Good Charlotte
Good Charlotte



by The Sludge USER (26 Reviews)
June 6th, 2006 | 26 replies

Release Date: 2000 | Tracklist

If your like me, you also jumped onto the "f*ck Good Charlotte" bandwagon once their 2002 album "The Young And The Hopeless" was released. Their incredibly over-produced punk influenced sound and boyish 'punk' image drawn in many preteen fans. Their songs and videos annoyingly flooded the pop stations of your local radio station and MTV. But secretly I was looking forward to it, and found some joy in it until the huge backlash happened in the punk world.

Unforgivable I couldn't deny my past. The skeletons in my closet ate at my musical soul. Just after the passing of my grandmother in 2000, when I first started looking towards music to heal the pain. And on MTV2, (the only music video station to actually play videos at the time), Little Things was consistently playing, and I was immediately drawn in. The images of being a loser in school and a father not being there that I could relate to. So I saved any cash I received to purchase the album, as it became a must have. Upon purchase, my Green Day and Weird Al albums took a break as this cd became full rotation on my stereo system and headphones. After when Benji and Joel hosted the late night MTV "All Things Rock" before the release of their follow up in 2002, I had already had money saved and purchased when released. At first I noticed a slight (just slight) change, but still enjoyed a fair amount of it. After a month or so, banned it from myself once everywhere, a hating Good Charlotte movement happened as I was getting into more punk. So naturally I joined along before being labeled anything that wasn"t me. I gave away my copy of "The Young And The Hopeless," then this album became on my back burner for until recently when I looked at the cloudy picture on the cd itself and decide to, so to say, 'give it another go.'

Good Charlotte got their start as twins Benji and Joel Madden was introduced to such bands as Rancid and Social Distortion by their older brother Josh. After a Beastie Boys concert in 1996, as the twins were 16yrs old, they decided to gather up a few friends to start a band, and moved to Maryland. After some practice and a solid line-up molded, the boys released an EP in 1999, which caught the eye of Sony executives after the breakout of Blink 182's "Enema Of The State." Many labels swallowed up anything related to a punk sound, as New Found Glory, Fenix TX, Handsome Devil, and of course Good Charlotte were given chances. In 2000, was this self titled debut LP released to only a mild success rate.

Good Charlotte:
Joel Madden - Vocals
Benji Madden - Guitar/Vocals
Billy Martin - Guitar
Paul Thomas - Bass
Aaron Escolopio - Drums

Really, the best musical quality on this album, is Paul's quirky bass lines. They stand out here a lot more than on their latter albums. Its evident that tracks like "I Don't Wanna Stop" and "Let Me Go" that the bass brings a fresh mark to Good Charlottes sound. Its even more evident in "Little Things" as it drives the song, especially during the verse as only it and the drums brings across Joel's lyrics of the downside of being a loser while everyone has it better than them. Along with "Screamer," the bass drags along the emotion along the verse with the high pitched guitar at the intro. The emotion keeps on flooding through this song, as Joel unleashes some of the best lyrics he has ever written. Very uplifting, about when life gets you down, just hold on and you'll get by.

Originally Posted by Screamer
You say that I'm a dreamer,
I saw you're a non-believer
Take out the light,
take out the light and start screaming.
I'm dreaming,
I'm a dreamer,
no one believes me,
and you don't either.
The lyrics on here period has more emotion and meaning than their latter records. Songs like the tear jerker "Seasons" reminisce of the good times in a past relationship. The song starts out with a soft acoustic feel, as Joel's low toned vocals provided touch to the feel of the song. About a minute in the distortion begins, and the song drives home once the pace builds up as the line "I wanna fall in love, tonight" starts. Well the lyrics aren't all about relationships like other pop-punk bands at the time (ala New Found Glory). There are songs about a father not being available while the Madden twin growing up. Hints of these lyrics are found in songs like "Little Things," ('We checked his room, his things were gone. We didn't see him no more, d*ck!') and "Waldorf Worldwide," (I'm tired of my old man, because he's never around). In fact "Waldorf Worldwide" is a rant on wanting to make it big so they don't have to live in the slums anymore. It has a nice ska quality sound, and there is even rapping during the verses. Such a happy feel to the song, even though the lyrics are about being alone in the world.

What Good Charlotte simultaneous does right and wrong is their much softer songs. Notably their last track "Change" and their hidden track titled "Thank You Mom." Common sense will say that Joel's voice doesn't fit with a soft acoustic track, being how broad and limited it is, and common sense is right again. But on "Change," it seems to fit perfectly. Mellow acoustics, well placed bass line, and the dums fit nicely. Well written lyrics about falling in love with someone you can't have. "Thank You Mom" has the same feel as "Change" but this track is actually the perfect ode to one's mom. Real brownie points were scored here.

Originally Posted by Thank You Mom
You were my mom,
you were my dad.
The only thing I ever had was you,
it's true.
This disc isn't all butter and cookies. Laced with filler. "The Click" is the opening track from the short lived cartoon show "The Undergrads." (This song wasn't included on my disc, that"s how long I've had it). Its just a very typical song. It keeps a catchy verse, referencing Star Wars, but eventually just blends into blandness. "I Don"t Wanna Stop" will get you bobbing your head slightly with its bouncing guitar riff. That"s where the fun stops, after a few listens, the lyrics and music just gets old quick. "Festival Song" could have just been named "Whining About Growing Up" because its complaining lyrics on not wanting to grow up and be a man. The music was played nicely, and its catchy, but the lyrics are pretty much a mess.

Its hard to suggest this disc to anyone that already has their mind set on how undeserving Good Charotte is, so is unlikely to give this debut a shot. It"s a good thing that Benji and Joel writes more on their life experience than about girl/relationship problems amongst the rest. The happy bass lines adds a lot to the listen ability on here. But the filler during the last half gets shot, even though they aren"t all that bad.

The Sludge's Thumb Up's
Thank You Mom (hidden track)
Waldorf Worldwide

Recent reviews by this author
Bon Jovi 100 Million Bon Jovi Fans Can't Be WrongThe Offspring Rise and Fall, Rage and Grace
New Found Glory From the Screen to Your Stereo Part IIRide Nowhere
Akon KonvictedAndrew W.K. The Wolf
user ratings (371)
other reviews of this album
kolzig33189 (4)

ShadyTwist (3)
The Maddens and their crew's debut is actually... pretty decent....

Comments:Add a Comment 
June 6th 2006


whoa, thats quite the interesting recommended albums ya got there, well just one in particular. :p
But this is the most tolerable of the three albums they have. I still wouldn't listen to it today, but it isn't all terrible. Beats the other two for sure though.

Digging: Nap Eyes - Thought Rock Fish Scale

The Sludge
June 6th 2006


Album Rating: 3.5

Thanks for the comments, I dont know if keeping that Metallica album is legal or not here. But I get quite a chuckle from it none the less.

I bowled a perfect game with this 300th comment!This Message Edited On 06.06.06

The Jungler
June 6th 2006


123 to Tom

Solid review.

June 6th 2006


cool review i dont agree with the rating and i was urpreised to see metalicas album as a recomended album.

June 6th 2006


Good review and pretty much agreed over all.

[Though I do like their song "Hold On" from their "The Young and the Hopeless" album, as well as the music video for it. >.>]

June 6th 2006


Good job Sludge.

June 6th 2006


Album Rating: 1.5

Nice review, man. I still thinks this album blows, but good review.

Afro Ninja
June 6th 2006


Album Rating: 2.5

nice job Sludge, i think this was a pretty decent album and you've made me want to listen to it again

*goes off to find it*

June 6th 2006


Album Rating: 3.0

I actually kind of like this one. I usually don't like Good Charolett, but I've liked "Little Things" since I first heard it.

June 6th 2006


I was actually thinking about reviewing this since the previous one was lacking; now there is no need to. Excellent work.

June 6th 2006


Album Rating: 1.5

Nice reivew, dude. Don't really agree with the rating, but you justified your points well.

June 6th 2006



June 6th 2006


Good review, but this album is so bad it's not even funny.

The Sludge
June 7th 2006


Album Rating: 3.5

you've made me want to listen to it again

Its so freakin awesome to actually get people to actually listen to a GC album.

The Sludge
July 17th 2006


Album Rating: 3.5

Why would you recommend Astro Lounge? That album's terrible, especially when compared to Fush-yu-Mang

Well Astro Lounge felt like it would fit, as a recommendation to this album. I agree, Fush Yu Mang owns any Smash Mouth material.

The Sludge
July 21st 2006


Album Rating: 3.5

I just want to put all 3 GC albums on the main page of comments :D

The Sludge
July 21st 2006


Album Rating: 3.5

It brings a tear to my eye.


The Sludge
July 21st 2006


Album Rating: 3.5

Good, I deserve it.

(I really dont)

February 6th 2007


I like your review but, also you deserve something else as you revealed your personal cowardice. What you basically said is that alot of people started hating GC, so then you joined along with them and then tried to disregard GC as a catalyst to helping you get over your grandmother's death.

July 1st 2007


Album Rating: 1.5

Good review, but I can't enjoy this band. Even after 2 buds they're still unbearable to me.

You have to be logged in to post a comment. Login | Create a Profile


Bands: A B C D E F G H I J K L M N O P Q R S T U V W X Y Z

Site Copyright 2005-2017
All Album Reviews Displayed With Permission of Authors | Terms of Use | Privacy Policy