A Circle Of Crows
A Circle Of Crows (DEMO)



by Robert Garland CONTRIBUTOR (345 Reviews)
January 5th, 2020 | 6 replies

Release Date: 12/20/2019 | Tracklist

Review Summary: Bar a few missteps, A Circle Of Crows has the potential to dawn a new era.

Some bands want to do everything. They’re typically so convinced in their ability to combine all the facets they love that they fail to focus ability into a single well-thought idea. A Circle Of Crows, hailing from Indiana (South Bend) fall into the trap mentioned above. For a six tracked demo, complete with both an intro and outro - there’s a lot going on. In introducing the demo the listener is greeted by the cawing of crows, ominous drone and subtle sweet synth; all the makings of an atmospheric, folk-drenched, black metal record. Despite some strong indications found in the intro, all this atmosphere is sucked away as ‘Będziemy Wolni’ riffs and snarls into being. Gang vocals, spoken word, blast beats, low growls all make an appearance before a token rock solo joins the fray, legato and sweep further detach the band’s music from the atmosphere of their contextual lyrical base. A concept built loosely on the act’s name-sake and specifics not conveyed well enough through music to even matter to the listener. A quick look at the band’s Bandcamp page gives details of a demo abstract in sounds of thrash, black, death and folk - but I fear there are too many cooks in this kitchen to make something of instant value.

I’m being largely critical of this little demo, but there’s a lot to be taken away from A Circle of Crows eponymous effort. These guys have a knack for songwriting (specifically in playing their instruments), it’s just staunched by equal measures of flamboyant and over-saturated ideas (overbearing guitar solos, Iron Maiden-esque leads, a million vocal nuances). Put simply, all their eggs are in one twenty-eight minute basket and rather than focusing on a particular set of styles or soundscapes, the group’s 2019 demo comes off insatiably “jack-of-all-trades” rather than the gateway to something truly worthwhile. To continue with my criticisms mentioned above I can’t help but notice all the vocal styles that pepper this little demo. Snarls, growls, shrieks, spoken word, audio excerpts and cleans, all with their own little variations where specific tracks demand.

Even the hair/speed metal stylings that dominate ‘To Cinder’ meld into a blackened thrash effort complete with gang vocals. A haphazard lead dominates the track, well above the band’s rhythm efforts, but nothing really comes together cohesively as ideas pull apart from each other rather than supporting the music’s central themes. The take away from here is that this is literally the bands first foray into releasing music. Overall, this demo is A Circle Of Crows dipping their toes in to test the temperature. When these guys nail down what type of sound(s) they want to focus on, they’ll actually have a full-length to meet critical esteem and maybe even make a name for themselves.

Recent reviews by this author
The Ocean Phanerozoic II: Mesozoic | CenozoicSteve Von Till No Wilderness Deep Enough
Defeated Sanity The Sanguinary ImpetusGaerea Limbo
Pyrrhon Abscess TimeLamb of God Lamb of God
user ratings (2)

Comments:Add a Comment 
Contributing Reviewer
January 5th 2020


Album Rating: 2.5


Show some love for a sput-bud project. Maybe a few streams/purchases on their Bandcamp can help achieve a follow up.

I reviewed this on request of Panzerchrist, he was forewarned that I'd give an honest opinion (one way or the other). Hopefully he doesn't see this as hostile, but constructive as the guys move towards making more music.

January 6th 2020


Thank you for the review, dude. I had a feeling that the multi-genre approach could spread the general sound out a bit too much, and that's certainly something we'll be working on moving forward. We know what we're good at and we're sharpening it up.

I really appreciate you taking the time to listen

Digging: Skeletal Remains - The Entombment of Chaos

Contributing Reviewer
January 6th 2020


Album Rating: 2.5

and that's certainly something we'll be working on moving forward.

Thanks for being a good sport about it. There's a lot to work with. All I can say is lean into your strengths and dabble with the other elements. There's no need to give every style a fair share in the light - rather use those 'bits' to flavour the core sound. Does this make sense?

January 6th 2020


Yeah I get your meaning. Just be more subtle about the genre additions, while focusing on a more central sound. That's certainly something we've discussed quite a bit since we finished these tracks. I think we needed to vary it as much as we did to really find that sound, though. Our bassist is a traditional punk enthusiast, our guitarist is more inclined to traditional heavy metal and I've always been more inline with prog, folk and orchestral compositions.

Long story short but we've found the middle ground now, as a result.

January 6th 2020


Good review Nocte, I had a chance to listen to this and agree with your points. It's a hard one for me to rate, because on one hand there is a lot of interesting and technically impressive parts throughout the demo, but the main hindrance, as you mentioned, is the "too much of everything" that gets in the way of the overall experience from start to finish. That being said, if these guys could tighten up their focus a bit, I think they have the potential to release something definitely worth listening to

Contributing Reviewer
January 9th 2020


Great review as usual Nocte. Love the wholesome talk itt

Digging: The Ocean - Phanerozoic II: Mesozoic | Cenozoic

You have to be logged in to post a comment. Login | Create a Profile


Bands: A B C D E F G H I J K L M N O P Q R S T U V W X Y Z

Site Copyright 2005-2019 Sputnikmusic.com
All Album Reviews Displayed With Permission of Authors | Terms of Use | Privacy Policy