The Beatles
Sgt. Pepper's Lonely Hearts Club Band



by TippingPoint USER (1 Reviews)
May 2nd, 2019 | 9 replies

Release Date: 1967 | Tracklist

Review Summary: I feel really bad for Amanda...

The Beatles – <i>Sgt. Pepper’s Lonely Hearts Club Band</i> just got a reissue two years prior which is extremely a fundamental tune in for any Beatles fan. Obviously, we couldn't kick back and appreciate this crossroads in popular music history:

Amanda Marcotte writes: “Against ‘Sgt. Pepper’: The Beatles classic made pop seem male, nerdy and ‘important’ – and that wasn’t a good thing.”

What are you doing? It's features like this that get me sort of discouraged, reasoning about how much guileful click bate has developed like cancer on the substance of standard news-casting. When I really perused this article, I started to believe that Amanda Marcotte is sufficiently insane to think what she's composed here is valid.

You're letting me know when they discharged <i>Sgt. Pepper’s Lonely Hearts Club Band</i> it was old white men who were super into the Beatles? Every one of the radicals and all the high school music audience members at the time, they were simply tossing their Beatles records out the window? I wager you thought they were considering, "No doubt, man, the Beatles, they're simply father rockers now." As if young ladies didn't keep on tuning in to the Beatles music at the time? As though there were no male Beatles fans like pre-<i>Rubber Soul</i>?

The nearest she comes to characterizing this horse crap is the point at which she fundamentally applies that the sort of music that has a bubblegum quality to it is innately female. Then, I could list many females who make dynamic, forceful, or loud music. That female craftsman may differ thus so their class of female fans. That is to say, the sheer presence of up-roaring young lady groups delegitimizes the vast majority of what you're stating. It doesn't mind the way that she never recognizes the incongruity that a great deal of the female music she records all through this piece is transcendently composed, performed, and delivered by men.

She cites that men later went on to strive for disco and proceeded hope for much that came after:

“But disco is also the backbone of every prestigious musical form that was invented after it. Hip-hop is built on disco samples. All that electronic dance music (EDM) that white dudes love these days. Ripping off disco. EDM in its various forms can be kind of dumb and bro-ish or intricate and nerdy. But it’s largely seen as masculine, and therefore is far more respectable than when it was called disco, and its audience consisted of ladies or gay guys who enjoyed dressing up and having fun on the dance floor.”

At the point when in actuality land, Amanda, individuals became ill of disco since it achieved a similar pinnacle of social immersion that a lot of melodic developments did before disco.

She acts like disco was the initiation of something, or the adolescents are simply by one way or another as the early adopters and on top of things. Disco was particularly aroused by the funk and soul that went before it. That is to say, the gatherings of people of those sorts are guys and exceptionally female as well, yet generally extremely male. That is to say, a gigantic impact for Michael Jackson was James "It's a man's world" Brown. Amanda goes on to rate the record as a B-plus, for some reason, quoting:

“…closing track, ‘A Day in the Life’. Some of it, like ‘She’s Leaving Home’, is forgettable. It’s a B-plus record. It’s no ‘Dare’ by Human League, that’s for sure.”

That is to say, that is fine, that is her supposition, and I don't believe it's the Beatles best either. At that point, she undermines her own supposition by conceding that due to the manner in which she sees the collection socially, she's continually going to have some sort of issue or inclination against it. At long last she proclaims:

“But part of me will always begrudge the record its reputation, because it helped lead to a world where certain kinds of pop music were treated as inferior, for decades, just because its fan base was mostly people who looked like me.”

You spent nearly this whole piece endeavoring to tear down music audience members and artists who look like me…

user ratings (4460)
other reviews of this album
1 of

Comments:Add a Comment 
May 2nd 2019


delete this

May 2nd 2019


Album Rating: 4.5

Bro you just posted cringe

Digging: Yellow Swans - At All Ends

Staff Reviewer
May 2nd 2019


Album Rating: 4.5

this is probably dumb but Amanda Marcotte has to be one of my least favorite twitter users ever. So painful

May 2nd 2019


Album Rating: 3.5

delete this

May 2nd 2019


Album Rating: 5.0

Congrats you wrote a review of the article that was worse than the article itself

May 3rd 2019


Album Rating: 4.0

The fuck did I just read

May 3rd 2019


Album Rating: 5.0

hahahaha what is this

Digging: The Bunny The Bear - Afterglow

May 3rd 2019



May 3rd 2019


What is this, really? Why you lose your time with someone that only can see her point of view? Why you wrote this? This isn't a review, really. Here we should must be writting and discussing about of one of the best and most important albums ever. So, it was a pity, really.

You have to be logged in to post a comment. Login | Create a Profile


Bands: A B C D E F G H I J K L M N O P Q R S T U V W X Y Z

Site Copyright 2005-2019
All Album Reviews Displayed With Permission of Authors | Terms of Use | Privacy Policy