Pain of Salvation
The Perfect Element, Part 1


5.0
classic

Review

by e210013 USER (251 Reviews)
August 8th, 2017 | 21 replies


Release Date: 2000 | Tracklist

Review Summary: The first part of two musical conceptual pieces around the childhood and adolescence. This is really the first magnum opus masterpiece released by the band.

“The Perfect Element, Part 1” is the third studio album of Pain Of Salvation and was released in 2000. The line up on the album is Daniel Gildenlöw, Kristoffer Gildenlöw, Johan Hallgren, Fredrik Hermansson and Johan Langell. The album had also the participation of Camila Andersson, Pettter Axelsson, Mihai Cucu, Gretel Gradén and Johnny Björk.


“The Perfect Element, Part 1” is the first part of two planned musical conceptual pieces around the childhood and adolescence. Its second conceptual part would be released in 2007, as their sixth studio album, not under the name of “The Perfect Element, Part 2”, but under the title “Scarsick”.

Their debut album “Entropia”, was favourably received by both, the media and fans of the genre. The material for their second album “One Hour By The Concrete Lake”, was composed amidst a difficult period that resulted in the amicable separation of guitarist Daniel Magdic and the band. Just prior to entering the studio, guitarist Johan Hallgren was drafted and tackled the impossible task of learning all his guitar parts in record time. “One Hour By The Concrete Lake” was described as being heavier and darker than its predecessor. The album reaped outstanding reviews once again and began to cement the band’s reputation as being an important, powerful new force on the progressive metal scene. Their third album, “The Perfect Element, Part 1”, balances between the hard and the delicate, the grungy and the powerful.

As usual with the band, this is another conceptual album, this time focused on the forming of the individual personality, particularly on the events that marked our childhood and adolescence and that will shape our personality forever, making us what we are today. The subject is a bit more focused on the social and educational aspects of the forming of the individual person from adolescence to adulthood. “The Perfect Element, Part 1” explores many themes within its context. It includes some and very different aspects such as child abuse (sexual and physical), sexuality, tragedy, drug abuse, love, pain, anger, loss (of live and innocence, among other things), shame, regret, despair and inner struggles. All these themes are dealt as a story that explores the live of two fictional persons, one male and one female (known in the lyrics as He and She), which are two broken and dysfunctional persons. As Daniel said, “The Perfect Element, Part 1” shouldn’t be seen as an autobiography or a true story of the band’s elements, despite some parts of the concept and its emotions are influenced by their lives. However, other parts are there because they only want to emphasize them.

Musically, the album has a great variety of musical styles, ranging throughout. It goes from the more aggressive style, to the softer and low parts that any Pain Of Salvation fan will come to expect of any of their albums. The song writing is absolutely incredible. Another element that works very well and adds something to the progressive style of the band is the continuous musical theme that runs throughout. The music is something you can relate to and feel the emotions expressed through the lyrics. The album is quite dark and at times very depressing. Every song represents a theme or an element representing the development of two people, (He and She), from childhood to adolescence. Another good thing about the album is its high level of consistency. The album is captivating from the first to its last track, almost equally, and it flows together as a symphony. It has got an intricate technique, very strong and with very efficient melodies when it comes to feelings, and where everything is just perfect. The music seems very simple, but where all the musicians, well analyzed separately, prove themselves to be very creative, technically skilled and very qualified, especially while considering the small details, and of course, watching all the arrangements, focusing on creativity. Vocal arrangements are perfectly clear, musical improvisations and arrangements are constant and quite creative, the solos are genially composed and finally the keyboard suits created the general ambience by the whole album.


Conclusion: On “The Perfect Element, Part 1” all songs are great, and even thinking this is a conceptual piece, you can listen to any song you want and still get the same effect, without having to listen to it in order. As with all Pain Of Salvation works, I recommend reading the lyrics while listening. It makes the experience much deeper. I love everything about this album, from the musicianship, the song writing, the lyrics and vocals, to the pacing of it. This is really a perfect album, where the songs flow and move gracefully from mood to mood, from crushing power to whispering atmosphere. The high standards of their two previous albums are moved even higher. The complexity of the music is wonderful. As with their other two works, the attention to details makes the music sweeping on a grand scale. The atmosphere against which the music paints its picture is detailed and richly textured. “The Perfect Element, Part 1” has a sound all its own, yet, it can be perfectly connected musically to Pain Of Salvation previous and subsequent releases.


Music was my first love.
John Miles (Rebel)



Recent reviews by this author
Finch (NL) Glory of the Inner ForceCamel Mirage
Carmen Dancing on a Cold WindDavid Bowie The Man Who Sold the World
Peter Baumann Romance 76Tangerine Dream Rubycon
user ratings (647)
4.3
superb
other reviews of this album
TheSpaceMan (4.5)
Many rewarding secrets unearth themselves the longer one stays tuned....

Luminol (4)
While outstripped by the intensity of later "Remedy Lane" and the emotional introspection ...

asheroth (4.5)
...



Comments:Add a Comment 
e210013
August 8th 2017


5143 Comments

Album Rating: 5.0

After some weeks of vacations, here I'm with some more reviews, this time with prog metal genre and returning to one of my favourite bands and with one of the best albums, in the genre. I intend to put more five prog metal albums in the next weeks related with three of my favourite bands.

I hope you like it and comments are welcome as always.

Ocean of Noise
August 9th 2017


10970 Comments

Album Rating: 5.0

Possibly the greatest prog metal album of all time. Nice choice for a review.

e210013
August 9th 2017


5143 Comments

Album Rating: 5.0

Thanks Ocean.

TheIntruder
August 9th 2017


759 Comments

Album Rating: 4.5

Final I am able to comment your review. Yesterday it was not possible. The site it's been so temperamental lately that it was not possible.

So, nice choice for the review and nice work too. I love this album and band. I agree with Ocean of Noise. This is one of the best prog metal albums of all time. Pos.



e210013
August 9th 2017


5143 Comments

Album Rating: 5.0

Thanks Intruder. I'm very happy that you appeared on my reviews again.

Yeah, you're right. The site has been too much temperamental for my taste. For instance, I put the review in the morning, in my country, but in the afternoon it was completelly impossible to do anything. So, I hope that the absence of comments yesterday was due to that fact.

Cheers.

TheIntruder
August 9th 2017


759 Comments

Album Rating: 4.5

I am sure it was due to that. The review is good as always and the album is great too.

e210013
August 9th 2017


5143 Comments

Album Rating: 5.0

I hope so. Anyway, Pain Of Salvation isn't one of the most loved bands on Sputnik. And besides that, according to Jethro, the prog movement here on the site is very weak in these days.

Anyway, thanks for your support.

TheIntruder
August 9th 2017


759 Comments

Album Rating: 4.5

You are welcome. You can count with me. Continue your good prog work. It's important for guys like me.

e210013
August 9th 2017


5143 Comments

Album Rating: 5.0

I appreciate what you said. Thanks again, pal.

Jethro42
August 9th 2017


18275 Comments

Album Rating: 4.5

Relistening to it, I ask myself if I really prefer Remedy Lane over this. Both are really melodic and an easy listen with catchy and mellow songs. Both albums are well balanced between metal and soft parts. I wish Remedy Lane would have been The Perfect Element Part II instead of Scarsick which has too much flaws with songs that needed much more work for the biggest part.

I think I prefer Remedy Lane as a whole. Will revisit it. Their classic lineup was awesome.



Welcome back, e21, mate. Hope you passed good times during your vacations. Also happy 70th and good one, you prog provider hahah

ksoflas
August 9th 2017


1427 Comments

Album Rating: 5.0

Pain of Salvation

The Perfect Element, Part 1 auto pos!

e210013
August 10th 2017


5143 Comments

Album Rating: 5.0

@ Jethro

I agree with you. I still prefer "Remedy Lane". I don't know why. Maybe the concept, the cover, I'm really not sure. However, I think both are perfectly equal in terms of quality. And yeah, it's a pity that "Scarsick" has not been "The Perfect Element Part II". Anyway and despite that, "Scarsick has its charme and quality too.

Thanks Jethro. Yeah, I can say that the vacations were good. And I think I became in a good shape to continue our prog path. I changed the type of the bands and albums since the last ones. But you know me, I like to change. I'll return with more things less known again. It's my intention to change always. After all we are talking about prog and prog must always change. Isn't it?ah,ah,ah.

So, your vacations, in terms of prog, ended too, my friend. With me on Sputnik, boredom is over for you from now on, ah,ah,ah.

Cheers.

e210013
August 10th 2017


5143 Comments

Album Rating: 5.0

@ ksoflas

Thanks for your participation and pos, as is usual on my reviews about Pain Of Salvation. It's always a pleasure to see a great fan, like you, of this incredible band. So, you mustn't lose my next review.

Cheers.

ksoflas
August 10th 2017


1427 Comments

Album Rating: 5.0

I'm sure i won't miss it, keep on the good work man.

e210013
August 10th 2017


5143 Comments

Album Rating: 5.0

Thanks man.

y87arrow
August 24th 2018


713 Comments

Album Rating: 4.5

It took me a long time but now in 2018 after few years I like all songs on this album. Really great stuff.

I'm no expert in prog metal, but I love this album and others like Scenes From A Memory from Dream Theater.



Don't know if bands like Animals As Leaders, Textures, Meshuggah and Gojira (album From Mars To Sirius) can be considered prog metal, but I think they have elements of it.



But I want to discover something similar to Pain Of Salvation. Is Riverside a good choice there?

ksoflas
August 24th 2018


1427 Comments

Album Rating: 5.0

Not so similar to PoS but a great band nevertheless.

You should definetely try them arrow.

Jethro42
August 25th 2018


18275 Comments

Album Rating: 4.5

@arrow, if you haven't already, try;

Dark Suns - Existence

Indukti

Symphony X

Fates Warning

Psychotic Waltz

Dream Theater

y87arrow
August 25th 2018


713 Comments

Album Rating: 4.5

@Jethro42:

Thank you. I already know Dream Theater (I have 2 albums of them).



About Symphony X yes they might be my next choice (or Riverside), I tried some songs from the album "V: The New Mythology Suite", sounds very nice so far.

Jethro42
August 25th 2018


18275 Comments

Album Rating: 4.5

My recs are all prog metal, and they're all similar to Pain of Salvation at some point, except for Indukti which are rather brutal - I forgot about that fact - however, Susar has its good prog moments. Don't forget Remedy Lane, the first two albums and Be from PoS (in pretty much that order. Be is fantastic, but a bit more experimental). As for Riverside, none of the albums are perfect imo, but each of them has its strenght.

Cheers!



You have to be logged in to post a comment. Login | Create a Profile





STAFF & CONTRIBUTORS // CONTACT US

Bands: A B C D E F G H I J K L M N O P Q R S T U V W X Y Z


Site Copyright 2005-2023 Sputnikmusic.com
All Album Reviews Displayed With Permission of Authors | Terms of Use | Privacy Policy