Review Summary: Choosing between this and St. Anger (Metallica) is proving to be hard.
Megadeth has been a band who always tried to take different roads, their whole career has been about experiments. Its probably one of the softest Megadeth albums ever, but does that make it bad"
Yes it does, this is the worst Megadeth album.
I believe Mustaine tried to do the same thing with super collider that he wanted to 1999's risk, but the difference is that Risk was a DECENT album in their 'pop-rock' genre but a truly disappointing album for Megadeth fans. However, Super Collider takes an approach on the modern heavy metal sound, and the fact is, that this does not even sound close to anything that Megadeth's made in the past.
The lyrics are cheesy, a few good riffs here and there but songs don't feel well constructed.
No memorable moments.
Go check out Dystopia instead.