Porcupine Tree
In Absentia


5.0
classic

Review

by MM23 USER (2 Reviews)
January 24th, 2006 | 18 replies


Release Date: 2002 | Tracklist


Well, here we are at last, on the doorstep of a review of one of the greatest albums to grace this Earth since Opeth's Morningrise. I simply cannot put into words how incredible this album is to me. Maybe I'm just a fanboy, but the result is the same: I would marry this album if it were possible.

Why? Let me tell you. Never have I heard a band anything like Porcupine Tree. Every single album they release just blows me away, and for some reason, In Absentia blew me the way the most out of any of them. This is the kind of stuff Progressive is all about. Porcupine Tree simply blurs the lines between genres, and does it so absolutely elegantly. It's the only way I think I can put it into words. One second the song will be on a beautiful acoustic ballad, then the next it'll be slowly merging into a soft electrical one, then the next it will be an assault of heavy, distorted electric.

The album is also innovative in the fact it's a concept album---a very depressing one, in fact. The album is (supposedly, I'm not COMPLETELY sure) about this kid growing up to become a serial murderer. And, to me at least, it portrays this mood not through the lyrics---but more through the mood of the music, which is why it's just so incredible to me.

Sure---maybe a few of the songs on In Absentia are a bit lackluster compared to others, but I don't think any of them don't shine in at least one way or another. On with the review!

Lineup
Steven Wilson - guitar, vocals
Richard Barbieri - synthesizers
Colin Edwin - bass guitar
Gavin Harrison - drums and percussion

The album begins with the song Blackest Eyes, which I think is a very odd song indeed. It begins with a very Opeth-like barrage of heavy, distorted electric, and leads you on thinking it's going to be a heavier song---then, somehow, it changes at the last second into an incredible melodic chorus done with heavy acoustic. It works well. You'd think it wouldn't, but somehow they make the merge perfectly. Maybe I'm just biased... all in all, a wonderful song, and definitely one of the better ones on the album.
5/5

Then we move onto Trains, which is yet another gem. Such a beautiful, beautiful song. It begins with a simple acoustic riff repeated over and over, with Steven singing somewhat hauntingly, then it slowly blends into a medium-heavy electric prog rush with an amazing chorus and an awesome melody. Again, simply one of the best songs on the album. The lyrics are weird and abstract as always, but they portray the mood of the song perfectly. Songs like this are what prog is all about...
5/5

Lips of Ashes. An underrated song if there ever was one. Sure, it's simplistic, and it's also pretty short... but the depth of emotion portrayed through the song... amazing. The acoustic hook played over and over is nothing special---but the dark, haunting, beautiful vocal passages are what make the song amazing up until around 3:25, when you get a really nice solo played along with the acoustic hook. It's simplistic, but like I said... the depth of emotion and the mood are portrayed perfectly. Great song to fall asleep to, as well. Yet another prog gem!
4/5

And then we have arguably one of the best, if not the best, song on the album: The Sound of Muzak. The vocals are odd as always (Porcupine Tree lyrics are always weird) but the musicmanship is OHMYGODORGASMINMYPANTS quality. I have no idea what instrument, or how heavy the studiowork is in this song, but I *love* the sound of the intro. ***ing catchy as hell vocal passages too.

"It's one of the wonders of the world,
and it's going down, it's going down, I know.
It's one of the wonders of the world,
and no one cares, no one cares enough."

What the hell does it mean? I have no idea, but it sounds great! Awesome song. And it ends with a pretty kickass solo, too... but yeah.
5/5

The next song on the album, Gravity Eyelids, doesn't quite match up to the other songs on the album. But is it bad? No. Not by a longshot. One of the longer songs on the album, droaning on to nearly 8 minutes. Which is probably it's main flaw. It should be shorter. There are just huge stretches of... nothing, for half of the song. But, the chorus, and some of the vocal passages, as said for other aforementioned songs, are just beautiful. And, once more, the lyrics are weird as hell! Good solo and electric work around 4:10, too.
4/5

Then we get to the only instrumental of the album, Wedding Nails. Once more, underrated as hell. This song kicks a lot of ass, even though it drags on a bit too long than it should. It's kind of hard to describe---give it a listen yourself. Wedding Nails proves that Porcupine Tree doesn't just know how to rock---they know how to roll, too.
4/5

Prodigal is another one of my favorites. Similiar to Trains, but without the acoustic introduction. It just gets straight to the meat---the electric. It's a softer, more poppish song, but good nonetheless. The chorus is also excellent. Nothing especially exceptional, though.
4.5/5

The next song, .3, is a cool song---but... unfortunately, it's quite boring. I guess no album can be perfect, but... .3 isn't really quite on par with the rest of the album at all. It's just the same bass hook played for 5:25. Still, a very pretty song.
3/5

The Creator Has A Mastertape is a ***ing weird ass song. Man, what the hell is this? Haha, it makes no sense! But it's not a bad song, even if it is weird, even for Porcupine Tree standards... in fact, I'd even go so far as to say it's good enough to be REALLY good. It's just... different than the other songs on the album. Fast paced compared to most Porcupine Tree, too. Really good song, another one of my favorites on the album.
4.5/5

Heartattack in a Layby is a very depressing track, amidst a sea of lighthearted prog. Simplistic, with a sad acoustic hook (and the ocassional short electric burst), this song has a very high mood of death about it, and definately excels at what it's supposed to convey. Decent song, with a beautiful chorus.
3.5/5

Approaching the end of the album, you find the little track Strip the Soul hiding at track number 11. Catchy. Good lyrics. Good chorus. Good vocal passages. Good musicmanship. In fact, the word "good" basically embodies this song entirely. It's not the best, it's not the worst. An above average track that is just fun as heck to listen to.
4.5/5

And finally you get to the end, and whereas you'd expect other bands to end their albums with a bang, instead you get the song Collapse The Light Into Earth. Meh. Mixed feelings on this one. I'm a big fan of orchestra-like piano ballads... but this seems kind of thrown together in a rush. It has maybe one melody, played over and over and over and over and over again for almost 6 minutes. Not a horrible song, but probably the worst on the album. Pretty big dissapointment, and a bad way to end the album.
2.5/5

All in all, Porcupine Tree's In Absentia is a solid album that takes you on one wild prog-filled ride through a billion different sounds and moods. It's very multi-riveted, with every song possessing multiple hooks and melodies that make you think "Wow, they must have really put their hearts and souls into this."

I love In Absentia, and I'm hoping maybe you'll give it a try if you haven't already---I'm hoping you'll be as pleased as I was.

Pros:
-- Beautiful. Captures the word in every possible meaning.
-- Very inspired and original---unlike anything else I've ever heard.
-- Opeth's Mikael Akerfeldt does some awesome backing vocals and solos.
-- Incredibly melodic and mood-conveying guitarwork and vocalwork.
-- Odd, but well-fitting lyrics.
-- Fun as hell to listen to.

Cons:
-- .3 and Collapse The Light Into Earth are mediocre at best.
-- Some parts drag on a little too long and become repetitive.

And there you have it. Prog at it's best, folks.

Always the summers are slipping away.


user ratings (3242)
4.2
excellent
other reviews of this album
1 of

Comments:Add a Comment 
i am the robots
January 25th 2006


1027 Comments


Very nice review again Chris... blah, not really the biggest fan of PT but they're good.

MM23
January 25th 2006


33 Comments

Album Rating: 5.0

And yes, I know I'm going to get a lot of shit from people who hate In Absentia compared to other PT. Bring it on!

pulseczar
January 25th 2006


2385 Comments

Album Rating: 3.0 | Sound Off

Okay review, was fairly discriptive for a track by track review, but doesn't explain why the album deserves a 5/5. I used to like this album more, but they just sound like a bland rock band on too many of the tracks, The Creator has A Mastertape, Trains, Gravity Eyelids, Heartattack... and Collapse... are the only songs that don't bore me. The rest are just meh. Deadwing and Lightbulb Sun are both much better, and mid-early 90s PT just owns hard.

Zebra
Moderator
January 25th 2006


2647 Comments

Album Rating: 4.0

'Trains' is simply amazing, possibly my favorite PT song next to 'Halo.'



Decent review, you said a lot of things were "cool sounding" but you never explained why and that's what you need to do on a t-b-t review.



In Absenta > Deadwing. This Message Edited On 01.24.06

Storm In A Teacup
January 25th 2006


26980 Comments


No review could beat one of my nominations of overall review of the year


Great band Porcupince Tree, great band.

Jawaharal
January 25th 2006


1832 Comments

Album Rating: 1.5

Okay review, was fairly discriptive for a track by track review, but doesn't explain why the album deserves a 5/5. I used to like this album more, but they just sound like a bland rock band on too many of the tracks, The Creator has A Mastertape, Trains, Gravity Eyelids, Heartattack... and Collapse... are the only songs that don't bore me. The rest are just meh. Deadwing and Lightbulb Sun are both much better, and mid-early 90s PT just owns hard.


I knew it would grow out of ya

This Message Edited On 01.25.06

ColdSilence245
January 26th 2006


6 Comments


I've never listened to the band, I think the name "Porcupine Tree" kind of turned me away, but I read this review and downloaded a few songs and love them all. I really like Trains, Blackest Eyes, and The Sound of Muzak.

Kage
January 26th 2006


1172 Comments

Album Rating: 4.0

I love this album.This Message Edited On 01.25.06

Morvit
January 26th 2006


71 Comments

Album Rating: 3.5

really? the album's about this kid growing up to become a serial murderer?

Zebra
Moderator
January 26th 2006


2647 Comments

Album Rating: 4.0

The first two songs are amazing. and I'm trying to think of any other album that has a better opening and second track.

dustyboy316
January 28th 2006


56 Comments


This is my fav PT album. I love it. Wedding Nails is a great song.

IvortheEngineDriver
February 7th 2006


164 Comments

Album Rating: 4.5

I guess my review wasn't good enough



Great review though, man!



I wrote mine over 2 years ago...so, yeah

Doppelganger
December 19th 2006


3124 Comments

Album Rating: 4.0

Heartattack... definitely deserves a much higher rating. It's probably one of the best off the album. And does anyone else think the section of Gravity Eyelids about 5:15 sounds like the ending of Opeth's The Leper Affinity (not the piano outro)?This Message Edited On 12.19.06

ScelusNefas
December 20th 2006


274 Comments

Album Rating: 5.0

It's really cool if the concept story is true. Very good review, i hope you'll post some other for this group.



I have this, deadwing and stupid dream, i think i'll get lightbulb sun and don't know afer that.



Is there anyone who can tell me if the blackfield album worth a listen and is comparable to this?

This Message Edited On 12.19.06

Motiv3
May 21st 2009


9023 Comments


I've listened to 2 songs.... i think ive found my new favourite band 0.o they seem to have everything id want in a prog rock band, heavy riffing, great acoustics and the vocals are gorgeous, this album is on my list for sure.

PuddleSwimmer
May 21st 2009


1457 Comments

Album Rating: 4.5

Yeah it's a rly good-looking album

Mendigo
May 21st 2009


2299 Comments

Album Rating: 4.0

they seem to have everything id want in a prog rock band, heavy riffing, great acoustics and the vocals are gorgeous, this album is on my list for sure.


make sure to get some Oceansize ;)

also, this is good but Fear of a Blank Planet is better.

PuddleSwimmer
May 23rd 2009


1457 Comments

Album Rating: 4.5

Mendigo, thanks!



I now really really like Oceansize



You have to be logged in to post a comment. Login | Create a Profile





FAQ // STAFF & CONTRIBUTORS // SITE FORUM // CONTACT US

Bands: A B C D E F G H I J K L M N O P Q R S T U V W X Y Z


Site Copyright 2005-2019 Sputnikmusic.com
All Album Reviews Displayed With Permission of Authors | Terms of Use | Privacy Policy