Review Summary:
“Memory & Humanity” is an exercise in indifference
“Memory & Humanity” is an exercise in indifference. The much touted, 2008 “return to form” by Funeral for a Friend was muddled, disorientated and perplexed by its own sense of frailty. Written on the back of the uncharacteristic, “Tales Don’t Tell Themselves”, FFAF promised a more rounded, balanced and retrospective affair.
Much to the dismay of FFAF’s earlier fan base, “Tales Don’t Tell Themselves” was an album hindered by its own ambition, both commercially and artistically. Where as Tales floundered, this album crumbles at the band’s foundation; confused as to whether it should appease its loyalists or continue the daunting journey towards the stadium. Memory and Humanity’s pondering nature, ultimately, proves to be its downfall.
The stodgy Rules and Games re-call the faint undertones of the much-coveted “Casually Dressed & Deep in Conversation” period. Yet, it’s drab and workman like chorus recall the lacklustre moments of “Tales Don’t Tell Themselves”. If anything, it’s a case of a band on autopilot, devoid of the conviction that elevated FFAF to the higher echelons of the international post-hardcore “scene”.
Even as one of the strongest tracks on offer, Constant Illuminations seems an almost un-natural and un-inspired slice of Post-Hardcore. The thundering middle eight, punctuated by the welcomed screams of Ryan Richards proves to be a highlight. However, “Memory & Humanity” proves to be at its best when it looks forward rather than back. The sugar kissed Maybe I Am proves to be a leading stalwart in an otherwise, un-inspired and faltering series of songs. Its chorus and utterly infectious middle eight prove to be simple, yet effective pop rock.
“Memory and Humanity” proves to be an underwhelming response from a band struggling to find a purpose amidst an ever-changing industry. In the aftermath of this album, I questioned, not only, the relevance of Funeral for a Friend, but the role of Funeral for a Friend in today’s music scene. This album proved to be far removed from the essence and charisma that best encapsulated Funeral for a Friend initially.
Avoid.
