Cage The Elephant
Thank You Happy Birthday


3.5
great

Review

by SmokingolingUp USER (1 Reviews)
April 4th, 2011 | 10 replies


Release Date: 2011 | Tracklist


The first Cage The Elephant song I've heard was 'In One Ear', their successful single from their first, self-titled album. I thought it was a good bluesy rock song, and I decided to check out the whole record. After a few spins I figured all their songs sound the same and that the album is nothing special. But it was fairly enjoyable. I watched a few recorded live shows on youtube and found out that they are really spectacular. The singer, Matt Shultz was jumping into the crowd, singing while crowd surfing and he basically made the people go mad. This was back in 2009 and I remember thinking that if this band was going to put out another record I'll have to check it out, because I felt like they do have potential.

Then early 2011 their second LP entitled 'Thank You, Happy Birthday' finally came out. I thought that with this album CTE would either prove themselves to be a really awesome band or that it's gonna be exactly like their debut showing that this is just another rock band that will be forgotten in a few years. Neither of the two was the case.

The record kicks off with 'Always Something'. A really promising strart - haunting drum beats and great bass lines, a song that gets you moving. This one showed that the band had matured musically. Great song. The next one is called 'Aberdeen' and it sounds like anything from their debut, maybe with a little more Pixies influence. It's enjoyable though. Then comes the extremely ironic but awesome 'Indy Kidz', a great song with a fantastic one minute bass driven instrumental part at the end.

At this point I really thought that this album is gonna be decent and 'Shake Me Down' made me absolutely sure about it. A touching song with radio friendly melodies, but still being unique in some way. Then came '2024' and with it's only three minutes it easily destroyed my bubble of this record being pure awesomeness. It sounds like something from the first album but it's just terrible. It has really nothing interesting about it, except that it starts to get annoying halfway through.

From this point on the record goes up and down. It still has it's great moments like 'Sabertooth Tiger', a song that I definitely want to see live one day. It's fast, heavy and punk influenced, with Matt going crazy this is sure awesome live. 'Rubber Ball' is a nice and quiet ballad and even 'Sell Yourself' is a pretty good but weird song. It sounds nothing like their debut which makes it even better.
'Around My Head' kinda sounds like '2024' and it isn't much better. Along with 'Right Before My Eyes' it's one of the low points of the album. The worst one is 'Japanese Buffalo' though. It is like a bad joke. I'm not sure it was ment to be taken seriously but I'm sure it was a bad idea to put it on the record. The last song is 'Flow', a pretty good ballad including an acoustic version of 'Right Before My Eyes'. It's a thousand times better than the plugged version.

Cage the elephant showed us that they can make some killer music, but still it looks like they haven't really found their sound yet. To me this record gave them another few years until their next album comes out. Probably that one will consist of quality music only and not just some great songs and some that are average or even worse. So I suggest you to listen to their better songs: Always Something, Indy Kidz, Shake Me Down, Rubber Ball, Sabertooth Tiger and Flow.

And if CTE are going to put out another record you should definitely check it out, it could be a really good one.


user ratings (452)
3.3
great
other reviews of this album
1 of
  • Fugue (3)
    If you listen carefully enough, it’s possible to distinguish the sounds of a band findin...

    SloppyMilkshake (2.5)
    It's not my birthday, but thanks for the gift! Hey...did you happen to keep the receipt by...

    Tikicobra (4)
    Cage the Elephant's sophomore release is a surprisingly fantastic one....

    Eeyah (3.5)
    Cage the Elephant deliver a solid sophomore effort...

  • BlakeMcCoy (3.5)
    A good album with gems wrapped in a bag of strange, facing a new direction....


Comments:Add a Comment 
North0House2
April 4th 2011


6055 Comments


From the summary alone, I can tell that I don't want to be reading this review... So I won't. Fix that thing up man, then I'll read it. I don't want to risk reading a bad review. Since the summary is sub-par, it warns me of a bad review. Just saying.

whywontyoudie
April 4th 2011


3067 Comments


usually, "far from being decent" means it's bad. that was awkward to read.

BludgeonySteve
April 4th 2011


558 Comments


Shake me Down is just so offbeat indie. I kind of like it but it also gnaws at me. Will listen some time.

flalafell
April 5th 2011


689 Comments


negged

letsgofishing
April 5th 2011


1445 Comments


Yeah, this review has some issues.

The main one, it's way too personal. You want to keep "I" statements to a minimum. You want your reviews to be
authoritative and convincing, to convince people that your opinion is absolute fact, and as soon as you throw in
personal adjectives, that illusion of fact is replaced with "this kid is a really shitty writer."

So to give you an idea, your first two paragraphs should of ideally read something like this

"Cage The Elephant have always shown promise. Their breakthrough self titled debut was a recklessly fun filled romp
filled with maniacal pop tunes guaranteed to make you jump up and down, play beer pong, and have the drunken
time of your life. Unfortunately the album was plagued by formulaic songwriting which in time made the entire
experience extremely monotonous. Yet the band always had talent, showcased especially by their shamelessly
entertaining live performances. Cage the elephants second LP "Thank You, Happy Birthday" showcases this talent with
the band expanding their sound into new territories, unfortunately it is plagued by the same problems that the first
album had before."

Obviously, I just typed that out so it's rough. Another thing you want to improve is describing the tracks. Often times
you just state your personal opinion without backing it up with any evidence. for example what makes Japanese
Buffalo a bad joke?

and finally there's a lot of grammar mistakes, incomplete sentences, etc. I know how tempting it is to post a review
after you finish it, but you really have to put some work into editing a piece of writing. That's where you make the
great review, not the first draft, but the second and third.

and by the way, your summary doesn't make any sense, surprised no one's brought that up.

Best advice I can give you mate, read lot's of staff reviews, and see how they do it.

But anyway, I ain't NEG'in this, and if you fix it up a little I'll POS. welcome to the site man. For the record, this is the
longest comment I've ever written. Is it obvious I'm procrastinating or what? :P

kevin234
April 5th 2011


247 Comments


what album is better their first or this one?

kevin234
April 5th 2011


247 Comments


also this is a POS review

kevin234
April 5th 2011


247 Comments


This record is far from being decent, but it shows that the band can make awesome qualitiy music.


WTF

SmokingolingUp
April 5th 2011


1 Comments

Album Rating: 3.5

okay guys it's my first review and I'm just learning english in school. Letsgofishing thanks for the advices, and Kevin234 i think this one is still better than the first one.

letsgofishing
April 5th 2011


1445 Comments


Yeah dude...don't let all the negs get you down, obviously the more you write the better you'll get at it..



You have to be logged in to post a comment. Login | Create a Profile





FAQ // STAFF & CONTRIBUTORS // SITE FORUM // CONTACT US

Bands: A B C D E F G H I J K L M N O P Q R S T U V W X Y Z


Site Copyright 2005-2019 Sputnikmusic.com
All Album Reviews Displayed With Permission of Authors | Terms of Use | Privacy Policy