Holly Herndon
PROTO


4.5
superb

Review

by Gyromania USER (55 Reviews)
May 10th, 2019 | 226 replies


Release Date: 05/10/2019 | Tracklist

Review Summary: We are completely outside ourselves, and the world is completely inside us.

Artificial intelligence is a fascinating branch of computer science, albeit still in its infancy. In video games, business programs and most other applications, it’s clear that AI still has a long way to go. Chess engines are a sobering reminder of this: calculating anywhere between 70k and 80 million moves per second, they still draw and even sometimes lose games against the reigning World Chess Champion, Magnus Carlsen. That seems impossible, but indeed machines are only as good as their human-programmed algorithms. They still lack the intuitiveness and abstract nature of the human brain. There still exists no AI with the capacity for self-awareness or theory of mind. Yet their steadily growing presence in popular culture and reliance in everyday life is undeniable, and with the release of PROTO, Holly Herndon finds creative new ways to challenge the capabilities of AI.

What makes PROTO so interesting and unique is Spawn, an AI created by Herndon and her partner Mat Dryhurst. Spawn is two years old now and has been learning a lot in that time. This works in a similar way to a chess engine being fed several games from a database and improving with each subsequent performance. This makes for complete tedium in the chess world, producing cut-and-dry theory that’s boring to watch, but when applied to music, the effect is far more unpredictable and, well, frankly strange as hell. Spawn is the driving force behind this album, taking bits and pieces from choral recordings and fitting them into a pop aesthetic.

In a way, listening to PROTO is like hearing James Blake’s self-titled album for the first time. Despite PROTO being far more abstract, both illustrate how you can utilize machines to produce something intimately human-sounding, despite all the contradictions. The stark contrast, however, is in the application. James Blake’s approach was more of a man-meets-machine, where the machine itself had no creative input and acted more as a vehicle for Blake. On PROTO, the machine takes on a performance role, almost as if it has its own creative consciousness. This is especially apparent on “Godmother”, a track composed by Spawn using only the scraps of Herndon and Jlin. The result is a whirring of disembodied vocals and dark sound effects, seemingly incoherent but structured. It’s perplexing how well it works. Spawn’s presence is felt throughout the album, in songs like “Evening Shades”, a call-and-response track where the AI is trained to generate its rendition of the choral vocals. It can’t be known for sure just how much of the album’s creativity is owed to Spawn, but that ambiguity is part of its charm, allowing subsequent plays to coax out further speculation.

PROTO isn’t just a one-trick pony though. As Herndon herself has said, she isn’t trying to write herself out of the creative process, but rather have a symbiotic relationship with Spawn. Allowing Spawn to bring so many ideas to the table, Herndon and her collaborators were free to work on some of the loveliest choral arrangements in recent memory. She left a few of the live training sessions as short tracks on the album to help provide further insights to her creative process. These choral works are processed and repurposed to produce songs like “Frontier”, one of the album’s highlights. Starting like an uplifting, warped tribal version of an Eric Whitacre song, it eventually evolves from a layered hymn into a melodious pop song with an utterly triumphant conclusion. There’s so much to dissect in any given track, so many layers of voices, both human and inhuman, field recordings and other such samples. It’s a heady experience to say the least.

In an interview with Stereogum that provides important context on PROTO, Herndon elucidates her approach to creating music: “I have a really weird practice. I basically have a research-oriented art practice that manifests itself through pop albums. There’s always this fine balance of getting the concepts across but also just allowing the music to be music and just letting people enjoy it viscerally.”” That kind of description might turn some away. PROTO is certainly a challenging album, and some of these tracks come across as somewhat improvisational. But it has to be said that for how alien it appears, it’s still very tethered to the earth, rooted in tangible human emotions. It speaks to Herndon’s ideology that humans and machines can collaborate together to produce the best of both worlds. This is something we might see more and more in the future as technology continues to accelerate at a rapid rate, but for the time being, PROTO sounds ahead of its time.

Language is a voice. It’s like this shared cultural thing that we learn through mimicking one another. So that’s kind of what the process has been with Spawn. It’s this process of mimesis where I’m training her on my speech and she’s mimicking me and trying to make sense of what I’m doing, kind of like a baby. But that’s also how we as a culture develop language and this human intellectual project we have.



Recent reviews by this author
Coldplay X&YThe Cranberries No Need to Argue
Death Grips The Money StorePharmakon Bestial Burden
Sadistik Flowers For My FatherFoals Holy Fire
user ratings (110)
3.6
great
related reviews

Platform
recommended by reviewer
James Blake James Blake
M.I.A. Maya

Comments:Add a Comment 
Gyromania
May 10th 2019


29103 Comments

Album Rating: 4.5

Check out the Stereogum interview, it's great

Observer
Staff Reviewer
May 10th 2019


7363 Comments


fascinating. how long til the technological singularity are we?

great work gyro. I listened to eternal, and i dont think this is my deal. Certainly refreshing though

Digging: Handsome - Handsome

SowingSeason
Moderator
May 10th 2019


32879 Comments

Album Rating: 1.0 | Sound Off

Excellent work Gyro. I'm still digesting this, it's my first HH album. luci compared it to Sophie's latest and I kind of hear that just in the clashing dynamics. At the same time, this is definitely its own animal.

Digging: Abigail Williams - Walk Beyond The Dark

luci
May 10th 2019


12070 Comments


the big difference between the two is that herndon's sound isn't bubblegum/clubby, it's rooted in academia. I struggle to call this deconstructed club because it's far removed from any notion of the dancefloor.
I thought of introducing this to you as "imogen heap's final form." the track "fear, uncertanity, doubt" brought that to mind.



anatelier
May 10th 2019


2951 Comments

Album Rating: 3.5

enjoyed this a lot on a superficial level but will listen again with a better understanding of the concept and see how much it pops off

Gyromania
May 10th 2019


29103 Comments

Album Rating: 4.5

I hear just as much "Hide & Seek" as "Lindsfarne" in "Fear, Uncertainty, Doubt". And yeah agreed, this is pretty far from club/dance stuff. I can see people comparing it to Sophie though, both are very artsy and out-there, but closer analysis reveals them to be worlds apart aesthetically.



Ponton and Sowing - Thanks guys!

WatchItExplode
May 10th 2019


7375 Comments


Listening to Godmother certainly felt like hearing the birth pangs of something sentient.

Digging: Lunar Shadow - The Smokeless Fires

Observer
Staff Reviewer
May 10th 2019


7363 Comments


and props on writing another one, seems its been a while

Lord(e)Po)))ts
May 10th 2019


48489 Comments

Album Rating: 3.0

Dopeness

Digging: CHINAH - ANYONE

Sinternet
May 10th 2019


21120 Comments

Album Rating: 4.5

this month is shaping up to be awesome, i thnk this will displace big thief as my AOTY now

Digging: Vi Som Alskade Varandra Sa Mycket - Det Onda. Det Goda. Det Vackra. Det Fula.

Lord(e)Po)))ts
May 10th 2019


48489 Comments

Album Rating: 3.0

Wat is big thief

Gyromania
May 10th 2019


29103 Comments

Album Rating: 4.5

Ponton - Yeah I don't really write anymore, kind of lost the motivation. I remember there being a lot of dull albums out back when I got my contrib tag and I just didn't really feel like talking about them.

Sinternet
May 10th 2019


21120 Comments

Album Rating: 4.5

its like warm folky goodness, kinda reminiscent of those early 70s artists like linda perhacs/sibylle baier but more modern, you might dig, adrianne lenker has the voice of an angel

Lord(e)Po)))ts
May 10th 2019


48489 Comments

Album Rating: 3.0

I'll check

DoofDoof
May 10th 2019


6665 Comments

Album Rating: 3.0 | Sound Off

Good review, the mystery of just how much of the creativity is down to Spawn is intriguing me a lot

Digging: Kev Hopper - Corbyn Sceptic Club

luci
May 10th 2019


12070 Comments


everyone watch the music video for "eternal," it will become inseparable from how you view the track

Gyromania
May 10th 2019


29103 Comments

Album Rating: 4.5

not a fan of that video, but i do think the first like 20 seconds are cool. much prefer the video i saw for frontier

Dewinged
Contributing Reviewer
May 10th 2019


17246 Comments

Album Rating: 4.0

Great rev Gyro. This is definitely intriguing. Gotta check it out.

Digging: Common Holly - When I say to you Black Lightning

Chambered79
May 10th 2019


464 Comments


Alright Matt I'll check. The premise here sounds like what was going on with floral shoppe tho

ArsMoriendi
May 11th 2019


27946 Comments

Album Rating: 3.5

Wait AI helped make this? Interesting



Seems like a revolutionary concept



I know AI has "composed" music before, but this is the first time I see it being used to compose a commercial release rather than just machine learning experiments etc.

Digging: Shuggie Otis - Freedom Flight



You have to be logged in to post a comment. Login | Create a Profile





FAQ // STAFF & CONTRIBUTORS // SITE FORUM // CONTACT US

Bands: A B C D E F G H I J K L M N O P Q R S T U V W X Y Z


Site Copyright 2005-2019 Sputnikmusic.com
All Album Reviews Displayed With Permission of Authors | Terms of Use | Privacy Policy