">
 

RJD2
Magnificent City Instrumentals


4.0
excellent

Review

by STLMiguel USER (20 Reviews)
May 23rd, 2006 | 15 replies


Release Date: 2006 | Tracklist


After paying his dues for a few years, producer RJD2 finally got the attention he deserved in 2002 with the release of his Definitive Jux debut, Deadringer. In the four years since, he has remained remarkably busy, releasing a follow-up to Deadringer, the criminally underrated Since We Last Spoke, in 2004 and working on a number of side projects. These have included producing single songs for his peers (“Saliva” from MF Doom’s Viktor Vaughn album, for instance), recording as one half of the hip-hop duo Soul Position and 2006’s Magnificent City, a disc he made with underground veteran Aceyalone. While almost all of his guest appearances are smashing successes and Soul Position is largely considered one of underground hip-hop’s most promising acts, Magnificent City … well … it sort of sucked.

The problem? Aceyalone, usually as consistent an emcee as you can find, completely dropped the ball. His rhymes were unexpectedly simple, he sounded bored and the hooks to most of the songs featured him just saying the name of the song over and over. When one man is making the beats and another is writing the rhymes, there isn’t much room for either party to mess things up, but Aceyalone didn’t bring his best game and the entire album suffered. The beats, though, weren’t too bad at all, and hip-hop fans have been blessed with Magnificent City Instrumentals, which is (obviously!) nothing but RJD2’s beats.

And how do they sound on their own? Surprise, surprise, folks, Magnificent City Instrumentals is loads of fun. Now, is it Deadringer good? No, and it isn’t Since We Last Spoke good, either. But give the man a break; these tracks were written with an emcee in mind, Aceyalone just didn’t deliver. Overall, Magnificent City Instrumentals is relaxed, fun and full of energy. RJD2’s style has often been called “cut-and-paste hip-hop” because he throws so many different sounds together and the album, particularly the latter half, is a perfect example of this. “Junior,” for instance, features sleigh bells, heavy distortion, a high-pitched woman’s voice and wind instruments. The next track, “Heaven,” blends electric guitar with a fun piano part, and the next track, “Here & Now,” revolves around a sample of someone playing a harp.

Another highlight is "Disconnected," which features a great horn section that was once ruined by Aceyalone shouting the word "disconnected" over and over. Now, you can focus on the track's laid back sound and the quick vocal samples RJ mixed into the background. Other strong tracks include the funky “All for U,” which was also a highlight on the original Magnificent City album, and “A Sunday Mystery,” which is 90 seconds of piano, guitar and suspense.

Of course, since these are instrumental versions of an album that once featured rhymes, some of the songs seem a bit boring. During the parts where Aceyalone was originally spitting a verse, the songs will occasionally bore and frustrate you. “The beat is good, RJ,” you’ll think, “but you keep playing that horn part over and over!” This is a minor problem, though, and it’s one that fans of the genre will likely forgive rather quickly. After all, if the horn part he keeps repeating is great, who cares, right?

Fans of producers such as DJ Shadow and Diplo, be warned: These aren't slow, epic pieces that build and build until they reach a dramatic climax. These are average-length tracks that will make you want to get up and dance or at least nod your head. It would be ideal music to play at a party as background music right after, say, the Avalanches' Since I Left You. If you want to lay back, get stoned and watch your ceiling fan while the music makes you debate the meaning of life, stick with Endtroducing. RJD2 doesn't want to change your life, he just wants to improve it.



Recent reviews by this author
Carole King TapestryDabrye Two/Three
My Morning Jacket It Still MovesDanger Mouse and Jemini Ghetto Pop Life
Lyrics Born Same !@#$ Different DayBob Dylan Knocked Out Loaded
user ratings (21)
4.1
excellent
related reviews

Since We Last Spoke

The Third Hand

The Colossus
recommended by reviewer
J Dilla Donuts


Comments:Add a Comment 
The Jungler
May 24th 2006


4826 Comments


Decent review. Welcome to the RJD2 club.

Can we get a tracklist please?

STLMiguel
May 24th 2006


335 Comments

Album Rating: 4.0

I added it right after I posted this. And it isn't easy writing a review for an album of instrumentals that weren't really meant to be instrumentals, I thought I did OK.

The Jungler
May 24th 2006


4826 Comments


You did do OK, more detail and this would have been great. Thanks for posting the tracklist.

STLMiguel
May 24th 2006


335 Comments

Album Rating: 4.0

Yeah, I'm looking it over and you guys are right ... I think I forgot how much of it was background when I looked it over, y'know? I might throw in a few comparisons so people unfamiliar with him get a better idea.

STLMiguel
May 24th 2006


335 Comments

Album Rating: 4.0

OK, I added a few graphs. Thanks for the critique, I hope you guys dig it a bit more. And if you don't, well, maybe this site can release a different version of my review like the label did in the case of this album.

The Jungler
May 24th 2006


4826 Comments


Better, your paragraphs are really small but this is worth a positive vote.

Jawaharal
May 24th 2006


1832 Comments


RJD2 is the man.

Robert Crumb
May 24th 2006


165 Comments


I disagree about Magnificent City. Not Aceyalone's finest moment, but I liked a few tracks on it. RJD2 saves his ass with some nice beats more than a couple times though, so I would imagine this is pretty solid.

spoonfedcrayons
June 15th 2006


35 Comments


I dont know if I should get the instrumentals or the full album. Ive been getting some instrumental albums lately, (Madlib, Special Herbs) and Aceyalone has some weird lyrics. Which version should I get?

STLMiguel
June 15th 2006


335 Comments

Album Rating: 4.0

Well I would obviously tell you to get this version.

The Jungler
June 21st 2006


4826 Comments


I'm listening to Supahero right now (on internet radio) it's good, just a little repetitive. I may look into this.

STLMiguel
June 22nd 2006


335 Comments

Album Rating: 4.0

Cool.



You know, for a review that apparentally everyone thought was super short, this really isn't all that small. I think people just want me dead here.

STLMiguel
June 22nd 2006


335 Comments

Album Rating: 4.0

No, it doesn't really suck. I'm a journalist by trade, I was taught to write in short graphs and when I didn't in school, people would kick my face in. I've since learned that most people here don't do that, so I adapted so people wouldn't freak out about it.

Bron-Yr-Aur
June 22nd 2006


4405 Comments


This is a good review, just kind of lacking. Worth a vote though.

STLMiguel
June 22nd 2006


335 Comments

Album Rating: 4.0

Thanks. And I fixed most of the white space just for you, iluvatar, so breathe in the text and love it.



You have to be logged in to post a comment. Login | Create a Profile





STAFF & CONTRIBUTORS // CONTACT US

Bands: A B C D E F G H I J K L M N O P Q R S T U V W X Y Z


Site Copyright 2005-2023 Sputnikmusic.com
All Album Reviews Displayed With Permission of Authors | Terms of Use | Privacy Policy