Radiohead
Kid A


4.5
superb

Review

by doctorjimmy USER (60 Reviews)
November 11th, 2014 | 34 replies


Release Date: 2000 | Tracklist

Review Summary: The best Radiohead album so far

Kid A is quite a departure from OK Computer, Radiohead's previous studio effort.The reason is, it boasts a lot more experimentation and a different, more cerebral mood and atmosphere . You can sense it right from the first track with its ominous piano introduction that leaves such a ‘cold’ feeling on the listener, and when the effects come in, it becomes something else entirely. And the song is not all atmosphere and no melody, either. The vocals are extremely intoxicating and restrained at the same time, as well. After Everything In Its Right Place follows Kid A which displays excellent electronic drumming that serves as a background for more ‘snowy’ piano lines and superbly edited vocals. A brilliant track, that goes to show how electronic instruments can give a song a truly exciting edge. The National Anthem comes next with some sensational drumming, but this time from what I can tell it’s real drums. The bass line is extremely well written and is tied with the beat in perfect fashion. And after the middle Thom starts screaming and effects make their way in along with horns that result in a mesmerizing climax. The horn soloing is reaching a high point near the end, when it is accompanied by Yorke’s shrieks. Great fusion of jazz and electronic, I say.

How To Disappear Completely is an acoustic ballad in the more ‘traditional’ vein, only this time it is filled with first-rate effects that alter in dynamics with ease. And Thom’s voice is at its best here alternating falsetto and regular singing comfortably. Treefingers is further emphasizing the electronic aspects of the album, and it is haunting, really. An ambient track, it lulls you into its own world and you wish you could stay there for ever. And at three minutes, there is no sign of overstaying its welcome. Optimistic benefits from a particularly intriguing and crisp guitar tone and from Thom Yorke’s intense vocals. Near the end, the drums are suddenly ‘awakened’ and serve as a steady background for the guitar lines. And the song changes one more in the very end of the song, becoming faster and more upbeat.

In Limbo has some refreshingly inventive guitar finger-picking in a abnormal tempo that provides the song’s basis. The guitar licks that appear at one point are well-written, too. Finally, the song ‘drowns’ into a sea of effects to make room for Idioteque which has the best electronic drum beat on the album and is coupled with exciting effects and masterful vocal harmonies that give the song a superb flavor. And it isn’t overlong, which is quite impressive since it runs for five minutes. Excellent! Morning Bell, segued with Idioteque, begins with an interesting drum pattern and features the cold and snowy piano touches of the first songs. Together with the well-thought falsetto of the vocals and and the gradual take over of effects, it is a shattering listen. Suddenly, the song does a little break by increasing the volume and fluently dives back to the previous beat. Thom’s ‘mumbling’ in the middle make room for the second outbreak that lasts a little longer this time and the track finishes with some ‘dying’ piano lines.

Now, the final track, Motion Picture Soundtrack has more ambient experimenting and clever arrangement with some astral harp (is it a harp?) playing and in the middle it just stops abruptly. When I heard it for the first time I thought the disc was over, but I was wrong. After some twenty seconds or so, the ambient part resurrects for a brief crescento and then fades out again, leading to nearly two minutes of nothing but silence.

Highlights of the album include, well, everything except Motion Picture Soundtrack,which is great for the first three minutes, but the rest of the song is really unfocused. That’s because the first time the sound stops and we are treated with silence, it is an unexpected trick. But after the last fade out, there is no reason to continue the silence for two minutes. What’s the point? Anyway,the album is still such a shattering listen, better than OK Computer in my opinion, because despite the similar mood of the songs(there’s even less diversity than on OK Computer), Radiohead managed to make an album that flows perfectly without embracing the ‘rules’ of a ‘traditional’ listening experience, because every single song is so interesting in its arrangements and songwriting, that you can’t but be attracted to its charm.



Recent reviews by this author
Eric Clapton 461 Ocean BoulevardEric Clapton Eric Clapton
The Rolling Stones Out of Our HeadsThe Animals The Animals (US)
Earth, Wind and Fire That's The Way of The WorldThe Rolling Stones Aftermath
user ratings (7674)
4.4
superb
other reviews of this album
1 of


Comments:Add a Comment 
Gwyn.
November 11th 2014


17270 Comments


Well, this is a risky review, since the one for the last album got quite negative reviews.


Neg

TumsFestival
November 11th 2014


2470 Comments

Album Rating: 4.0

This isn't actually a terrible review but there's really nothing left to say about this album that hasn't been said 50 times before, plus this is basically a track by track

Necrotica
November 11th 2014


10693 Comments

Album Rating: 4.5

The review could definitely use a lot of work. First, as Gwyn pointed out (with a neg, lol), take out the first two sentences ASAP and rework the first lines of the next paragraph. Even if it ends up as a slightly generic way to begin a review, at least it isn't as awkward as the current intro. Also, this review just feels like a track-by-track rundown in disguise. There's not much flow when so much overbearing detail is packed into the piece (I've been guilty of this in the past too). Try trimming your thoughts down into different categories to give the reader a more concise and approachable point of entry. Also, some of the grammar is off. For instance, "for ever" should be "forever" and "kinda faster and groovy" sounds incredibly awkward.



I won't pos or neg this one, but I'll help you with proofreading if you want. I enjoyed your Fleetwood Mac review so I know you can make good write-ups... so keep at it :]

doctorjimmy
November 11th 2014


386 Comments

Album Rating: 4.0

thanks for the feedback, mate ;)

Vakarian12
November 11th 2014


4091 Comments


shit band

Jots
Emeritus
November 11th 2014


7562 Comments


in the future, if you're having issues with grammar, you can go to the 'site forum' and post your review in the proofreading thread. Someone will probably help out

Mongi123
November 11th 2014


22034 Comments

Album Rating: 5.0

The reason you keep getting negs is because of how poor your grammar is. You gotta try to proofread a bit better man. Like Johnny said, send your reviews to the proofreading thread they'll be a big help.

TheMoonchild
November 11th 2014


1315 Comments


Are people trying to set a world record for most reviews of one album or something

TheMoonchild
November 11th 2014


1315 Comments


That said this isn't a terrible review IMO it just feels like a regurgitation of most of the others.

Sowing
Moderator
November 11th 2014


43943 Comments

Album Rating: 5.0

Any Kid A review is a regurgitation of one of the other hundreds of Kid A reviews

RadicalEd
November 11th 2014


9546 Comments

Album Rating: 2.0

I hate this album. And this review.

Tunaboy45
November 11th 2014


18421 Comments

Album Rating: 5.0

What Necrotica said.

Artuma
November 11th 2014


32762 Comments

Album Rating: 4.5

"I hate this album."



said no one on this site ever

AgainAnd
November 11th 2014


281 Comments

Album Rating: 3.5

I hate this album.

Snake.
November 11th 2014


25249 Comments

Album Rating: 4.5

This isn't actually a terrible review







yes it is

TalonsOfFire
Emeritus
November 11th 2014


20969 Comments

Album Rating: 5.0

this review just feels like a track-by-track rundown in disguise [2] at least this wasn't as annoying as the OKC one

Artuma
November 11th 2014


32762 Comments

Album Rating: 4.5

"AgainAnd

November 11th 2014





273 Comments

Report this Post

Album Rating: 3.5



I hate this album."







ha. ha.

AgainAnd
November 11th 2014


281 Comments

Album Rating: 3.5

Okay the jig is up. Though I could claim I hate it because it doesn't get me like it used to. Only the title track still blows me away like this album used to way back when.

VaxXi
November 11th 2014


4418 Comments


Another Kid A review. Why?

Ryus
November 11th 2014


36622 Comments

Album Rating: 4.0

Because this guy offers a fresh point of view that hasn't been covered by any of the 29 other reviews.























lol



You have to be logged in to post a comment. Login | Create a Profile





STAFF & CONTRIBUTORS // CONTACT US

Bands: A B C D E F G H I J K L M N O P Q R S T U V W X Y Z


Site Copyright 2005-2023 Sputnikmusic.com
All Album Reviews Displayed With Permission of Authors | Terms of Use | Privacy Policy