The Fall of Troy
Doppelganger


3.0
good

Review

by IronGiant USER (15 Reviews)
April 17th, 2014 | 21 replies


Release Date: 2005 | Tracklist

Review Summary: The Fall of Troy shoots for the moon and ends up landing in a Hot Topic located in a dilapidated suburban shopping complex

The Fall of Troy has always been a band people loved to talk about. You had the kids who owned every Dance Gavin Dance shirt screaming in one ear how the guitar has never been played like Thom Erak, lead guitarist and vocalist, plays it while simultaneously being vocally bludgeoned to death by the pretentious metal heads who snub any song under ten minutes long or anything by a band not named Opeth. When I discovered The Fall of Troy back in 2010 while I was in eighth grade, I was caught somewhere in the middle of that spectrum. I was at an age where heavy equaled tough and scary equaled cool. My iPod was filled to the brim with Slipknot and I had Cannibal Corpse out my wazoo because I believed with all my heart that that was the music that understood me best. ‘No one knows what it’s like to get an F on a paper you worked really hard on or have your crush go out with your best friend’, I told myself. I felt alone. And wouldn’t you know it, Doppelganger was there to pick me up, dust off my clothes, and hold my hand as we pioneered this new frontier that was filled with unknown creatures of the opposite sex and funny-smelling plants that made you feel hungry and happy and all-knowing and insignificant all at the same time– a place known ubiquitously as junior high.

Unfortunately, like most middle school romances, this relationship was short-lived. As I grew up and musically matured, dipping my toes in several new genres and starting to actually pay attention to musical attributes like lyricism and concept and emotion, Doppelganger stagnated. I tried to approach the album with my newfound insight, but it came up short. You didn’t exactly have to be Einstein to figure out the ‘hidden meaning’ behind these lyrics, which were half-baked tales of love, loss, and introspection that felt more like doodles in a notebook than full-fledged ideas and stories. The instrumental prowess, while undeniably present, seems to suffer from the opposite. Each song sounds exactly how it sounds–every riff, solo, and note these guys could think of was crammed into each song’s nook and cranny until it was so unfocused and bloated that it burst at the seems. “Whacko Jacko Steals the Elephant Man’s Bones” is the best example of this, perpetually shifting from one idea to the next and ultimately leaving the listener overwhelmed by its messy structure and cacophonous tone. Erak, who’s voice use to be a kick in the balls, now grated my ears and he sounded more like a pseudo-intellectual sap than the bad-ass I pegged him to be years before. “Mcacaulay McCulkin” starts interesting enough, ditching the typical atonal riff for a fluid and melodious one, but drags for its eight-minute run time. The most normal song on the album, “F.C.P.R.E.M.I.X”, which was commercially propelled by its inclusion in Guitar Hero III, also happens to be the most catchy and accessible of the bunch. The screeches are kept down to a minimum, only included supplemental to the chorus, and provided by bassist Tim Ward, and the mid-section of the track features one of the most enjoyable head-banging moments of the album.

But at the end of the day, Doppelganger feels more like a schematic than a final product. It shows hints of promise by offering a few truly enjoyable tracks (We Better Learn to Hotwire a Uterus” and “Mouths Like Sidewinder Missiles”) but misses the mark holistically. It sounds like a demo, a collection of songs, rather than an album, and thus, leaves you with your finger hovering over the skip button more often than you’d like.

Sooner or later, we all grow out of certain things because a) we don’t want them anymore, b) they served their purpose and aren’t needed anymore, or c) because growing up and trying new things is a natural part of life. It’s the reason some of us choose to trade smoking our friends at Super Smash Bros. Brawl for smoking blunts with the same people you played those same games with. It's why your stuffed dolphin you had when you were younger that helped fight bad dreams is now sitting in a box somewhere in the attic.

Doppelganger was perfect for it was–a juvenile and rough-around-the-edges album that helped a kid get through an awkward transitional phase in his life. Alas, despite my previous statements, this album will always be sentimental to me. The Fall of Troy’s unique blend of Post-Hardcore and Progressive Rock provides an entertaining, albeit unbalanced, experience for the listener who doesn’t care so much about lyrical content and more so about being able to point out to his friends a cool riff or lick every few minutes. With the band’s somewhat recent announcement to reform and go back to the drawing board to create some new music, one can only hope that The Fall of Troy learns to filter its ideas and create a streamlined and focused album that is as fun to listen to as Doppelganger was so many years ago.



Recent reviews by this author
Slowdive SouvlakiKanye West Yeezus
My Bloody Valentine LovelessOught More Than Any Other Day
Death Grips The Money StoreThe Beatles The Beatles
user ratings (2293)
Chart.
4
excellent
other reviews of this album
1 of


Comments:Add a Comment 
paradox1216
Emeritus
April 17th 2014


730 Comments

Album Rating: 5.0

Great review, though I fall more into the "this is a modern classic" camp.

kris.
April 17th 2014


14676 Comments

Album Rating: 4.5

"You had the kids who owned every Dance Gavin Dance shirt screaming in one ear how the guitar has never been played like Thom Erak, lead guitarist and vocalist, plays it"



i have not once ever worn a DGD shirt thank you very much

Jade
Emeritus
April 17th 2014


10698 Comments


this album sucks man

XingKing
April 17th 2014


12558 Comments

Album Rating: 5.0

No. This album is a classic

SnakeDelilah
April 17th 2014


20005 Comments

Album Rating: 3.5

Album's awesome without the remastered tracks.

Digging: Glassjaw - Material Control

ANJ45
April 17th 2014


207 Comments

Album Rating: 4.5

Great review, but yeah, this album rules... for me, at least!



The songwriting is just top-notch, I've never felt that this is technical to the point of wankery at any point, it's very chaotic, yet cohesive in a way.

Calc
Contributing Reviewer
April 17th 2014


15835 Comments

Album Rating: 4.5

this album sucks man [2]

JS19
April 17th 2014


6056 Comments

Album Rating: 2.0

Everyone is wrong

Digging: Sleeping at Last - Atlas - Space 2

HenchmanOfSanta
April 17th 2014


1994 Comments

Album Rating: 4.5

You really need to break up that opening sentence. I had to read it like three times. Otherwise this is well-written, although it's condescending and makes false assumptions about why anyone likes this album.

IronGiant
April 17th 2014


1551 Comments

Album Rating: 3.0

agree about that opening sentance as I re-read it again @henchman, thanks for the advice. and I do like the album, it just is way over hyped imo. It's a good album and nothing more to me

IronGiant
April 17th 2014


1551 Comments

Album Rating: 3.0

the way I look at it is that they don't successfully satisfy either of the genres they set to "re-invent" with the album... if I

wanna listen to awesome prog/post-hardcore guitar work I'd wayyy rather listen to Tera Melos' debut or a TSOAF album,

which do everything this album does a lot better.

HenchmanOfSanta
April 17th 2014


1994 Comments

Album Rating: 4.5

the way I look at it is that they don't successfully satisfy either of the genres they set to "re-invent" with the album... if I

wanna listen to awesome prog/post-hardcore guitar work I'd wayyy rather listen to Tera Melos' debut or a TSOAF album,

which do everything this album does a lot better.

And that's all fine, but you seem to be operating under the assumption that people only love this album because they don't know any better. My taste has expanded a hundredfold since I first heard this and I still love it.

IronGiant
April 17th 2014


1551 Comments

Album Rating: 3.0

I think you mistake my apprehension for condescendence. The album is meant to be taken at surface value; it isn't one to

be analyzed or picked apart like I like to do with albums. In a review where I like to dig deep into the tracks' musical

anatomy, the songs leave more to be desired, thus my disappointment as portrayed in the review. I didn't mean it as a

personal attack against anyone who likes the album. Music is subjective and if my review seems objective in anyway Santa,

I apologize because that was not my intention in the least. I will try to recognize and eliminate potential listener's bias if I

notice any in my future reviews.

Calc
Contributing Reviewer
April 17th 2014


15835 Comments

Album Rating: 4.5

"the way I look at it is that they don't successfully satisfy either of the genres they set to "re-invent" with the album..."



You also seem to think the notion of this band reinventing anything is something other than hype from fans and not anything the band said or did here.

paradox1216
Emeritus
April 17th 2014


730 Comments

Album Rating: 5.0

There arent even many good DGD shirts tbh, I have one of the only good ones I've seen

paradox1216
Emeritus
April 17th 2014


730 Comments

Album Rating: 5.0

And yeah honestly, I went through a period of

hating these guys back when I hated everything

I was into when I was like 13 or 14, and now I

love them again



But really, though they never did anything

completely terrible, there was a major drop

after album 3

Jade
Emeritus
April 17th 2014


10698 Comments


Comment more IronGiant, you're an insightful user that makes discussions worthwhile around these parts. Forgot to mention how much I like this review

IronGiant
April 17th 2014


1551 Comments

Album Rating: 3.0

thanks Omaha, that means a lot coming from a Staff Reviewer such as yourself. I really love music and would be more than happy to have discussions with you and the rest of the community about different albums and such. Please read my other reviews when and if you have the time and tell me how you like them!

IronGiant
April 17th 2014


1551 Comments

Album Rating: 3.0

and paradox I was totally just making a jab in the review, I am not aware of the DGD shirts available hahaha

paradox1216
Emeritus
May 1st 2014


730 Comments

Album Rating: 5.0

Just wanted to update and let everyone know I finally found a decent DGD shirt



You have to be logged in to post a comment. Login | Create a Profile





STAFF & CONTRIBUTORS // SITE FORUM // CONTACT US

Bands: A B C D E F G H I J K L M N O P Q R S T U V W X Y Z


Site Copyright 2005-2017 Sputnikmusic.com
All Album Reviews Displayed With Permission of Authors | Terms of Use | Privacy Policy