">
 

Iron Maiden
Edward The Great


4.0
excellent

Review

by Fade.To.Black USER (3 Reviews)
March 25th, 2006 | 37 replies


Release Date: 2002 | Tracklist


With the Album opening on the blasting drums of "Run to The Hills" and closing on Bruce Dickinson screeching for Brazil to scream for him, Edward the Great is Sixteen songs that prove that Iron Maiden are one of the Greatest bands in metal and one of the greatest on the planet. This reveiw is based off the original Edward thte Great.

Run to the Hills (Harris)[3:59]
The son opens with a catchy drum beat quickly followd by a vaguely annoying guitar intro. The song soon speeds up and comes into the chorus, the sort of thing that can be roared into a stadium of 70,000 people as well as be sung by 20 drunks in a bar. The guitar solo for the song is good if only a little short. Overall a good song.
4/5

The Number of the Beast (Harris) [4:55]
With a spoken intro it is quickly followed by almost whispered words. The song speeds up for the chorus which is entered by a primal scream from Bruce. A long fast solo that just has that special sound that only Iron Maiden Seems to be able to produce. Not a Bad song but a bit Long. Incidentally, the song is based on a dream.
4/5

The Flight of Icarus (Harris) [3:54]
A realtively boring song intro which very soon turns into a very melodic chorus. The second Verse heralds the arrival of Icarus, who is then betrayed by god. One more incredible solo then another one to take us to the end of the song which has some excellent bass work from Harris. Another incredible song.
4/5

The Trooper (Smith/Dickinson) [4:14]
The Trooper seemed to me to be just a little too generic for Iron Maiden. It was good but it isn't necessarily good enough for a greatest hits album. A circular solo follows the second chorus. A breif break for Bruce in a small instrumental part. Not a bad song just not great either
3/5

2 Minutes To Midnight (Smith/Dickinson) [6:03]
An incredibly catchy riff opens this song followed by a excellent verse, prechorus and an incredible chorus. The Solo starts slow but soon builds up into a solo that cuts over the rest of the band. The song goes soft briefly only to be followed by the intro riff which leads back into the verse,prechorus, chorus structure with the song ending on a bit of a disapointing outro. Overall and incredible song, a must have for any metal fan.
5/5

Wasted Years (Smith) [5:09]
An almost happy intro soon turns to vocals about someone who has wasted their life. This isn't to say it isn't a good song. Another melodic chorus from Bruce reinforces how good Maiden really are. The intro riff is repeated before the solo comes in. A fairly average solo yet still excellent. This song has everything a music fan could want. It has words to satisfy emo's, punks and headbangers all at once. Top Notch song
5/5

Can I Play with Madness (Smith/Harris/Dickinson) [3:33]
An annoying unacompanied voice opens this song by yelling the song name. The rest of the band soon joins. They compliment the song well yet are still very noticeable. The chorus come back with the songs title except this time it is any thing but annoying. The Solo has an almost duel beetween the lead guitar and the rest of the band. The song closes on the same annotying unnacompnied voice, taking away from an almost perfect song. Still great though.
4.5/5

The Evil That Men Do (Smith/Harris/Dickinson) [4:36]
A song starts slowly yet is soon sped up. The vocals are briefly average yet soon jump to excellent with the prechorus. Sadly the song gets worse when the reach the chorus. Another solo that has many guitar players jelously staring at the pictures of Iron Maiden and the incredible sound they produce. Another good song, with some interesting lyrics.
4/5

The Clairvoyant (Harris) [4:29]
An intersting bass intro guides the song along until the rest of the band joinin. With thoughts of death we hear a song that i find horribly average. It sounds too forced and it is too long. Also the chorus is boring and the verses all sound very similar. A solo peirces through which breifly picks the song up but it falls back again. Not a bad song, but like The Trooper, just not incredible like some other songs on the album.
3/5

Infinite Dreams (Harris) [6:13]
Another generic Iron Maiden song with the only interest coming from the guitar interludes and solo, with the best bit of the song being the secong half.
3/5

Holy Smoke (Harris/Dickinson) [3:50]
A very catchy intro followed by vocals from the perspective of christ. It is talking about how the bible can be interpreted and the real story may not be getting through. A solo follows that is technically insane. Ending on an ahh of satisfaction the listener feels the same. Great song
4.5/5

Bring your Daughter...To The Slaughter (Dickinson) [4:46]
The last disapointing song on this album, it opens very well with an intersting verse, but then a stupid and boring verse. I suppose all they could think of that rhymes with slaughter was daughter. And I don't blame them that is tricky but still it is still a boring song. The best bit of the song is a musical interlude beetween choruses.
3/5

Man on The Edge (Gers/Bayley) [4:15]
Another slow intro we soon hear Blaze Bayely's Deep resonant voice. A good song with a great chorus even if it is just the same phrase over and over agian.
4/5

Futereal (Harris/Bayley) [2:58]
A very catchy intro followed by some interesting lyrics. An fairly average chorus folwed by a technically incredible solo yet it isn't the best. Not a bad song.
3.5/5

The Wicker Man (Smith/Haris/Dickinson) [4:36]
The return of Bruce Dickinson's voice returns to sing a great verse and an awesome chorus. Another solo leaves us reeling. Great song, maybe a little Long.
4/5

Fear of The Dark[Live At Rock In Rio] (Harris) [8:04]
This song really cements Iron Maidens reputation as not only as a great studio band but as an incredibly live band. This song opens with a crowd that can actually hold the melody and rythymn of the song before Bruce Dickinson takes over. This song is Eight Minutes of Maiden at their best. Probably My favourite Iron Maiden Song ever, this song goes from acoustic into screaming electric. Bruce has an incredible voice in the way that he can sing softly as well as scream incredibly. We are fooled into beleiving the solo starts twice before it does. But when it starts no one should want it to end. An amazing song
5/5

From fantastic riffs to Burning solo's to amazing vocals to the sort of choruses that seem to encompass every genre of music. If you have not heard Iron Maiden Before,get this album. It is annoying that it lacks any rare footage but it is the best place to start if you haven't heard any Maiden.

Dedicated to Iron Maiden girl (You Know Who You are)

Faithfully, Fade.To.Black


user ratings (246)
3.9
excellent
other reviews of this album
DoughBoy69 (4)
A great compilation album. While, some songs shouldn't of been on here and others that weren't inclu...



Comments:Add a Comment 
pattern_recognition
March 25th 2006


950 Comments


Bit of a spellcheck needed, but pretty good for a tBt. However-
The Flight Of Icarus - 'relatively boring'
*shocked*
The Trooper - 'generic'
*shocked again*
Run To The Hills - 'a vaguely annoying guitar intro'
*triple shocked*
The Evil That Men Do - 'gets worse when they reach the chorus'
*ultra quad-shock meltdown*
Bring Your Daughter... - 'dissapointing...stupid and boring verse'
*heart attack*
And yet you liked Holy Smoke...?
*head explodes*
Dude...dude...DUDE.
Your review was well written though, so cheers to that. Peace (:

This Message Edited On 03.25.06

kolzig33189
March 25th 2006


335 Comments


actually number of the beast is based on an experience of getting mixed up with a satanist group not a dream

south_of_heaven 11
March 25th 2006


5618 Comments


i am appauled at your view of The Number of the Beast and The Trooper.


but still, a good review


and kolzig33189, I too thought that TNOTB was based off a dream, as that what Bruce stated...seemed I was wrong...


madmunch
March 25th 2006


89 Comments

Album Rating: 5.0

I disagree with some of your ratings, personally I think Trooper is one of Maidens best songs and that Number of the beast is fantastic

Bfhurricane
March 25th 2006


6284 Comments

Album Rating: 4.0

*what the first guy said*



Great album, but I think that if you let these songs grow on you a little you'd realize how amazing most of them are

Shadius
March 25th 2006


203 Comments


I didn't particulary like your reviewing style, with comments like a guitar solo being average, yet still excellent. A little paradoxical, I suppose you're talking about how hard it is to play or something along those lines, which is pointless, IMO.

I disagreed with many of your comments, also, I'm not sure if it's that or the writing style that makes me thing this review isn't great.

temporary
March 25th 2006


207 Comments


I'm sorry, but I can't understand this CD warranting a four. Its surprisingly poorly compiled. First off, there's nothing from their pre Bruce era, and the selection from the rest of their albums is pretty awful. Where's Hallowed Be Thy Name, Revelations, Aces High, Powerslave, or Heaven Can Wait? I'm also a bit miffed by your review, in which you did things like describe Flight of Icarus as "Relatively boring" but then "another incredible song." I'm not going to beat on your opinion, as that's your own, but this was a rather faulty review.

Aakon_Keetreh
March 25th 2006


448 Comments

Album Rating: 4.0

THis is just another greatest hits album. Its okay. 4/5

Bfhurricane
March 25th 2006


6284 Comments

Album Rating: 4.0

I think that they could have put together a much better CD:



- Hallowed Be Thy Name, Phantom of the Opera, Wrathchild, Prowler, and a few others should have been on here from Maiden's earlier years

tom79
March 25th 2006


3964 Comments


Not a bad compilation, but definetly could of had some better songs like people have said already (Aces High, Powerslave,Revelations,Invaders). But for the most part, it has a good song selection.

Shadius
March 25th 2006


203 Comments


Uh.. since when was Hallowed be thy name a single?

The tracklist is fine for what it is.

Fade.To.Black
March 26th 2006


85 Comments

Album Rating: 4.0

Thanks for your feedback. When i say a solo is average yet excellent it means that its fairly average for maiden yet still beats the hell out of most other bands. Thanks for your comments i really need to get better at this.

south_of_heaven 11
March 26th 2006


5618 Comments


Just because its a Greatest Hits does not make it a Greatest Single's album "Shadius". Many albums such as this one still will feature many of the artists greatest work, single or not.

Songs like Hallowed Be Thy Name, Phantom of the Opera, Wrathchild, and Powerslave will forever always be some of the greatest songs ever written by Iron Maiden, so for them to be ignored on a greatest hits album is very dissapointing.This Message Edited On 03.25.06

Ad Absurdum
March 26th 2006


44 Comments

Album Rating: 2.5

[quote=Obi One Kenodi]I'm sorry, but I can't understand this CD warranting a four. Its surprisingly poorly compiled. First off, there's nothing from their pre Bruce era, and the selection from the rest of their albums is pretty awful. Where's Hallowed Be Thy Name, Revelations, Aces High, Powerslave, or Heaven Can Wait? I'm also a bit miffed by your review, in which you did things like describe Flight of Icarus as "Relatively boring" but then "another incredible song." I'm not going to beat on your opinion, as that's your own, but this was a rather faulty review.[/quote]I completely agree. Whilst (most of) the songs are good, this is a bad compilation in my opinion.

Also, I am severely disappointed at the blatant lie in this review surrounding 'The Trooper' and its greatness.

Bfhurricane
March 26th 2006


6284 Comments

Album Rating: 4.0

Honestly, did you listen to all the songs on this album once, then rate them? Im sorry to say this, but it really doesnt sound like you knew anything about these songs when you wrote this review. Give The Trooper and Number of the Beast another listen.

Fade.To.Black
March 27th 2006


85 Comments

Album Rating: 4.0

Sorry, I only listened to every song 25 times for this reveiw. I'm sorry if this isn't enough. I will try to be a good Iron Maiden fan and suit my tastes to match yours. I'm sorry that you dont like my reveiw but this all opinion based. Just to me a chorus consisting of ah ah ah ah ah ah just doesent really cut it as an incredible song. And i do like the number of the beast i dont know why i rated low. And i also think it is mssing some important stuff like Hallowed be thy name and powerslave.

Bfhurricane
March 27th 2006


6284 Comments

Album Rating: 4.0

I never said i didnt like your review. It was well thought out and you definitely backed up your opinions in the appropriate manner.

All I said was that I think that if you let some of these songs grow on you, your opinions on aspects of certain songs will probably change. And as for the Trooper, the part where hes screaming "ah ah ah ah ah" as you blandly described it, his voice is used more in that part as an instrument itself to accompany the galloping powerchords which sounds really cool.

namaan
April 4th 2006


10 Comments

Album Rating: 3.0

while those individual tracks are good...im not a fan of greatest hits albums even from a band as superb as Maiden...hence why i own all the studio albums



my view is ( as a hardcore maiden fan who remembers listening the the 1981 album KIllers with Paul Di'anno on vocals and Clive Burr on drums at 6 years old, due to my father being a maiden fan in his younger days)



if you gonna listen to Maiden..listen to a whole album..you'll appreciate the quality better that way



as an aside..im listening to piece of mind while writing this

Mikesn
Emeritus
April 4th 2006


3707 Comments


It's a greatest hits, not a best of compilation.

But, Aces High is a single, and it's missing. =/

I won't be purchasing this any time soon.

Fade.To.Black
April 7th 2006


85 Comments

Album Rating: 4.0

It's an Awesome album if you judge that by the quality of the songs on it. But i do encourage anyone to buy the original albums especially Powerslave, Sevventh Son Of A Seventh Son and Iron Maiden, oh and Number Of The Beast, and Peice Of Mind, and Dance of Death and Brave new World And and and........Just buy all of them. Dont Download, Buy.



You have to be logged in to post a comment. Login | Create a Profile





STAFF & CONTRIBUTORS // CONTACT US

Bands: A B C D E F G H I J K L M N O P Q R S T U V W X Y Z


Site Copyright 2005-2023 Sputnikmusic.com
All Album Reviews Displayed With Permission of Authors | Terms of Use | Privacy Policy