Pink Floyd
Echoes


3.5
great

Review

by mark1991 USER (37 Reviews)
April 21st, 2012 | 15 replies


Release Date: 2001 | Tracklist

Review Summary: A small window teasing a vast universe

Pink Floyd’s career cannot be captured or summarized on a single or even double CD. There have been countless of compilations released over the years, and even though all of them have their merits, none of them can really serve as anything more than a very basic and shallow look at a great band’s legacy and art. Echoes: The Best of Pink Floyd was released in November 2001 and is generally considered the best available Pink Floyd compilation album, but only if you do not take into account the live album Pulse.

The album is divided into two CDs, but really the order of the songs seems jumbled up and the album does not seem to follow a certain pattern. As could be expected not all the band’s albums are represented. Ummagumma, Atom Heart Mother and Obscured by Clouds do not have any songs included, and even though these albums make up the Pink Floyd’s lesser back catalog it would have been a nice surprise to include songs like ‘Fat Old Sun’ and ‘Childhood’s End’.

Pink Floyd enjoyed their hay day during the 70s, when they released four near-flawless albums in a row. Dark Side of the Moon, Wish You Were Here, Animals and The Wall are the band’s most popular albums and for good reason, so rightfully a great portion of the songs are taken from this era. Tracks like ‘Time’, ‘Money’, ‘Comfortably Numb’ and the definition of a perfect 5 minute rock track, ‘Wish You Were Here’, are all recognizable songs for the casual listener and also fan favorites. ‘Sheep’ is taken from Animals, a long and powerfully written social critique with some brilliant guitar work, unfortunately without its companion pieces the song doesn’t quite feel as fulfilling. Still it’s good to see Animals getting some richly deserved exposure.

Monster tracks ‘Echoes’ and the emotional tribute ‘Shine on Your Crazy Diamond’ are also included, although unfortunately at a reduced size. Most bands would have just taken the easy way out, and simply not included 20+ minute tracks on a compilation, it’s not like Pink Floyd didn’t have any other songs to pick. But Pink Floyd never really took the easy way out, so what we get here are chopped up version of great songs. They are still great in this edited version, but when someone is used to gold even silver is seen as an inadequate replacement.

The Barrett era is not forgotten either. This was a different time for the band, with a unique genius driving them forward. It was brought abruptly to an end when Syd Barrett had to leave due to some psychological problems. Gilmour, Waters, Mason and Wright would pay tribute to their comrade frequently in the future. ‘See Emily Play’, ‘Arnold Layne’, ‘Jugband Blues’ and ‘Bike’ are Barrett songs, and they show the earlier more whimsical nature of Pink Floyd. Sadly, the instrumental epic ‘Interstellar Overdrive’ is not included.

As pretty much everyone in this universe and beyond knows, Pink Floyd’s end was anything but smooth. Waters had a falling out with the rest of the members, and after releasing what is essentially a solo album, he left Pink Floyd. Gilmour, Mason and Wright went on and released two decent but at the end disappointing releases to bring to a close Pink Floyd’s musical journey. ‘Learning to Fly’ is a great and very popular Pink Floyd song from this final era. The lyrics are powerful and colorfully descriptive, and although Gilmour’s vocal performance is a bit monotone, it is still a worthy song. ‘High Hopes’ is also one of the band’s best songs, and is also significant since it’s the last song on the very last album, but only a reduced version is included. Fortunately, the song is cut only by about a minute so it comes out relatively unharmed.

Pink Floyd is an album band, and here the listener gets exactly would is expected, snippets of a whole. The casual listener will enjoy hearing the radio hits, but the more avid follower might start missing the unity that is a part of all of the band’s great works of art.



Recent reviews by this author
Butch Walker Left of Self-CenteredPink The Truth About Love
Barenaked Ladies Everything to EveryoneMetallica Death Magnetic
Avril Lavigne Let GoGuns N' Roses G N' R Lies
user ratings (359)
3.8
excellent
other reviews of this album
DesolationRow (2.5)
...

SilentPsycho (0)
...

temporary (3)
...


Comments:Add a Comment 
SgtPepper
Staff Reviewer
April 21st 2012


4508 Comments


Great review, though in my opinion this is at least a 4... or maybe I'm just too big a Floyd fan. And yeah there's a lot of good songs that got neglected here. For example I'm listening to "Let There Be more Light" from Saucer as im writing this, and in my opinion one its of their best songs but sadly didnt make the cut.

KILL
April 21st 2012


81232 Comments


fuck greatest hitz

rockandmetaljunkie
April 21st 2012


8433 Comments

Album Rating: 3.0

Good review i pos'd.

Album is good, although some diamonds are missing.

tarkus
April 21st 2012


5568 Comments


KILL speaks truth


Graveyard
April 21st 2012


6371 Comments


this album only has two songs from a saucerful of secrets?

c'mon bro

Irving
Staff Reviewer
April 21st 2012


7502 Comments


Solid review.

Record companies need to learn that Floyd "Best Of" albums just don't work. The A Foot in the Door compilation that EMI released last year is even worse, shameless money grab that it was. An instant neg if I ever saw one.

DominionMM1
April 21st 2012


18403 Comments


Well done. For a band like Floyd, greatest hits packages just don't work.

JohnnyoftheWell
Contributing Reviewer
April 21st 2012


16669 Comments


They put the worst song from Animals in and forgot Have A Cigar

Digging: Nick Cave and The Bad Seeds - Ghosteen

coolcamjam
September 7th 2012


1 Comments


^^^ Cuz it's easy and enjoyable to get into an old band that literally has a hundred old albums. All you people criticizing the creation of greatest hits comps are complete fanboy trolls. This is a finely arranged comp for the uninitiated who have only heard their most popular songs on the radio and such. Highly recommended.

KILL
September 7th 2012


81232 Comments


lol shut up

someguest
September 7th 2012


29931 Comments


agreed

menawati
September 7th 2012


16587 Comments


Making a Pink Floyd compilation is like fixing wheels onto a tomato - time consuming and totally pointless.

someguest
September 7th 2012


29931 Comments


unless that tomato enjoys travel

menawati
September 7th 2012


16587 Comments


I suppose that would be a tourmato

someguest
September 7th 2012


29931 Comments


hahaha



You have to be logged in to post a comment. Login | Create a Profile





FAQ // STAFF & CONTRIBUTORS // SITE FORUM // CONTACT US

Bands: A B C D E F G H I J K L M N O P Q R S T U V W X Y Z


Site Copyright 2005-2019 Sputnikmusic.com
All Album Reviews Displayed With Permission of Authors | Terms of Use | Privacy Policy