Asia
Astra


2.5
average

Review

by RavenRock USER (25 Reviews)
June 4th, 2011 | 16 replies


Release Date: 1985 | Tracklist

Review Summary: Right before they went through the infamous downfall, there was one album that salvaged some reputation.

Before Asia completely spiraled into mediocrity for one-and-a-half decades of pure disappointment and horrible attempts at music, Asia released Astra, their last album that ever got any attention. It was a transition from the poppy, tongue-in cheek self-titled debut, and it was very interesting at the time, one of the biggest albums of the early 80's. After a second album that isn't particularly remembered as a great achievement, now here comes Astra (originally titled Arcadia, to follow the number of album names with A), a more serious, far more different look at the band's lyrical career.

Where do you go when your second album fails to impress, whereas your first completely tops charts" Well, the infamous third album came for Asia. Some bands just stop at the second record when they are barely noticed by the media (though groups like Axel Rudi Pell remain strong underground), and Asia would never be the same after Astra, either. Steve Howe left the band and was replaced by the guitarist Mandy Meyer. The tour for Astra was abruptly cancelled, and a lack of media / public attention, John Wetton left after Astra, and Meyer would eventually just leave.

(The album did receive a brief resurgence in popularity in 1997, when the re-release hit #37 on the Billboard 200 for three weeks, and "After the War" would become Angels and Demon's lead guitarist Caesar Faux named it his favorite pop song ever)

The tracks here aren't memorable, however, it's just business as usual in most tracks. There's the usual love song ("Love Now Till Eternity"). At this point, Asia might as well of been beating themselves to death. The later vocalist Geoff Downes will appear with supporting vocals, but is clearly not up to the decent standards of John Wetton. Aside from "After the War", which is an anti-war message, everything here feels repeated, and there's nothing here that they haven't done before. As a matter of fact, "After the War" probably drops the best lyrics on the album:

"One more dead is one more
Then it ought to be
A travesty oh oh
One more missed will be kissed
To eternity
Or purgatory oh oh"

In fact, if their later albums sounded anything like this, then albums like Silent Nation wouldn't of been such an embarrassment. And as with the last two albums, in defense of Astra, are still stellar. The keyboard work is exceptional as usual, containing some good riffs to the standards of bands like Journey. The bass melodies are thumping, and Wetton is still contains some energy, and is mostly tolerable throughout their last truly good release. In fact, it could be the highlight of the album considering that John Payne was such a mediocre vocalist, containing very bland pitches and inflections.

It also marks the first and only time Asia had a message in various parts, and it actually went through completely. However, other bands have had sparse messages throughout their albums, however little they be, and do it better. This is not a pop epic by any means. Asia never really had it in them for records, and Astra is the closest they come to actually achieving some decency, and haven't made a complete embarrassment of themselves, sans the 2008 album Phoenix. Even so, Astra is just about as good as every record before it: slightly above average.

The worst part about Astra is that everything went down from here.

For Asia's Standards: 3.5 / 5
For Music Standards: 2.5 / 5

Recommended Tracks:

After the War
Countdown to Zero


(These are songs that you might actually like from Asia. Arguably, the former is the best song they've ever recorded)

Did I mention that the rock band Phaze likes this album"



Recent reviews by this author
Power of Zeus The Gospel According to ZeusFrank Turner England Keep My Bones
King Crimson In the Court of the Crimson KingAsia Omega
Arcade Fire FuneralRadiohead Kid A
user ratings (43)
Chart.
2.8
good
related reviews

Asia

Arena

Silent Nation

Omega
recommended by reviewer
Journey Raised on Radio
Asia Arena


Comments:Add a Comment 
RavenRock
June 4th 2011


688 Comments


I swear to god, I have never seen a band who actually sucks this much.

Nagrarok
June 4th 2011


8598 Comments


IN THE HEEEAAAT OF THE MOMENT

RavenRock
June 4th 2011


688 Comments


Hey, it's Matthijs van der Lee, the best reviewer of Yes albums and what not.

RavenRock
June 4th 2011


688 Comments


I put in some information I learned from a Hit Parader mag. And I'm trying to review every Asia album.

Nagrarok
June 4th 2011


8598 Comments


Indeed it is, I am glad to see you doing more things that do not already have many reviews, well done sir.

RavenRock
June 4th 2011


688 Comments


Anybody who actually likes Asia is...

Well, you like Asia. That's enough.

RavenRock
June 4th 2011


688 Comments


Sorry Nag, I just mean to review albums that I have listened to thoroughly.

However, the less reviews, the less attention it gets. Nonetheless, thank you van der Lee. Maybe I'll review some Journey.

Tyrael
June 4th 2011


21113 Comments


I liked their debut, but everything after that was just meh. Nice review.

Nagrarok
June 4th 2011


8598 Comments


No apology needed, it's best to start reviewing with albums you know better, but it gets pretty useless when one get its 15th-or-so review. I know what you mean with the attention but keep at it. And Nag will be fine.

RavenRock
June 4th 2011


688 Comments


No, everything after Astra was humiliating. Payne's vocals made me want to shoot myself through the foot without a bulletproof vest on.



RavenRock
June 4th 2011


688 Comments


I don't know if I told you this yet, Mathjis, but your reviews inspire mine.

liveatthegods
June 4th 2011


62 Comments


Well that's a good compliment.

I haven't written any reviews yet, but maybe I'll beat you to reviewing the last Hardline album. I've gotten into live albums that have gotten no reviews yet.

Loanshark
June 4th 2011


333 Comments


"After the War" would become Angels and Demon's lead guitarist Caesar Faux named it his favorite pop song ever

Don't think this is correct. But I've enjoyed reading your recent reviews!

RavenRock
June 4th 2011


688 Comments


Have you even heard of Angels and Demons, Loan?

But thank you nonetheless.

Nagrarok
June 5th 2011


8598 Comments


your reviews inspire mine


That certainly is a nice compliment.

fpcassini
December 9th 2012


20 Comments


I saw Asia during this album`s european tour- Robert Fripp filled in for Steve Howe- best concert of my life!



You have to be logged in to post a comment. Login | Create a Profile





STAFF & CONTRIBUTORS // SITE FORUM // CONTACT US

Bands: A B C D E F G H I J K L M N O P Q R S T U V W X Y Z


Site Copyright 2005-2017 Sputnikmusic.com
All Album Reviews Displayed With Permission of Authors | Terms of Use | Privacy Policy