Jonny Craig
A Dream Is A Question You Don't Know How To Answer


1.5
very poor

Review

by Hovercun7 USER (7 Reviews)
April 23rd, 2011 | 38 replies


Release Date: 2009 | Tracklist

Review Summary: 1 song is good, 2 songs are average, the rest? Ask Jonny, I haven't a clue what happened

Jonny Craig is renouned for being one of the most hit & miss vocalists on the scene right now, hits in the studio, and misses in live performances. He's been kicked out of two bands; Dance Gavin Dance (Although reformed with them late 2010) and just recently, Emarosa (2011). To be kicked out of one band is enough, but two? In any case, with DGD or Emarosa, or any other band he's been affilated with or provided guest vocals for, has always been an average listen, his voice sometimes screeching, sometimes flowing out of the listeners speakers. It was the band in the background that made his voice listenable, as it provided a cushion of softness that almost apologised for his voice screaming down your ear. No-one, bar no-one, asked for a solo record. But Jonny Craig being Jonny Craig has recorded a solo record, and even though at time of review, this record has been floating about a bit, it's only just recently come into the public eye, and people are still discovering it. Which they shouldn't bother doing. Whereas before, you had an excuse to listen to his voice, because he was part of a band, now you don't. Listening to Jonny Craig solo is a bit like dogging in a city centre bus stop- people will give you dirty looks when they see you doing it, and you will almost certainly not get any pleasure, only discomfort.

Besides all of this, there are 3 tracks on this album that are worth even mentioning, and they seem to be the 3 that have been shunted out for video/single release. 7AM, Two Bottles and the Wrong Road, a hefty title you would admit, is probably the albums selling point, as it's a genuinely good song. It has a rhythm, it's not bad vocals at all, and he doesn't mention himself in it, as is Jonny Craig's forte. I must admit, (I have no time girl, To play this game with you) is a lyric that managed to embed itself in my brain for a while, and made me keep coming back to the song. The second track thats worth anything is Istillfeelher Part 3, and even though it's one of these annoying multi-part song series that all of Jonny Craig's bands seem to follow, and even cross-address, such as DGD with The Robot With Human Hair, or the Istillfeelher 'franchise', (many of these songs don't even lyrically follow each other in the first place), it's a relatively good song. Again, it's unique, easy to sing; if only it didn't have that annoying title. The last track, Children of Divorce, (finally a song title that doesn't confuse or leave you gasping for air), is actually a beautifully written ballad about not feeling right or fitting in with a certain someone. It's unique, and it actually feels like top grade stuff.

These 3 songs, however, are not enough to keep the album afloat. The remaining tracks are underwhelming, painful to listen to (in both his voice, and the lyrical nonsense that he's written). There's no depth, no feeling, nothing to entice the listener, nothing that shows he has had a good lengthy musical career with multiple bands. It seems he has leant nothing, and the only thing you can say about this album is that it can't be worse next time, it can only get better.



Recent reviews by this author
Sum 41 Screaming Bloody MurderConditions Fluorescent Youth
Black Stone Cherry Between the Devil and the Deep Blue SeaHyro The Hero Birth, School, Work, Death
The King Blues Punk & PoetryAsking Alexandria Reckless and Relentless
user ratings (329)
3.3
great
other reviews of this album
UO910 (3.5)
To: Jonny. Love, Jonny....

Bitstream (3.5)
In risk of inflating Jonny's already volatile ego, this really isn't that bad....



Comments:Add a Comment 
iFghtffyrdmns
April 23rd 2011


7044 Comments


"sceaming" in the first paragraph should be screaming

"Jonny Craigs forte" in the second paragraph should have an apostrophe

"relitively"
*relatively


oh jonny craig, selling scam macbooks to kids...

Tyrael
April 23rd 2011


21108 Comments


oh jonny craig, selling scam macbooks to kids...

Tbh that has nothing to do with the quality of his music...
edit: 'haven't' should be 'don't have' in your summary

Hovercun7
April 23rd 2011


7 Comments

Album Rating: 1.5

*edits*



that story did make me laugh however

balcaen
April 23rd 2011


3183 Comments


the title "Istillfeelher pt. III is the most unintentionally funny songtitle ever. how many parts were there to his feeling her? why does STILL feeling her have at least three parts?

taxidermist
April 23rd 2011


7265 Comments


I think there's like 4 parts, but i'm not sure. All I know is that I STILL feel her ;_;

Urinetrouble
April 23rd 2011


5771 Comments


album should be called macbooks

taxidermist
April 23rd 2011


7265 Comments


Itilldon'thavemymacbook Pt. X ;_;

Tyrael
April 23rd 2011


21108 Comments


album should be called macbooks

This was released waaaay before that happened.

balcaen
April 23rd 2011


3183 Comments


i already thought DGD's last album should've been called "downtown macbook mountain II"

balcaen
April 23rd 2011


3183 Comments


What I Would Give To Be Australian is easily the best track after Children of Divorce.


interestingly, the former is supposed to be named for the guys from closure in moscow. i'd be embarassed to be on this record. i guess they do get one of the best songs though...

Winsomniac
April 23rd 2011


8831 Comments


Ohohoho!

Well played, Madame Ball-kin. Brought the lulz.

DoubtGin
April 23rd 2011


6879 Comments

Album Rating: 3.0

What I Would Give To Be Australian > rest

taxidermist
April 23rd 2011


7265 Comments


Istillfeelher pt3 is catchy though :3

bloc
April 23rd 2011


70024 Comments


I Still Feel Her is pretty cool

elephantREVOLUTION
April 23rd 2011


3052 Comments

Album Rating: 2.5

"hits in the studio, and misses in live performances."



i've seen jonny live twice, once with emarosa and once with dgd, and he was flawless. the emarosa set was boring as hell, but the whole band was spot on.

Realm
April 23rd 2011


2512 Comments


lose that summary it's urgh

btw the macbook scandal gave us this brilliant masterpiece.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8IEOs6kLIRY

North0House2
April 23rd 2011


6153 Comments


renouned is spelled as: renowned

Spec
April 23rd 2011


39398 Comments

Album Rating: 2.5

What the fuck is so funny guys? My MacBook still isn't here yet.

North0House2
April 23rd 2011


6153 Comments


I got mine a few weeks ago.

MalleusMaleficarum
April 23rd 2011


16396 Comments


album blows



You have to be logged in to post a comment. Login | Create a Profile





STAFF & CONTRIBUTORS // CONTACT US

Bands: A B C D E F G H I J K L M N O P Q R S T U V W X Y Z


Site Copyright 2005-2023 Sputnikmusic.com
All Album Reviews Displayed With Permission of Authors | Terms of Use | Privacy Policy