Pickin' On
Green Day Blue Grass


3.5
great

Review

by The Sludge USER (26 Reviews)
June 11th, 2006 | 19 replies


Release Date: | Tracklist


I just love accidental chocolate goodness. Actually accidental music that accidentally ended up in my shopping cart and accidentally left Meijers with out anyone knowing. I never heard of a bluegrass tribute to the Californian punk band Green Day, although aware of the Pickin' On series. As I mentioned, it somehow ended up in my shopping cart as I was shopping for paintball equipment. After I walked out and loaded my vehicle, I noticed this disc was at the bottom of my cart. Being the dishonest curious little boy inside, I kept it to give it a listen.

The Pickin' On series usually consist of standard country artist, giving the bluegrass treatment to a somewhat of a greatest hits selection. Such selections include Willie Nelson, Gretchin Wilson, Nickel Creek, Garth Brooks. But with a little research, I ended up finding out that it wasn't just country artist picked on. Selections include U2, Pink Floyd, The Beatles, The White Stripes, Metallica etc... With even more research, I found out that there are over 100 albums got the bluegrass treatment. That may end up being excessive, but that cant deny the uniqueness of taking the challenge of Pickin' On Green Day.

In case you've been living with your head under the ground over the last 12 years, Green Day is a pop punk band from California who formed in 1988 by Billie Joe, Mike Dirnt, and John. After recording their first album, John left the band and was replaced with friend Tre Cool. After a local following on their release of Kerplunk in 1992, record executives jumped to sign them, but only Reprise snabbed them to record their enormously famous major label debut Dookie. Green Day enjoyed quite standard success and expanding on their sound through their career until the release of the comeback album of 2004 with American Idiot, expanding their fanbase, while losing loyal fans due to their over exposure and image change. Green Day's sound has been influenced by bands such as The Ramones, The Clash, The Who, and local ska heroes Operation Ivy.

All songs performed by Honeywagon and Cornbread Red.

The Good:

BANJO SOLOS!!!!!
Yes, there are banjo solo's, a freakin' lot of them. Even in places where it don"t seem to fit. In Basket Case (Dookie), there is one oddly placed small solo right after the first chorus, after the line "Am I just paranoid, or am I just stoned." Even though its odd, it fits to the song nicely. There is an even larger solo, approximately 40 seconds long in the middle, plucking their away around the verse and chorus. The cover itself is upbeat and complements the original quite well. Coming Clean (Dookie) has hefty solo's also. Quite possibly one of the most up tempo tracks on here, as banjo's and mandolin are plucking all over the place.

Its nice to see that most of the songs weren"t straight ports. When I Come Around (Dookie) was taken from a solid pop-punk song to a touching soft ballad. The music throughout the entire song is moving and the soft vocals adds loads of emotion to the song. It flows well, and it even to manage throwing in a soft banjo solo towards the end. Time Of Your Life (Nimrod) starts off similar to the Green Day version. After the first chorus hits, the music changes and becomes an up tempo jam fest.

The Blah:

I didn't want to call this the bad section, since there technically isn"t any 'bad' songs on here. Just some that just seemed uninspired. Extraordinary Girl (American Idiot) itself is an interesting selection, since it was one of the weaker tracks on American Idiot. Even there is one of those unique banjo solo's in the middle of the song, as a whole, the music just plained seem uninspired. Major cool points were lost, as the songs were automatically edited by the vocalist.
Quote:
Originally Posted by Nice Guys Finish Last
Tell me I'm insane, ohh I'm so happy I could cry.
Quote:
Originally Posted by American Idiot
Mind true America
Nice Guys Finish Last (Nimrod) was lacking overall. Sounded more like an Hawaiian ukelele than a banjo. The vocals on the Cornbread Red era sounds like a Faygo version of Rascal Flatts. The song selection for the most part is a good selection, but not choosing anything off of Insomniac (notably Brain Stew) or Longview (Dookie) while choosing tracks like Extraordinary Girl and Coming Clean is quite frankly are poor decisions. Although the overall music on here is actually bluegrass, but it isn"t traditional bluegrass. Bluegrass to me expresses emotion through the music. Without emotion, it just sounds like bluegrass influenced country music.

The Overall:

The overall production quality sounds pretty good, Coming from a completely unknown label, CMH.
The concept is completely original.
The banjo solo's rip any Slayer song a new one.
The cover for When I Come Around owns over the original. If that"s possible.
Time Of Your Life gives a nice uplifting face lift.

Edited by lyricist choice.
The music can sound uninspired.
The song selection is a bit weak, without Longview.
This Nice Guys Finish Last version was weak.

Its hard to recommend this to this to many people. Cause obviously its an acquired taste. I cant recommend this to fans of Green Day because the thought of banjo's can throw them away immediatly. Cant recommend this to any fans of bluegrass simply for the fact that I mentioned above about the lack of emotion. All I can do is recommend this to anyone that has an open mind to try something new.

Maybe I should give Fade To Bluegrass: A Tribute To Metallica a shot, and not steal it this time.

The Sludge's Thumb Ups:

When I Come Around
Time Of Your Life
Basketcase



Recent reviews by this author
Bon Jovi 100 Million Bon Jovi Fans Can't Be WrongThe Offspring Rise and Fall, Rage and Grace
New Found Glory From the Screen to Your Stereo Part IIRide Nowhere
Akon KonvictedAndrew W.K. The Wolf
user ratings (3)
Chart.
3.2
good
trending other albums

Utopia

Singularity

Dead Magic

Arca


Comments:Add a Comment 
The Sludge
June 11th 2006


2169 Comments

Album Rating: 3.5

I dont know, I just had fun with this review. After all its bluegrass.This Message Edited On 06.11.06

Honeymoon_Croon
June 11th 2006


297 Comments


Wow. First of all, great review.
Second of all, I must see this. Bluegrass Green Day? Sounds yummy

metallicaman8
June 11th 2006


4677 Comments


Superb review :thumb:
I'm definitely going to look into this.

711
June 11th 2006


1341 Comments


I saw this at my record store and I had no idea what it was... guess I may give it a listen now. The review made it sound great

masada
June 11th 2006


2733 Comments


Pickin' on Green Day isn't the artist name. This would most likely go in Various Artists.

Two-Headed Boy
June 11th 2006


4527 Comments


This review doesn't satisfy me, unfortunately. Maybe it's just my nit-picking taste, or the stupid album concept, but I don't know.

JohnXDoesn't
June 11th 2006


1393 Comments


Nice review. I reviewed the new various artist/David Lee Roth Van Halen bluegrass album a couple of days ago. Cornbread Red is one of the artist featured on that one. They also have Def Leppard, Linkin Park, Aerosmith, and Nickelback bluegrass stuff. It doesn't work all the time, but when it does I like it. I'm definitely going to check this out. I've reviewed 3 bluegrass/folk albums in the past month and have been surprised at how much I enjoy this music. A fourth is on the way soon.

The Sludge
June 11th 2006


2169 Comments

Album Rating: 3.5

Nice, I really think I'm gonna look forward to the Metallica one. There is also a Blink 182 that would sound interesting also.

stinkypoptart
June 12th 2006


1169 Comments


great review.

NEDM
June 12th 2006


1113 Comments


American Idiot - Cornbread Red

Cornbread Red! WTF! :lol:

The Sludge
June 13th 2006


2169 Comments

Album Rating: 3.5

Honeywagon pwns over Cornbread Red, I'm telling ya'll!

tonequest
June 17th 2006


1 Comments

Album Rating: 5.0

hey sludge,

thanks for reviewing our record. I'm Bryan Clark (of Honeywagon) - guitar, vox, and dobro. There is a funny story about that record and how "cornbread" got involved against our wishes.



I'll repost later with that info....



in the meantime I'd like to invite you to my website which also has some clips from our other CMH releases:



We've done a Blink 182 tribute and [my favorite] the rolling stones tribute called "paint it blue".



here's the link:

http://www.bryanclarkmusic.com



Cheers,

Bryan

The Sludge
June 19th 2006


2169 Comments

Album Rating: 3.5

Oh wow, I dont feel so confident with this review now that an artist of the cd I reviewed actually commented on it. Its an honor, and I will definatly look into other albums like this. Thanks for the feedback man, very much appreciated.

Activista anti-MTV
July 17th 2006


3151 Comments


Well Written? Yes

The Sludge
July 17th 2006


2169 Comments

Album Rating: 3.5

Giggity.



Thank you all!

Angmar
July 17th 2006


2688 Comments


Personally i hate these types of things im not much of a green day fan in the first place but blue grass tributes and string cortet tributes IMO suck.

The Sludge
July 17th 2006


2169 Comments

Album Rating: 3.5

Well you have to keep an open mind to this album. Otherwise you are going to pan it off as shitty.

The Sludge
April 7th 2007


2169 Comments

Album Rating: 3.5

Bumping this showcase some samples.



You have to be logged in to post a comment. Login | Create a Profile





STAFF & CONTRIBUTORS // SITE FORUM // CONTACT US

Bands: A B C D E F G H I J K L M N O P Q R S T U V W X Y Z


Site Copyright 2005-2017 Sputnikmusic.com
All Album Reviews Displayed With Permission of Authors | Terms of Use | Privacy Policy