Chelsea Grin
Desolation Of Eden


1.5
very poor

Review

by Pr0nogo USER (81 Reviews)
July 15th, 2011 | 14 replies


Release Date: 2010 | Tracklist

Review Summary: The Devil Wears Prada of deathcore antagonise us yet again with an obnoxiously terrible release.

Deathcore is a pretty sad guy, as far as genres go, and with each release from the rather intolerable Chelsea Grin, his life gets progressively sadder. From the steady, depressive chugging to the unimaginably repetitive drum tracks, Desolation of Eden is the mark of another truly sad experience in a genre that already suffers from boring and unimaginative run-of-the-mill half-assery that can only hope to constitute an album.

What the six-piece from Utah's capital city lack in innovation and originality they make up for with sheer irritation and obnoxiousness. I literally had to turn off all of their songs halfway through due to Koehler's ear-raping vocals. Regardless of how repetitive the instrumental work is, it all takes a back seat to the obnoxious screaming that's so asynchronous with the rest of the album that, if you told me the lyrics were written to a different music track, I wouldn't be surprised. Normally, I don't recommend listening to bad music, but if you think bands like Impending Doom or Postmortem Promises are bad, you need to listen to a song like "Recreant".

This band was bad to begin with - their EP made about as much sense as the invention of Christian black rapcore - but seriously. When I heard they were making a new record, I said to myself, "I could cry." Maybe it'll be better, maybe it won't. As for Desolation of Eden, you could chalk this up as another below-average venture into an already suffering genre, but what really gets me is the god-awful sounds that the vocalist emits throughout this record. I can't help but wonder what made them think that it would be a good idea to include Koehler as a vocalist, and even moreso, I can't understand why anyone - even their primarily-scene-ridden fan base - could possibly think that they sounded good. My head is sore. Thanks, Chelsea Grin.Â*Bottom line is, for a band that's bringing back the scene kids into a genre during a predominately-Whitechapel and Oceano era, their 2010 debut does exactly what you'd think: suck.Â*
Case closed.

Recommended Tracks:
Don't even think about listening. That's my recommendation.



Recent reviews by this author
Aenaon Cendres Et SangTrenchRot Necronomic Warfare
Seduced (AT) The ProclamationCarnality Dystopia
Origin OmnipresentSepticflesh Titan
user ratings (663)
2.7
average
other reviews of this album
XxTruexMetalxX (4)
This album is a clear indication that the band is improving, and it is actually pretty great. That i...

peterbraa (2)
BREAKDOWNS + BREAKDOWNS + MORE BREAKDOWNS!!!! = Desolation Of Eden????...



Comments:Add a Comment 
Pr0nogo
July 15th 2011


379 Comments


Dropped some much better deathcore in the suggestions. Even Impending Doom, who I find to be rather average at best, can really offer a lesson or two to these guys in terms of structure and just about anything else.

Also, Animosity and the rest of the suggestions are fucking cuntsmashers. In the good way.

Parallels
July 15th 2011


10146 Comments


Just read your review. Although I didn't neg it, it should be a bit longer.
This just sounds like a long rant/soundoff.

Only sonictheplumber can get away with these shorties

Pr0nogo
July 15th 2011


379 Comments


I'll extend it, yeah. I don't know exactly what there is to elaborate on (maybe more shit about the songs), but I see your point.

I'm pretty sure I garnered that neg from someone who didn't like what I had to say about deathcore as a genre, even though I quite like good deathcore.

Spluger
July 15th 2011


1972 Comments

Album Rating: 2.5

lol Oceano.

fsharptrit0ne
July 15th 2011


4816 Comments


This band is worse than Oceano

piecey
October 25th 2011


28 Comments

Album Rating: 5.0

dont write a review if you already dont like the band before you write it, now you basically typed a couple paragraphs to bash the band and others like it, and you look like a pretty big doucher.

piecey
October 25th 2011


28 Comments

Album Rating: 5.0

just saying guy

CrimsonLies
April 29th 2012


2579 Comments


Lol wut?

Eulogize
April 29th 2012


2996 Comments

Album Rating: 3.0

Used to have this at a 4.....





lol

MalleusMaleficarum
April 29th 2012


16396 Comments

Album Rating: 2.0

no one is surprised

KSK1
April 29th 2012


4118 Comments


This review sucks. The only thing I got out of this was that you think the vocals are terrible. It's relatively short and you spent 70% of it talking about how awful the vocals are, and the other 30% is just a bad metaphor about how you think deathcore is shitty. At no point did you talk about the actual album with the exception of mentioning one song. For the record, im not a fan of this either but this review is garbage.

DeathByAstonishment
May 11th 2012


268 Comments


good review, won't check this out.

Pennywise_M
June 4th 2012


7502 Comments

Album Rating: 3.5

How can someone even dare to call this a "good review".



Alex is one of the most talented lead vocalists to ever work on a Deathcore release. I do recon that at first that his high-pitched scream seems a bit too much, but the more i became to get into the band's mood, the more i came to understand how Alex thrown an amazing work on the vocals (in both LP's). And one thing is to say you don't like it, another is to speak of the man's singing as "ear-rapping vocals". You sound like my father ffs.



Darion, you don't like Chelsea Grin - get it. Should've skipped the review.

XyphynX9
December 13th 2012


137 Comments

Album Rating: 3.5

Whitechapel better? Yes. Impending Doom better? Yes. But these guys shit on Oceano lol



You have to be logged in to post a comment. Login | Create a Profile





STAFF & CONTRIBUTORS // CONTACT US

Bands: A B C D E F G H I J K L M N O P Q R S T U V W X Y Z


Site Copyright 2005-2023 Sputnikmusic.com
All Album Reviews Displayed With Permission of Authors | Terms of Use | Privacy Policy