Porcupine Tree
The Incident


4.0
excellent

Review

by e210013 USER (127 Reviews)
August 22nd, 2015 | 11 replies


Release Date: 2009 | Tracklist

Review Summary: Is this the end of the road for Porcupine Tree? Is “The Incident” their swan song?

“The Incident” is the tenth studio album by Porcupine Tree and was released in 2009. The line up on the album is Steven Wilson, Richard Barbieri, Colin Edwin and Gavin Harrison.


In recent years, Wilson and his band mates have been exploring the metal side of the progressive music and their last albums have had a relatively heavy side. On “The Incident” the band transcends metal and produced something that combines metal, acoustic, prog and rock elements, in a very intelligent way. It consists of two discs, the first one being the continuous 55 minute song cycle “The Incident” and the second disc with 20 minutes of unrelated band’s compositions. The final four songs appear on a separate disc to emphasize that they aren’t related to the main concept.

“The Incident” is a concept album based on one Wilson’s idea. The original idea appeared when he was caught in a motorway traffic jam driving, when he passed a road accident. He thought that an accident is something so traumatic and destructive for the people involved, that he decided to make a concept album about it. Therefore, he decided to search other type of accidents reported in the media. So, the album is about several types of accidents, like a car crash, a drowning in a river, or a religious cult in Texas. He decided to call the album “The Incident”, not “The Accident”.

Unlike the angst of “Fear Of A Blank Planet”, some of the songs on “The Incident” are uplifting, even with the sombre subject matter. The style is no doubt a return on Porcupine Tree’s previous works, seeming to be almost a mixture of their last three albums with some darker elements of “Fear Of A Blank Planet”, some lighter touches of “In Absentia” and the heavy grandeur of “Deadwing”. Wilson seems adamant to give each song its own individual feel, despite being only one theme. The sound is often reminiscent of the “Signify” days with elements of the art/progressive rock that Porcupine Tree are known for, with the recent metal touches from “Fear Of A Blank Planet” and a twist of industrial influences on the Wilson’s solo work, “Insurgents”. “The Incident” is a magnificent escape into Wilson’s musical world, and once again, it ticks all the points of how to make a truly good album.

As “The Incident” is a whole work, I only want to detach one of its songs, “Time Flies”. “Time Flies” is a wonderful autobiographical Pink Floyd flavoured song, probably the best song on the album, with its open line “I was born in 1967”, which was the year when Wilson was born. 1967 was also the year of “Sgt. Pepper’s Lonely Hearts Club Band” of The Beatles and “Are You Experienced” of Jimi Hendrix. But musically, Wilson’s head seems to be more in tune with “Animals” of Pink Floyd, and specifically the song “Dogs”, than with The Beatles or the Hendrix music.

The second disc has 20 minutes of music that you can consider a bonus disc within the official release. The band decided to place these four songs on a separate EP and release it with the main album instead of a later EP release, as happened with “Nil Recurring” of “Fear Of A Blank Planet”. The content is relevant to the release, since the songs are inspired by some other “incidents” that in one way or another left a strong impression in Wilson.

“Flicker” is the band mixing of some of the elements of their sound, in the same way that has worked for them for the past ten years, and where the lyrics and the music are good. “Bonnie The Cat” provides an “In Absentia” feel, with insidious lyrical content. “Black Dahlia” has a memorable vocal work. “Remember Me Lover” seems to combine all of the elements that Porcupine Tree was experimenting on this album.

I had the privilege of be present in one of the concerts of the live tour of “The Incident”, in my country, Portugal. The only thing I can say is that I became astonished with the entire concert. Porcupine Tree is really a wonderful live band. That night, when I returned home and I was listening to the album again, I maintained my first impression. “The Incident” is better played alive than on the studio version. Alive, it has a much faster rhythm and is quite heavier than on studio. However, I must confess that the more I listen to the album, better it sounds to me.


Conclusion: “The Incident” is a great album, more acoustic and less heavy than their last ones. The first CD is really an ambitious and excellent musical project. However, the second CD doesn’t explore the same line of the first. It shows the more experimental Wilson’s side. “The Incident” is the most autobiographical album by Wilson and it has that distinctive sound that Porcupine Tree has created all over the years. The overall sound is less metal than the usual on their last albums and is somehow a return to the past. The first disc is fantastic and the fourteen parts flow one into the next in an excellent way. However, the second disc has four nice songs but only “Remember Me Lover” can reach the quality level of the first CD. Anyway, “The Incident” is another solid release from one of the best prog bands, nowadays.


Music was my first love.
John Miles (Rebel)



Recent reviews by this author
Gentle Giant Gentle GiantGenesis Trespass
Caravan For Girls Who Grow Plump in the NightQuiet Sun Mainstream
Khan Space ShantyHeldon Stand By
user ratings (1654)
3.5
great
other reviews of this album
1 of
  • Altmer (3.5)
    Porcupine Tree's new album is extremely competent, emotionally harrowing, but ultimately l...

    MorningView425 (4)
    Extremely talented and absolutely professional, Porcupine Tree releases another strong alb...

    EVedder27 (3)
    Porcupine Tree attempts to continue their trend of outstanding concept albums, but trip ov...

    Nosferatwo (2.5)
    For the first time, Porcupine Tree tread water....

  • bodiesinflight57 (4.5)
    A culmination of fifteen years as the world's most relevant progressive rock band....

    Cragorio (3.5)
    Not the best, not the worst. A very good Porcupine Tree album....

    Nick Mongiardo (3.5)
    The Incident is another solid entry into the Porcupine Tree discography despite some lackl...

    YoYoMancuso (2)
    "The Incident" is just 76 minutes of ambitious songwriting that feels more like a demo tha...

  • Brendan Schroer (2)
    Ambition meets disappointment....


Comments:Add a Comment 
Ocean of Noise
August 22nd 2015


10774 Comments

Album Rating: 3.5

I don't really like the summary but the review's good.

e210013
August 22nd 2015


2613 Comments

Album Rating: 4.0

Ocean of Noise:



"I don't really like the summary".



What do you want to meaning about this?

Ocean of Noise
August 22nd 2015


10774 Comments

Album Rating: 3.5

asking whether or not the album is their swan song seems irrelevant to what you're saying in the review. idk, it just doesn't sit well with me

e210013
August 22nd 2015


2613 Comments

Album Rating: 4.0

Ok, I see your point of view.



What I meant is that Steven wrote that in this moment, the musical project of Porcupine Tree was exhausted. He also said that in this moment he felt more comfortable with his solo musical project, and he had no idea of reactivating the project again in the near future.



So, what I meant is that I don't know if the musical project of Porcupine tree will be over, and "The Incident" will not be their last work.

danielcardoso
August 22nd 2015


11770 Comments


Hey man, what city do you live in, in Portugal?

e210013
August 22nd 2015


2613 Comments

Album Rating: 4.0

In the north of Portugal in Viana do Castelo. It's 60 km in the north of Porto, in the west coast, also near of Galiza in Spain.



You are Portuguese or Brazilian?

danielcardoso
August 22nd 2015


11770 Comments


Portuguese, live in Vila Nova de Gaia, Porto.

e210013
August 22nd 2015


2613 Comments

Album Rating: 4.0

Ok. Please to meet you. We are almost neighbours.



It's always a pleasure to know that a compatriot is member of the same site and loves also music, despite my taste be probably, more prog, than yours.



However, certainly we will talk more often in the future.

Jethro42
August 22nd 2015


15969 Comments

Album Rating: 3.5

I've always hesitated to giving this a 4 or a 3.5. I might relisten to it, to make sure.

Good review!

e210013
August 22nd 2015


2613 Comments

Album Rating: 4.0

Thanks Jethro 42.

TheIntruder
September 1st 2015


437 Comments

Album Rating: 4.0 | Sound Off

The Incident is really a good album. And yes, you are right e210013. "the more I listen to the album, better it sounds to me". Nice review, pos.



You have to be logged in to post a comment. Login | Create a Profile





FAQ // STAFF & CONTRIBUTORS // SITE FORUM // CONTACT US

Bands: A B C D E F G H I J K L M N O P Q R S T U V W X Y Z


Site Copyright 2005-2019 Sputnikmusic.com
All Album Reviews Displayed With Permission of Authors | Terms of Use | Privacy Policy