Thirty Seconds to Mars
This Is War


4.6
superb

Review

by Simon STAFF
October 18th, 2019 | 51 replies


Release Date: 2009 | Tracklist

Review Summary: This is a call to arms, gather the soldiers.

As the years trickle by and the wrinkles begin to set in, I ponder over this past decade hoping that, if nothing else, with all the trials and tribulations that I’ve gone through, I’ve at least become a stronger, wiser and better person from these last ten years. It’s a long time, and it zips past so quickly that many ignorantly overlook how far they’ve come in that time. It changes you; events can make or break you as a person – your perception of life, understanding one’s self a little bit more, or reprioritising the things that really matter. The trigger of this life-reflection stems from realising This is War is ten years old in December, which in turn had me casting myself back to 2009 to assimilate where I actually was as a person, all those years ago. It’s powerful and emotional stuff, and every single corner of your life will change to some degree as a decade goes by, nothing more so than perception. So, I sit down here now, musing over the lofty importance of Thirty Seconds to Mars’ third studio album – a record that didn’t seem all that grand to me at the time – and bathe in a newly reformed appreciation for it like never before. You see, This is War is not a perfect album, I don’t even think it’s their best album, but it is an album with an unquantifiable importance; a true artistic statement that many musicians and artists don’t even get the chance to earnestly explore in their own lifetime.

The ten years that proceed This is War have seen a dramatic shift in the band’s own operations; a detriment that now sees the band brought down to a two-piece (just the Leto brothers at the helm), serving up hollow and echoic trend-following pop songs with a pseudo inspirational undertone. But one has to explore the history behind the band to truly understand how they got to this shallow state of ostensible songwriting. Ironically, it’s the very same reason I spent so many years wrestling with the emotional torment This is War pertained. This is undisputedly 30STM’s most experimental offering to date: the record doubles down on its radio-friendly craft and hones in on sharp, accessible hooks that understandably appeal to broader audiences. If 2005’s A Beautiful Lie set them up for stardom, This is War shot them into orbit. This album is filled with precursory millennial woes – a facet pop music would predominantly adopt in the 10s – Jared Leto’s trademark croons, and a concentrated reliance on electronics over guitar riffs. The pretentious artistry was beginning to latch on more overtly here as well – although nowhere near as gaudy and empty as with This is War’s successors. Indeed, all of these elements were a crux that prevented me from getting a fully immersive experience at the time, but with hindsight and an open understanding for This is War, these cons appear minute and innocent in comparison to modern-day’s popular music. Furthermore, these elements aren’t arbitrary and are heightened; contextualised within the base of every song here.

I mean, thematically the album is a timelessly inspiring attack on the music industry and displays a fiery, once determined, band refusing to go down without a fight. This is War’s tale centres around the crushing lawsuit they were going through with their [then] label, EMI Records; a lawsuit that saw the band being put under the slow cooker for $30 million over a contractual dispute. Cutting a long story short, Jared and co. were signed to an awful agreement that saw the label massively profiting from the band, this saw 30STM self-terminating the contract under a Californian Law loophole that stipulates no contract can be bound for more than seven years. However, the band still owed EMI a record, which subsequently resulted in the lawsuit they found themselves in. This stress-inducing and horrific situation became the creative fuel for This is War. As such, all of the influences being melded together here bring an intense message underpinned by its own melancholic anguish. The omnipresent millennial woes represent the fight against the corporate status quo – strength in numbers – while Leto’s lamenting croons on the likes of “Alibi” really drive the album’s message home.

Writing an album is a time-consuming and emotionally taxing process, but imagine being sued for that kind of money when you’re trying to create something like this. There’s an ominous spark buried at the core of This is War, and it’s that very spark which makes this album stand the test of time. With all the sugary pop moments being displayed on the surface, therein lies a wallowing anguish underneath it all – present throughout its entirety. It’s only by the last act of the album that we see the true face of its emotional state; a saddened section of the LP that unearths the cinematic exploration Leto painfully desires with future works, but masterfully executes here. There’s little moments of genius, like the muffled vocal outro to “Stranger In A Strange Land”, that distorts to the point where Jared himself sounds like he’s drowning, or the uncomfortable sonic frequencies that open “L490”, invading your ears with literal unease before cathartically shifting into a beautiful acoustic guitar passage and fading out with chants that put the album to a close. These moments are scattered throughout the album and represent the raw, emotional tribulations of which This is War is based on. And honestly, if you aren’t really paying attention to these key moments – listening only to the straightforward instrumental work and upbeat chants – then the point could easily slip past you. However, the fact that the album builds right up until the end to take its mask off is a testament to just how talented these guys can be.

After ten years of living with This is War, can I sit here and say I love or hate this record with clear-cut conviction? Immersing myself heavily in music this past ten years has certainly helped my appreciation for this record, but unintentionally realising I’ve shared some of the happiest and darkest times of my life with this album, it transcends merely enjoying it for what it is. I guess the bottom line is that this was a statement for Thirty Seconds to Mars; a life-driving purpose that pushed their creative worth to its pinnacle, but also pushed their inner self and will to life-changing degrees. Though I didn’t see it at the time, This is War is lightning in a bottle that represents the importance of art, creativity and sticking to your own convictions. It encompasses all of the darkness and beauty humanity is capable of, to the point where you won’t find many albums that can offer this same kind of narrative with the same honesty and intensity found within. The context of the album is perfectly preserved for future generations to follow, but with ten years added to my belt, I certainly appreciate its sonic exploration with admiration now. The balance of rock, pop, and electronic ambience and experimentation is exceptionally pieced together, and hearing the whole thing from start to finish paints a vibrant and elating journey. The best part about this tale is it concludes with a happy ending; 30STM won their war against all the odds, and garnered critical and financial success with this album. The thing you’ve got to ask yourself now is, what have they become since this album’s release? A The Dark Knight quote may diminish the worth of my point, but as Harvey Dent said, “You either die a hero, or live long enough to become a villain”.

FORMAT//EDITIONS: CD/DVD/̶/̶C̶D̶/̶/̶D̶I̶G̶I̶T̶A̶L̶/̶/̶V̶I̶N̶Y̶L̶

PACKAGING: Blue cover variant, 6-panel digi-pak.

SPECIAL EDITION BONUSES: The 2-disc package contains three bonus tracks, “Hurricane 2.0 ft. Kanye West”, and two BBC live tracks “Bad Romance” and “Stronger”. And there’s a DVD containing music videos, a short film and a making-of.

ALBUM STREAM//PURCHASE: https://www.amazon.co.uk/This-War-30-Seconds-Mars/dp/B0029LHW68



Recent reviews by this author
Ludvig Forssell Death StrandingMayhem Daemon
Saint Asonia Flawed DesignDesert Sessions Volumes 11 and 12
The Darkness Easter Is CancelledHellyeah Welcome Home
user ratings (1175)
3.1
good
other reviews of this album
1 of
  • Jared P. STAFF (3)
    While the album is overblown and pretentious, the final product does turn out to be pretty...

    Herbie Chrost (3.5)
    "Whatever you do don’t be afraid of the dark; cover your eyes, the devil’s inside."...

    Nick Mongiardo (3)
    Very overproduced and pretentious, but still enjoyable nonetheless....

    pizzamachine (4)
    "Ultimately, This Is War is a near perfect blend of old and new, even though the album is ...

  • DarcieRoy (5)
    This Is War has triumphed....

    TheStory (1.5)
    This is War seems to be a trumpeting call to arms to a war that comes so often we get sick...

    DixieNormous (2)
    Jared Leto's retaliation for being sued by his label....


Comments:Add a Comment 
DrGonzo1937
Staff Reviewer
October 18th 2019


15810 Comments

Album Rating: 4.6

bit of a retrospective for this. firstly, it's ten years old in December, secondly, this album has grown with massive importance to me over the years, and thirdly, my original review for this was one of the first ones i did on this site and it was embarrassing trash.

Digging: Desert Sessions - Volumes 11 and 12

TheNotrap
October 18th 2019


12307 Comments


Judging by the high rating, it must be among your favorite albums of the past decade. I think I've never heard anything from these guys.

Digging: Abigail Williams - Walk Beyond The Dark

Gyromania
October 18th 2019


28946 Comments


...No

Calc
Contributing Reviewer
October 18th 2019


16357 Comments


the guardians of ga'hoole would love to read this

Digging: Crimeapple - Viridi Panem

kris.
October 18th 2019


15506 Comments


yikes

Gyromania
October 18th 2019


28946 Comments


Go home Kris, you're drunk

Pikazilla
October 18th 2019


6489 Comments


Great review. Album has a ridiculous amount of filler.

JohnnyoftheWell
Contributing Reviewer
October 18th 2019


17561 Comments

Album Rating: 2.0

Eep it's been a decade. Horrible album, but this thoughtful review made me realise I heard this around the time I was starting to get into music, full stop. Strange...

Digging: Hakushi Hasegawa - Air Ni Ni

Pikazilla
October 18th 2019


6489 Comments


Whoa, you must be very young johnnyboi

PunchforPunch
October 18th 2019


7085 Comments


This is where they're trying too hard to emulate U2 especially with 'Kings and Queens' which sounds like a bad 'Joshua Tree' era ripoff.

Source
October 18th 2019


14445 Comments


i remember kings and queens being on the radio constantly. dark times

PunchforPunch
October 18th 2019


7085 Comments


lol yeah. Gotta give it to them though, the chorus to that song is indeed pretty massive.

JohnnyoftheWell
Contributing Reviewer
October 18th 2019


17561 Comments

Album Rating: 2.0

"Whoa, you must be very young johnnyboi"

Let's play a round of Guess How Underage That Kid Was When He Had His 30STM Phase



DeadBitchAlexis
October 18th 2019


2466 Comments

Album Rating: 2.0

Stranger In A Strange Land is actually pretty good. Rest of the album can fuck off though.



Actually had this on CD when I was in Elementary school but yeah this band hasnt held up very well. Their debut aint bad tho.

JohnnyoftheWell
Contributing Reviewer
October 18th 2019


17561 Comments

Album Rating: 2.0

Yeah agreed Lex, that song is definitely the highlight here

DrGonzo1937
Staff Reviewer
October 18th 2019


15810 Comments

Album Rating: 4.6

I’d just like to point out, I disliked this album massively when it first came out. It’s one of those persistent albums I always had around me though; now I’m at the point where I can fully see its potential.



And tbh, I hadn’t listened to it for about a year. It was only when I realised it was ten years old I gave it a spin and realised how much I liked it that I had to go back and re-review it. If only to commemorate its anniversary

dmathias52
October 18th 2019


1043 Comments

Album Rating: 2.5

I'd also like to join the "I was super young when this came out and thought it was the pinnacle of music" club

Digging: Keaton Henson - Six Lethargies

Aerisavion
October 18th 2019


1822 Comments

Album Rating: 3.0

Shit, this is an excellent review man.



Your musings on where you were when this album dropped 10 years ago brought back some serious good and bad nostalgia on the dumb ass person I used to be.

AngryJohnny
October 18th 2019


963 Comments

Album Rating: 3.5

Didn't expect this

I loved this when it came out, and I was 15. I'm sure there would be some nostalgic value there today, but I doubt it holds up

Bloon
Contributing Reviewer
October 18th 2019


3029 Comments


damaged

Digging: Jeff Rosenstock - Thanks, Sorry!



You have to be logged in to post a comment. Login | Create a Profile





FAQ // STAFF & CONTRIBUTORS // SITE FORUM // CONTACT US

Bands: A B C D E F G H I J K L M N O P Q R S T U V W X Y Z


Site Copyright 2005-2019 Sputnikmusic.com
All Album Reviews Displayed With Permission of Authors | Terms of Use | Privacy Policy