Elliott Smith
Heaven Adores You



by DropTune USER (65 Reviews)
February 9th, 2018 | 9 replies

Release Date: 2016 | Tracklist

Review Summary: Haunting and heartbreaking, Heaven Adores You is a compilation of Elliott's work like you've never heard before.

To encompass the entirety of Elliott Smith’s career into an album is a bold move. Here lies an artist beloved by many and recognized by few; an artist who possesses raw talent, unique music, and a connection with fans unlike anyone before, passed before his prime. Heaven Adores You is more than a tribute—a celebration of the life of an artist who never saw the impact he made. The album is intended to be a journey through the era of Elliott Smith documenting his musical evolution until his untimely departure. Celebrating his career through music as well as film is a large project, and the album proves just that.

The album is meant just for Elliott fans. Heaven Adores You boasts a vast collection of tracks spanning across the entirety of his career. Numerous instrumentals display his signature finger-picking style as well as a few that play with electric guitars. The untitled instrumental tracks are little gems to say the least. They sound astonishing and fill the atmosphere with somber sounds only Elliott could orchestrate. The opening instrumental instantly places the image of Elliott sitting in a bar stool strumming his guitar into one’s mind, silently picking each note with conviction on a scale decorated with depression and mangled with misery.

‘Untitled Melancholy Song’ steps into a more modern format with a rhythm and lead section accompanied with overdriven guitars. The song has more of a bluesy vibe to it with bends and leads meshed into a grungy backdrop. The song is sure to please Elliott fans who long for a more modern style from Mister Misery. I also enjoy how the journey through Heaven Adores You takes us to his Heatmiser days. ‘Christian Brothers’ is very refreshing to hear among the others. It’s mellow vibe and messy drop half-way through is exceptional to complement Elliott’s musical stages.

Early and live versions of notable tracks are equally as impressive. ‘The Last Hour’ is somber, delicate, and sure to appease any hardcore Elliott fan. ‘Waltz #1’ demo is sure to haunt any listener with its endless spiral. Just hearing the lyrics, “Every hour I used to cope to make the repetition stop; what was I supposed to say,” will remind listeners of their first experience with XO. The acoustic version of ‘Son of Sam’ is sure to rival the original. Its deep chugging riff thumps through the ears as Elliott’s voice makes its grand entrance. The harmonica solo adds a whole new element to the song and serves as an intriguing listen for those who loved the original.

There’s something about ‘True Love’ that makes it my absolute favorite Elliott song. The opening riff is a slippery slope that sinks the listener into the most heartbreaking, soul-crushing, and sorrowful experience they will hear on this album. The song is agonizingly honest in a tale about drug addiction. “One day I got sick she played me a nasty old trick. Said, “I need cigarettes,” walked ‘round the block caught a cab,” is dauntingly captivating and is sung with such sentiment. The weeping guitar with a slight Spanish tone paints the canvas for this tale of woe in an atmosphere sure to make any Elliott fan breakdown.

“Take me up my Lord, take me up today. Take me out of this place, take me up with you today,” wrenches and twists as the song ends. ‘True Love’ is a song someone can feel. The lyrics are spoken in a way that perfectly displays the story before the eyes. I can almost see the rehab facility, the cab scene, and the honeymoon like a movie. There is no joy in this tale, however, just a garden of anguish for its listener.

Heaven Adores You is a breathtaking experience for Elliott fans to indulge. The decadent selection of tracks decorates facets of Elliott Smith throughout his short life. The instrumentals are a constant reminder of a voice we will never hear again. They’re like speech with no words as they paint the illusion of a silent reflection performing. The songs were selected with care and are a great celebration for Elliott fans to appreciate the life and career of a musician who was extraordinary. Elliott was just a man with his guitar who made a name for himself town by town, city by city, before defining one of the greatest films of a generation.

I wish other songs like “Taking a Fall,” “No Confidence Man,” or “Twilight” made the cut, but I’m more than happy with the songs we have. The ever present memory of an unsolved death haunts everyone who listens to this album. The closing lines, “see you underneath the willow tree,” are a kick to the gut. Elliott Smith wrote the book on misery—a twisted tale about a hero who saved the day but could not save himself.

Standout Tracks
True Love
Christian Brothers
Son of Sam (Acoustic)
The Last Hour [Early Version]
Everything Means Nothing to Me
Christian Brothers [Performed with Heatmiser]
Plainclothes Man
Waltz #1 (Demo)

Recent reviews by this author
William Ryan Key VirtueSlipknot .5: The Gray Chapter
System of a Down ToxicityNine Inch Nails Bad Witch
Mike Shinoda Post TraumaticSenses Fail If There Is Light, It Will Find You
user ratings (22)

Comments:Add a Comment 
February 8th 2018


Good job on the review, nice to see this get reviewed

February 9th 2018



February 9th 2018


Album Rating: 4.0

Thanks for the feedback! I enjoyed writing this review. Elliott Smith is one of my favorite musicians.

Contributing Reviewer
February 9th 2018


This is a great review.

You've made a lot of progress from where you were just a week(ish) ago! It strikes an excellent balance between comprehensive, but not overly detailed. It's casual and easy to read, but still very informative. It also really translates your love for his work, without coming off as fanboyish or overly biased.

Easy pos.

Digging: Lord Snow - SHADOWMARKS

February 9th 2018


Album Rating: 4.0

I really appreciated your critique on my early reviews. Thanks for all the help Spirit.

February 10th 2018


Album Rating: 3.5

nice review. I was initially very disappointed with this release, but in context it makes a perfect soundtrack.

I just wish they could've incorporated a few more unreleased tracks.

February 10th 2018


Album Rating: 4.0

Its hard for me to be disappointed with the record. Knowing the intention behind the release is what set my expectations. Most were thinking, "Finally, a bunch of unreleased tracks," but forget the movie aspect of it. The film incorporated these songs throughout its duration as well as a few tracks just for the album itself. I'm sure Elliott Smith's estate will drop a few more albums throughout the years, but Heaven Adores You is solely meant to celebrate the career and development of him as an artist rather than release a bunch of extra material.

February 11th 2018


Album Rating: 3.5

I pretty much agree completely. I picked this up on vinyl recently and it made me really appreciate this release. A lot of these tracks, especially the instrumental ones probably would've never even seen the light of day had it not been for this Documentary, in which they fit perfectly.

My want for more unreleased material is really a selfish desire, and not a slate against this release.

February 11th 2018


Album Rating: 4.0

I think every Elliott fan wants more material released. It's a little selfish, but we enjoy his music a lot. I'm mostly surprised "True Love" was never released. I easily see that song being a top 5 single. Most fans downgrade the album due to their disappointment with the film. The film adaption wasn't perfect, but again, the intention is what they ignore. The film celebrates his life rather than documenting it. It may have been disappointing in that sense, but this was a giant tribute project anyways. The album is hard to criticize sense its just a compilation of things. I can't dig into it aside from which tracks they chose. Though, this was a fun review and I enjoyed it.

You have to be logged in to post a comment. Login | Create a Profile


Bands: A B C D E F G H I J K L M N O P Q R S T U V W X Y Z

Site Copyright 2005-2017 Sputnikmusic.com
All Album Reviews Displayed With Permission of Authors | Terms of Use | Privacy Policy