Mike Shinoda
Post Traumatic


3.5
great

Review

by Simon.K CONTRIBUTOR (203 Reviews)
June 15th, 2018 | 83 replies


Release Date: 2018 | Tracklist

Review Summary: Words as weapons.

It’s hard to avoid being sucked into a circus of themes outside of an album when you know they are being used as the bricks and mortar for it. You can’t quite judge something at face value anymore when you’ve been exposed to the heavy subject matter, just look at David Bowie’s swansong; after his subsequent death a week after Blackstar’s release it was speculated to be a brave acceptance of death, facing it head on in a dazzling spectacle before checking out into the spiritual realm. As time drew on it was revealed Bowie had actually planned on making a follow up, and wasn’t quite the embrace many theorised, but in that window of conjectures, many – including myself – had romanticised Bowie as being the larger than life character he’d always been, taking humanity’s biggest question/fear by the horns and smiling at it with his most personal final chapter.

Basically, what I’m trying to say is going into any album with a weighty backstory can have a profound effect on the way you digest and enjoy the music – sometimes to the point where it makes you ignore the obvious flaws within a record. A lot of this is applicable to Mike Shinoda’s solo debut, Post Traumatic. Contextualised by its mantra of devastatingly abrupt loss, trying to assimilate and heal wounds that come from such tragic events, Mike focuses his themes on a contrast of intimately raw truths and the support that comes from them. This is the focal point for Post Traumatic and its frail demeanour is both sentimental and empowering, but the results can be outright heartbreaking at times. Of course, I have to admit I wasn’t entirely convinced by this project when the appetising EP came out in January. I was affected by the emotional subject matter – absolutely no qualms there – but some of the contemporary pop-rap choices left a jarring contrast for me to completely immerse myself in it. The basic premise for these tunes is set around poignant instrumentation; depressed piano melodies, cold electronic ambience and Mike’s pained vocal performances. The emitted feeling for this style represents his doubt, self-reflection and mourning perfectly, and when it sticks to this it feels completely organic and well suited to the concept of the record. Unfortunately, especially on tracks like “Place to Start”, there’s an injection of trap elements that causes a shifty tonal imbalance, one which ends up putting a dampener on the overall vibe, souring the sounds to the point of becoming a contrivance. Mike’s always been an open-minded artist, The Rising Tied says as much, but this niggle accumulated into an excellent EP watering itself down to a good one.

Hearing the complete album, my opinion remains largely undeterred. This is a solid pop-rap record that is as enjoyable as it is frustrating. Predictably, the strongest aspect comes from its lyrics and concept. Written as a therapy session of sorts for Mike himself and Linkin Park fans, this is a record made in Chester’s memory. Post Traumatic is designed around the five common emotional states: grief, denial, anger, bargaining and acceptance. The record starts off sluggish, brooding and talks about the shellshock of the situation as the world around him slows down to a state of utter stillness. By the time we get to “Nothing Makes Sense Anymore” the tempo moves up a couple of notches; brighter electronics and a pivot toward infectious melody as Mike struggles to come to terms with what has been taken away from him, while “Promises I Can’t Keep” delves into Shinoda’s psyche, realising he doesn’t have the control he thought he had with his life, questioning if he’ll ever be the same person by the end of the ordeal. The record progresses this way right up to its closer “Can’t Hear You Now", where it ends on an optimistic note, affirming he has low spells but has suppressed the demons and has a firmer grasp and acceptance on what has happened. It’s a really cathartic and enjoyable peregrination, and though the music is a doubled-edged sword at times, it manages to capture Shinoda’s mental state well enough to make it a pretty unique experience.

The frustration here comes from the same flaws the EP had, which is questionable stylistic choices that thwart hidden potential. “I.O.U” has a really abrasive beat, a cool laid-back vocal execution and the support of some eerie keyboard notes, but Mike’s high-pitched “I owe YOU!” is frequent, extremely distracting and gets old fast; the Kendrick Lamar approached percussive instrumentation on “Make It Up As You Go” is a pleasant addition, but gets shafted by the irritating airy performance of K.Flay; and “About You” contains pumping drums, intricate electronic layers and sub-bass which holds a trove of excellence, but the auto-tuned vocal hook of "it’s all about you” is another beat-down which could have easily been avoided. I could go on as nearly every track suffers from a couple of asinine hiccups, but the truth of the matter is the music takes a backseat here; it’s not the central focus. Like the EP, the lyrics and vocal performances trump the hip, trendy influences found in the music and if you’re a fan of Linkin Park or Mike Shinoda’s work this is a record made just for you. This is an instrumentally average pop-rap album coated in a wonderfully thought out and heart-rending story about a man coping with the loss of one of his dearest friends and deserves a spin if only for curiosity’s sake.

GREAT.

FORMAT//EDITIONS: CD/̶/̶D̶I̶G̶I̶T̶A̶L̶/̶/̶V̶I̶N̶Y̶L̶/̶/̶A̶R̶T̶ ̶B̶O̶O̶K̶ ̶E̶D̶I̶T̶I̶O̶N̶

PACKAGING: Standard jewel case.

SPECIAL EDITION: N/A

ALBUM STREAM//PURCHASE: http://www.mikeshinoda.com/



Recent reviews by this author
Spaceslug Eye the TideScars on Broadway Dictator
Bury Tomorrow Black FlameGodflesh Streetcleaner
Guns N' Roses Appetite For Destruction: Remastered...Wombbath The Great Desolation
user ratings (96)
Chart.
3.1
good
other reviews of this album
DropTune (3)
A fond farewell to a friend....

related reviews

Post Traumatic EP


Comments:Add a Comment 
JimmyPopAli
June 15th 2018


155 Comments

Album Rating: 2.5 | Sound Off

Not a bad review, but you seem to be giving it those extra brownie points that everyone else is; that it's a dreadfully average album that's pushed over the top due to the obvious Chester influence.



Had he dropped this same album with a living Chester, I think it'd be getting a much more critical response.

YakNips
June 15th 2018


19169 Comments


Mike Shinoda...

Smike Dinoda...

Snike Delidah...

Snake Delilah.......

holy shit

SteakByrnes
June 15th 2018


12293 Comments


woah...

Digging: Night Verses - From the Gallery of Sleep

bloc
June 15th 2018


50869 Comments


I always liked this guy's rapping so I'll check this out of curiosity

Digging: Bury Tomorrow - Black Flame

SowingSeason
Moderator
June 15th 2018


27012 Comments

Album Rating: 3.5

it's good

Digging: Wild Pink - Yolk in the Fur

Darius
June 15th 2018


16302 Comments

Album Rating: 3.0

"Mike Shinoda...

Smike Dinoda...

Snike Delidah...

Snake Delilah.......

holy shit"



Mind = Blown

Digging: Loma Prieta - I.V.

Toondude10
June 15th 2018


12867 Comments

Album Rating: 3.5 | Sound Off

Lift Off and Running From My Shadow are pretty sweet tracks imo



I was kinda hoping this would leave more of an impact considering what's been going on in Mike's life for the past year. Still though this is a decent record for what it is.

Digging: Monuments - The Amanuensis

Toondude10
June 15th 2018


12867 Comments

Album Rating: 3.5 | Sound Off

Also that summary reminds me of that Seether song

Faraudo
June 15th 2018


2196 Comments

Album Rating: 4.0

Lift Off is ace, and Chino makes it even better.

DropTune
June 15th 2018


1197 Comments

Album Rating: 3.0

I'll be reviewing this soon. From this review, seems like it fits my expectations. Shinoda is trying to find his footing. His next album I hope will be stronger. I feel it should have been a lot more raw than it plays out. Bennington's loss is still looming.

IcelandRevel
June 15th 2018


844 Comments


M-m-m-miiiike Shinoda...
M-m-m-MIII, MIII, MIII, MIII, WOO

DrGonzo1937
Contributing Reviewer
June 16th 2018


14473 Comments

Album Rating: 3.5

@Jimmiypop



That's exactly what I'm getting at. The music really isn't anything to write home about, but the lyrics and concept are so well thought out it elevates the record. It's not a case of giving it brownie points because Chester died. I think you're missing the point a little; this album wouldn't be here if Chester was alive.

RadicalEd
June 16th 2018


9297 Comments

Album Rating: 1.5

I'm sorry but this was a physically exhausting listen for me.

Digging: Ryo Fukui - Mellow Dream

Beardog
June 16th 2018


1981 Comments


good review

Drummerboy123
June 16th 2018


3084 Comments


Mike's verse in Lift Off really reminds me of High Voltage. Great album, quite samey and a lot of the songs follow the same structure but it's a fun listen and there's a lot of catharsis bleeding through it.

LethalPaintball
June 16th 2018


984 Comments

Album Rating: 3.0

this album is too god damn long

Digging: Svalbard - It's Hard To Have Hope

DropTune
June 16th 2018


1197 Comments

Album Rating: 3.0

I finally got around to my review. I gotta agree with Paintball, the album's a bit long. I think it's fine overall. Feels like a 3.3 to me.

https://www.sputnikmusic.com/review/77352/Mike-Shinoda-Post-Traumatic/

SteakByrnes
June 16th 2018


12293 Comments


3.3 would round up to 3.5 tho

RaylanCrowder
June 16th 2018


66 Comments

Album Rating: 3.5

"Had he dropped this same album with a living Chester, I think it'd be getting a much more critical response."



What does this even mean? Lmao.



The only reason this album exists is cos Chester committed suicide

Digging: Arrowbridge - Sirius

TheLongShot
June 16th 2018


423 Comments


I see this album is already attracting the Blackstar-esque idiotic hot takes -- "OMG this album about someone's death is overrated because that person died!!"

Idk if it's any good or not but come on people



You have to be logged in to post a comment. Login | Create a Profile





STAFF & CONTRIBUTORS // SITE FORUM // CONTACT US

Bands: A B C D E F G H I J K L M N O P Q R S T U V W X Y Z


Site Copyright 2005-2017 Sputnikmusic.com
All Album Reviews Displayed With Permission of Authors | Terms of Use | Privacy Policy