The Dark Pool



by joshieboy USER (20 Reviews)
November 1st, 2019 | 10 replies

Release Date: 10/25/2019 | Tracklist

Review Summary: What's the point of life if we can't be together.

Melbourne, Australia's Thornhill are one of the most interesting bands to hit the metalcore scene in some time. A genre synonymous with bands striving to do the same sound but in better ways, the genre rightfully received criticism of its efforts in the last few years. The genre needed a fresh outlook on things, a fresh sound and new ideas to become a force again. Thornhill can now lay a claim to the brand new metalcore crown.

The band came together straight out of high school and it consists of Jacob Charlton on vocals, Ethan McCann and Matt Van Duppen on guitar, Nick Sjogren on bass and Ben Maida on drums. The band quickly formed an underground fanbase with 2 EP's, the success of the 2018 EP 'Butterfly' being a catalyst for the band to embark upon the crafting of their debut full length record. 'The Dark Pool' is a tremendous achievement and is sure to gain the band deserved recognition and fandom.

The album begins with the track 'Views From The Sun' and the band immediately establishes what their sound is all about with a groovy intro riff before the soaring voice of Jacob Charlton takes over, he then shows his screaming ability before seamlessly hopping back into his soaring high cleans voice which is a fundamental part of the band's sound. 'Nurture' and 'The Haze' follow the same path with interesting riffs, great vocals and fantastic drumming from Maida.

The guitar playing from Van Duppen and McCann is continually interesting and the progressive tendencies are prevalent throughout the record. The way they are able to mesh with the vocals by Charlton is superb and is one of the reasons why this album works so well. The atmosphere created in this record is also worthy of praise and the way in which everything is able to connect seamlessly within the songs. The interlude 'All The Light We Don't See' goes perfectly into album highlight 'Lily & The Moon' where vocalist Charlton sings of his love for his old dog Lily and his belief in the afterlife.

''Lily and the moon
I see you everywhere
If there’s another world
I will meet you there''

''Lily & The Moon'' is able to standout through its great lyrics, excellent vocal delivery and the riff that kicks in after the chorus which allows Van Duppen and McCann to showcase their talents.

Another member of the band worthy of praise is drummer Ben Maida. While his playing may sound simplistic, he is able to produce some interesting fills that never seem to be boring or out of place. Interlude ''All The Light We Don't See'' is a good place to anaylse his drumming as they are on full show with the vocals taking a back seat. The intro to 'The Haze' is also a good way to hear Maida's drumming with nice fast playing and his style of drumming fits the band to a tee.

The production of the record may come under criticism from some with Nick Sjogren's bass not as prevalent as it probably should be. The bridge of 'The Haze' is the best place to hear Sjogren's playing as he gets a little chance to show what he can do. Production and mixing of the record was mostly done by the band itself presumably to cut down the cost of making the record and they do an admirable job showcasing their talents.

A small criticism of this record is that l would have loved to have heard some more lows from vocalist Jacob Charlton. His one solitary low is on 'Coven' and the breakdown that accompanies that low is outstanding. 'Coven' also shows the band at its best with Charlton showing some versatility in his vocal delivery, a powerful riff and a good atmosphere.

The album closes on the fantastic finisher ''Where We Go When We Die'' which also harkens back to 'Lily & The Moon' as Charlton sings about the afterlife and what happens when we get to the other side.

''Well what’s the point of life?
If we can’t be together
I need you here with me
I need you to remember''

The lyrics are a strong aspect to this band focusing on the themes of afterlife, sickness, love and loss. and a strong lyrical talent is just another notch in the belt for this very promising young quintet and will be sure to take them further into the future. For a band as young as Thornhill are, they have been able to craft a superb record that has put them on the map as one of the fastest rising stars of the metalcore scene. Their debut is a solid foundation for years to come and l can't wait to see what's next for these talented young Aussies.

Recent reviews by this author
Wage War PressureMovements Feel Something
Silent Planet When the End BeganElder Brother Heavy Head
For the Fallen Dreams Heavy HeartsCity Lights The Way Things Should Be
user ratings (90)
other reviews of this album
Tranqyl (4.5)
Sweep me away to a dream....

Comments:Add a Comment 
November 1st 2019


Album Rating: 4.5 | Sound Off

This album just received a really good review, but l wanted to put my own thoughts down. Definitely recommend everyone checks this out. It's great and these guys are deserving of the praise they are getting for this.

Digging: Counterparts - Nothing Left to Love

November 1st 2019


Album Rating: 4.0

pretty cool

November 4th 2019


Album Rating: 5.0 | Sound Off

Nice, well-written review. I agree with wanting more lows from Charlton but I spoke with him and he told me it’s because he does inhale lows, so it’s not good for his voice. Unfortunate but understandable nonetheless!

November 4th 2019


Album Rating: 4.5 | Sound Off

Awesome record, can't decide on a favorite song.

Digging: Thornhill - The Dark Pool

November 5th 2019


Album Rating: 4.5 | Sound Off

Thanks fellas. Yeah l heard Jacob doesn't do a lot of lows anymore due to it hurting. Not the biggest deal as his cleans are amazing. Lily & The Moon is still my no.1 but there's honestly not a weak song on here

November 6th 2019


Beautiful! This and Counterparts could be tied for AOTY

November 6th 2019


Album Rating: 4.5 | Sound Off

Agreed ^

November 7th 2019


gud revew


November 7th 2019


Album Rating: 4.5 | Sound Off

Thanks m8

November 9th 2019


Album Rating: 4.0

Fantastic album. Vocals and atmosphere on this are absolutely incredible.

You have to be logged in to post a comment. Login | Create a Profile


Bands: A B C D E F G H I J K L M N O P Q R S T U V W X Y Z

Site Copyright 2005-2019
All Album Reviews Displayed With Permission of Authors | Terms of Use | Privacy Policy