Elliott Smith
XO


5.0
classic

Review

by DropTune USER (65 Reviews)
February 24th, 2018 | 16 replies


Release Date: 1998 | Tracklist

Review Summary: A story for another time, XO takes no time in giving its listener one of the most important musical masterpieces they'll ever hear.

What if I told you XO is the happiest album you’ll ever hear? Right now, without reading any further, would you believe me? I want readers to remember this question until the very end of this article. What we are about to discuss will be the most joyous conversation of your day. XO is a bright-eyed look at alcoholism, addiction, and childhood trauma. We examine a lifetime of bleak outcomes caused by decisions out of our control. Impulses of the absent mind explained through metaphors and similes orchestrated so sorrowful. Elliott Smith puts the effort into making sure he puts the “fun” in dysfunction for XO.

XO fundamentally follows Elliott Smith’s psychological observations of himself and others around him. Shifting perspectives allow listeners to observe the intimacy of the narrative Smith so impeccably penned. ‘Oh Well, Okay’ puts us in the point of view of a person trying to comfort a hurting subject, but they shut off. ‘Waltz #2’ has us analyze the life of another person throughout different portions of their life. ‘Everybody Cares, Everybody Understands’ presents an angsty portrayal of the grievance those trying to relate to you have. Elliott Smith went as far to say that XO is ‘more hostile’ than his previous records, but we know he’s just joking. These are happy songs.

With XO being the major label debut of Elliott Smith, fans already expect an updated version of Mister Misery’s usual style. XO has a contemporary vibe to it and carries a unique charm to its music. ‘Baby Britain’ borrows from the Beatles and gives a lighthearted jam to those who journey deep enough. ‘Waltz #1’ wraps us into its deliriousness with a haunting backdrop and intoxicating atmosphere. The hypnotic piano, eerie guitar and enigmatic vocals are sure to entice those who enjoy a darker Elliott Smith. ‘Amity’ throws another laid back jam into the track with a vintage ‘60’s style and a smooth solo.

Elliott Smith’s sentimental writing shows throughout the record. Juxtapositions are commonplace throughout the record. Most songs seem interconnected, like ‘Sweet Adeline’ for example. “There’s a kid a floor below me saying, “Brother, can you spare sunshine for a brother, Old Man Winter’s in the air,” makes a reference to “sunshine.” Sunshine is referenced numerous times, notably during ‘Everybody Cares, Everybody Understands.’ Elliott Smith tells his story in a meticulous format and makes the lyrics all the more important. Waltz #1 and #2 are some of my favorite songs off of the record. I especially appreciate the line, “Tell Mr. Man with impossible plans to just leave me alone in the place where I make no mistakes -- In the place where I have what it takes.”

‘Waltz #1’ rivals its sequel with, “every time the day darkens down and goes away, pictures open in my head of me and you.” The waltz spirals through the airwaves and begs you to dance with your demons. The song curates an atmosphere with a symphony of sorrow and a hook of hopelessness. ‘Oh Well, Okay’ is another hidden gem to appreciate off of this record. I would count it as one of the most vital songs featured. The mood and style are simply astonishing. “With the one I keep where it never fades in the safety of a pitch-black mind. An airless cell that blocks the day,” hits like a ton of bricks when the speaker describes the lengths he goes to repress the memories of the past.

XO is an underappreciated record that deserves more credit than given. Elliott Smith’s discography is close to flawless in many regards. XO is original, enticing, and mesmerizing to experience. Nearly 45 minutes feels like hours wasted away in a surreal environment of miraculous misery. Nothing feels useless or unnecessary throughout XO. All songs mesh together and aid in the overall trek. Remember earlier when I asked if you would believe me if I said XO is the happiest album you would hear today? It’s joyful isn’t it? Such horrendous happiness disguised in discouragement. I knew XO would be an important thing for us to discuss. Elliott Smith tries to teach us listeners to find the happiness through the haze, so why aren’t you smiling?

Standout Tracks
Waltz #1
Waltz #2
Oh Well, Okay
I Didn’t Understand
(Just listen to the album. They’re all good)



Recent reviews by this author
William Ryan Key VirtueSlipknot .5: The Gray Chapter
System of a Down ToxicityNine Inch Nails Bad Witch
Mike Shinoda Post TraumaticSenses Fail If There Is Light, It Will Find You
user ratings (1508)
4.3
superb
other reviews of this album
FlawedPerfection EMERITUS (5)
A brilliant work of art, Elliott Smith takes his music to a new level with enhanced studio productio...

NathanBeesley (5)
The songs on XO are gateways to new worlds: It is through their inherent poetry and the fragile whis...

KjD (5)
Catchy, emotional, and well-written, XO is a masterpiece....

cagedbutterfly (5)
Elliott blends rock with folk and crafts a masterpiece of an album...



Comments:Add a Comment 
WilliamJ
February 24th 2018


10 Comments

Album Rating: 4.5

Another good review for this great record

DropTune
February 24th 2018


1292 Comments

Album Rating: 4.5

Thanks Will, glad you enjoyed it.

Risodo
February 24th 2018


666 Comments

Album Rating: 5.0 | Sound Off

perfect

William21
February 24th 2018


873 Comments


DropTune reviews an album and it's not a mainstream rock/metal album

What sorcery is this

Soyn
February 24th 2018


25 Comments


I remember long walks just listening to this record, I'd never really listened to any Elliott Smith album all the way through before, except for maybe his self-titled, which I loved. I also remember the first time the closing track came on and just floored me. It's so raw, but it's also, like the entire album, wrapped in something so warm and homely it almost hurts to stop listening. Love it, and it's probably my favourite in his discography.

DropTune
February 25th 2018


1292 Comments

Album Rating: 4.5

Well 21, I don't always swim in the mainstream. I tend to dive a little deeper. I also reviewed "Heaven Adores You" not too long ago.

GmemberKills
February 25th 2018


4311 Comments

Album Rating: 4.0

i used to think this was easily his worst release (which still meant it was amazing), but now pretty much every Elliott album feels like a classic to me...



I think it all just depends on what album connects with you the most when it comes to picking favorites

DropTune
February 25th 2018


1292 Comments

Album Rating: 4.5

Even his worst is flawless. I don't think any of his albums were bad. They're all classics to me. I'll post more Elliott reviews down the road.

ExtinguishingTheSun
February 25th 2018


369 Comments

Album Rating: 4.0

I always rank Roman Candle last in my head but then I think about the songs on that album and I'm like oooooooooooo

Good review btw

Nikkolae
February 25th 2018


6605 Comments

Album Rating: 5.0

this is the first review i have read for this album and i wholeheartedly agree

DropTune
February 25th 2018


1292 Comments

Album Rating: 4.5

I appreciate the feedback. Elliott Smith reviews are always a joy to write. Check out my review of "Heaven Adores You" if you enjoyed this.

tommygun
February 25th 2018


27108 Comments

Album Rating: 5.0

pos nice review of a great album

tommygun
February 25th 2018


27108 Comments

Album Rating: 5.0

man when that piano kicks in on pitseleh @ 'but no-one deserves it' that is a moment

Ryus
February 25th 2018


36582 Comments

Album Rating: 3.5

pitseleh is one of my fav elliott tracks

unclereich
February 25th 2018


11991 Comments


God fogive me

DropTune
February 25th 2018


1292 Comments

Album Rating: 4.5

'Pitseleh' makes me wish I was able to finger-pick.



You have to be logged in to post a comment. Login | Create a Profile





STAFF & CONTRIBUTORS // CONTACT US

Bands: A B C D E F G H I J K L M N O P Q R S T U V W X Y Z


Site Copyright 2005-2023 Sputnikmusic.com
All Album Reviews Displayed With Permission of Authors | Terms of Use | Privacy Policy