I Am Heresy
Thy Will



by Evreaia USER (17 Reviews)
May 17th, 2014 | 9 replies

Release Date: 2014 | Tracklist

Review Summary: A marriage of old and new.

“Don't forget who you are and where you come from.”

A short quote by Francis Scott Fitzgerald, but despite its short length it’s very powerful. It’s a reminder that newer doesn’t always equal better. But at the same time it reminds you dwell in the past either.

Meet I Am Heresy, a modern Metalcore band that’s on the one side firmly rooted into the more chaotic origins of the genre, but at the same time also into the melodic side of the genre that’s currently at reign, and all of this is coupled with an outspoken knack for genre blending. The band takes a heavy influence from Metalcore veterans such as Converge or Deadguy, but at the same time also from current acts like BoySetsFire and Bury Tomorrow..

“The death of God is the birth of human potential”

I Am Heresy is founded by Nathan Gray (of BoySetsFire-fame) “to live out his love for dark, violent noise". Something Gray & co did not try and hide. The entire album is drenched in a dark atmosphere, one rarely seen in the Metalcore genre. Lyrics and references about Satanism and witchcraft are common, but subtle enough to allow the band to use it as more than a gimmick.

Helmsman Nathan Gray is by far the most impressive member of the band. Delivering a performance that’s far more consistent and powerful than his work with BoySetsFire. His stand-out clean vocals have always been impressive, but it’s his new assortment of snarls, shouts, growls and even occasional shrieks (like in the song Rahabh) that really steal the show. Sounding more varied than ever, he easily acts as the backbone of the entire album.

Instrumentally the rest of the band are no slouches either! From the immediate aggression of album opener “Rahabh”, the tremolo picking in “Our Father”, the melodic sections of “March Of Black Earth” and even the multiple acoustic songs are all well thought out and executed. The band does not fear shaking up the standard formula found in the genre and they utilize opportunity offered to include other genres in the concoction of old and new. Crossover thrash can be found in songs like “Destruction Anthems “ and “Thy Will II (Black Sun Omega)”, while “Seven Wolves And The Daughters Of Apocalypse” showcase a more progressive metal song structure. Also, don’t forget about the aforementioned acoustic songs “Thy Will I (Black Sun Alpha)”, “Alarm”, “Hinnom I (Altar Of Fire & Earth)” and the Black Metal-inspired riffs found in “Devour”.

Yet, despite all that I Am Heresy succeeds at with Thy Will, the album suffers from a couple of glaring flaws that prevent the album of being more than “great”.

Smaller problems include a strange album flow. Unlike Converge’s Axe To Fall –an album with some obvious parallels- Thy Will switches the mood and pace with every song, drastic changes like transition between the acoustic “Thy Will I”’s and “Thy Will II”’s heavier crossover thrash-riffs don’t do the album any favor. These smaller conceptual oversights could have been forgiven if I Am Heresy was a band without any past experience, or if it was the only flaw the album suffered from. Which sadly, is not.

Thy Will greatest flaw, by far. Which consequently leaves it as a wolf without claws and teeth, is its production. The paper thin, way to polished production found on many new Metalcore albums. Not only does it rob the instruments of their power and impact, it also negates most of the darker atmosphere the band was aiming for. The melodic sections don’t suffers as much, but I doubt this band has the intention of being “just” a melodic metalcore band. A more raw and organic production –akin to Converge’s Axe To Fall or All We Love We Leave Behind- would not only have drastically improved the quality of the album, but it would also left it way more meaningful and with far more impact. Instead of a slightly darker, less melodic BoySetsFire album it sound like now.

“Never stop fighting, never give in!”

A strange album flow and poor, overproduced production bring down an otherwise outstanding album. At first the album will conjure up violent images of a great menacing wolf, but for those who stay long enough will notice the wolf’s lack of claws and teeth, making the experience far less thrilling and engaging that it could have been. 3,5/5

Recent reviews by this author
Anopheli The Ache of WantThe Great Old Ones Tekeli-Li
NAMI The Eternal Light of the Unconscious MindSo Hideous Last Poem/First Light
Csejthe ReminiscenceObsidian Kingdom Mantiis
user ratings (23)

Comments:Add a Comment 
May 17th 2014


Album Rating: 3.5 | Sound Off

Sorry bro, had barely any time to proofread, will do later.

Best metalcore of 2014, no doubt about that.

For the fans of BoySetsFire.

Rahabh = http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3MPEfPpRhKo

March of Black Earth = http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6J6Sz5TF52o

Seven Wolves And The Daughters Of Apocalypse = http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cbdaxcrVKHc

May 17th 2014


Album Rating: 4.5

yes, this album stil gives me the shivers when I listen to it, Nathan is for me by far the best singer in the post-hardcore / metalcore genre.

Nice review btw!

May 17th 2014


wasn't too impressed with their first album even though I love BSF

May 17th 2014


Album Rating: 3.5 | Sound Off

I personally enjoyed this far more than their debut, a lot more diverse and better execution.

May 17th 2014


I love BSF [2], but I haven't found anything I have heard by this group all that appealing.

Staff Reviewer
June 17th 2014


How did I not know about this until now???

June 17th 2014


Album Rating: 3.5 | Sound Off

It flew under the radar of most BoySetsFire fans I think

January 27th 2015


really interesting sound, enjoying this

October 28th 2022


Album Rating: 3.0

you know, this isnt half bad

You have to be logged in to post a comment. Login | Create a Profile


Bands: A B C D E F G H I J K L M N O P Q R S T U V W X Y Z

Site Copyright 2005-2023 Sputnikmusic.com
All Album Reviews Displayed With Permission of Authors | Terms of Use | Privacy Policy