that truly breathes, that heaves with the effort of being created, that envelops a room with a multitude of textures that ebb and flow, and one that most importantly is absolutely filled to the brim with the kind of unrestrained joy that I can’t help but be seduced by.


user ratings (414)
4
excellent
other reviews of this album
br3ad_man EMERITUS (4.5)
Do Make Say Think better themselves yet again with the most richly diverse release of their career t...

thebhoy EMERITUS (4.5)
A great album from the innovative and genre-bending Canadian outfit....

Two-Headed Boy (4.5)
If, by the end of 2007, this isn't considered one of the year's best, then we're in for one hell of ...

shade (4)
A great Post-Rock Album, and unique for it's genre....



Comments:Add a Comment 
Transient
March 29th 2021


1480 Comments

Album Rating: 5.0

i've started writing reviews for my friends to recommend them music and thought i'd upload them here for posterity / in case anyone wanted to help me improve my writing



love this record with all of my heart

Digging: Kayo Dot - Choirs of the Eye

XXMurdaBeatzXX
March 29th 2021


55 Comments

Album Rating: 4.5

Pos I really enjoyed this rev. I need revisit this album, been a hot minute, but you capture the elements that make this album special

hel9000
Contributing Reviewer
March 29th 2021


1158 Comments

Album Rating: 5.0

excellent write up for a beautiful album, you've inspired me to bump my rating a bit. one of my top post rock releases/acts for sure.

johnnyblaze
March 29th 2021


3322 Comments

Album Rating: 5.0

nice review! one of the best post-rock albums ever. perfect from start to finish. Joyful.

hel9000
Contributing Reviewer
March 29th 2021


1158 Comments

Album Rating: 5.0

perfect from start to finish [2] yeah i had to throw this on after reading this review. i fucking love this album. A With Living is unbelievably gorgeous.

johnnyblaze
March 29th 2021


3322 Comments

Album Rating: 5.0

the vocal production on that song is incredible. it really is a special song, definitely in my top 10 dmst tunes.

Demon of the Fall
March 29th 2021


19071 Comments

Album Rating: 4.0

Fantastic review.

I’m really beginning to love this and Hymn. Unique band.

Digging: Unwound - Challenge For a Civilized Society

mynameischan
Emeritus
March 29th 2021


1790 Comments


First review in 9 years just to end it with a preposition. Welcome back : )

Transient
March 30th 2021


1480 Comments

Album Rating: 5.0

hah! thank you

zaruyache
March 31st 2021


23768 Comments

Album Rating: 3.5 | Sound Off

well damn gina

Nikkolae
March 31st 2021


5678 Comments

Album Rating: 4.5

DMST were the first band I ever checked out because sputnik said so and goddamit its enough to make a grown man cry.

Digging: Zao - The Crimson Corridor

hel9000
Contributing Reviewer
March 31st 2021


1158 Comments

Album Rating: 5.0

hard to believe this album came out 14 years ago

ResidentNihilist
March 31st 2021


2050 Comments


I always get these guys mixed up with Rachel's



You have to be logged in to post a comment. Login | Create a Profile





FAQ // STAFF & CONTRIBUTORS // SITE FORUM // CONTACT US

Bands: A B C D E F G H I J K L M N O P Q R S T U V W X Y Z


Site Copyright 2005-2019 Sputnikmusic.com
All Album Reviews Displayed With Permission of Authors | Terms of Use | Privacy Policy