Protest the Hero



by Tyrael USER (28 Reviews)
March 31st, 2011 | 39 replies

Release Date: 2011 | Tracklist

Review Summary: Scurrilous might just be Protest The Hero's most fully realised effort to date.

Protest the Hero have never been your ordinary neighborhood band. They're a band of extremes, and they are known for their ability to blend these extremes together in a fresh and interesting fashion. Needless to say that after the massive success they garnered with their previous efforts, Kezia and Fortress, their newest release Scurrilous was being hyped quite a bit. However, even though expectations were sky high, Scurrilous doesn't disappoint. Quite the contrary, Scurrilous might just be Protest The Hero's most fully realised effort to date.

Scurrilous sees Protest the Hero taking a (small) break from the aggression and slowly evolving towards a more powerful progressive sound in which they amplify the focus on the melodic elements in their songs. This makes the songs feel more like a fully realised musical project rather than simply gripping you with highly technical riffs and complicated musical arrangements. Of course, melody isn't everything, and Protest The Hero is a very technically proficient band, so it would be a waste to not utilize the band's abilities to their fullest. That is why there's still plenty of technicality to be found here and their old musical tricks like the start-stop sections and the sudden tempo changes are still part of the toolbox. A good example is the album's most aggressive track 'Tongue-Splitter' which is just pumping with adrenaline and might just be the single best thing Protest The Hero have ever done. The difference between the technical parts on Scurrilous and those that can be witnessed on Fortress is that they seem to fit more into place this time around. These elements combined make the album come off as very slick and polished, but it might take a few listens to get used to. The sad part about Scurrilous is that it once again clearly points out who the weakest link of the band is: their drummer, Moe Carlson. Sure, he gets the job done, but it seems that just keeping up with the band was taking up all his time, so his overall performance turns out to be pretty stale. Luckily, the rest of the band are playing top-notch, so the drums turn out to be only a minor issue.

The band, or rather the band minus their drummer's performance may be top-notch, but the one thing that was destined to make or break Scurrilous is their lead vocalist and newly assigned lyricist Rody Walker. His vocal capabilities, consisting of an overall powerful voice, a strong falsetto, competent screams and even an occasional growl have always been a point of debate and his vocals will probably be the main point that people will like/dislike about Scurrilous. Rody's actual vocal performance is quite strong, even if you take into account that he is barely utilizing his screaming (or his growling) abilities. His screechy vocals combine well with the more progressive and melodic feel of the album, such as on the standout track 'C'est La Vie'. It is actually quite impressive how he manages to bring so much variation into the record . Not that the record wasn't already very varied to begin with, but Rody's vocals are a welcome addition. Still, Rody is not solely relying on his powerful cleans. You'll still encounter some fragments of his screaming abilities once in a while, like on the anthemic 'Tandem' or the aforementioned 'Tongue-Splitter' but they are still scarcely used throughout the album. Frankly, that is for the best, since more of his screams would probably not fit in with the overall less aggressive feel off the album anyway.

Whatever the case, Rody is obviously at the top of his game here and it is admirable how much effort he seems to have put into the lyrics, which are sadly not as good as the ones on their previous efforts. Still, they are not that bad and they do offer an interesting perspective on life. There is a lot of sarcasm hidden in his lyrics, and if you listen closely they might even surprise you. There are a few hiccups to be found in the lyrics, but the band manages to cover those up nicely. Rody wasn't the only one writing the lyrics for Scurrilous though, three songs written by their bassist, the guy with quite possibly the most awesome name of all time: Arif Mirabdolbaghi. And they are as good as ever. 'C'est La Vie' sees the band taking an interesting ironic spin on the theme of suicide, or 'Sex Tapes' which is a delightful parody on today's ever growing grip of the media. The third song, 'Moonlight', isn't all that special lyrically but the song is powerful enough as it is. The lyrical themes on Scurrilous are very varied, and this surely makes the album even more entertaining. The shift to a more open approach on the lyrics seems to have been for the best, because on Scurrilous the band have delivered some of their best and most honest lyrics to date. You could say that they have 'matured'. Well, maybe only in their lyrical approach, but the more personal take on certain matters helps the album feel more cohesive, and it certainly makes Scurrilous stand out as something more than just the next step in their musical career.

In conclusion: Scurrilous is the soundtrack to a wild roller coaster ride with a lot of variation, mind blowing melodic power, personal lyrics and fantastic musical arrangements that will leave you dazzled for a very long time to come. Taking all this into consideration, Scurrilous is definitely the next step in Protest The Hero's ever progressing quest for greatness. It'll be interesting to see where they will be going next.

Recent reviews by this author
Deathspell Omega DroughtMarina and The Diamonds Electra Heart
Coeur de Pirate BlondedEUS Keep You Close
Cruachan Blood on the Black RobeAosoth III - Violence & Variation

user ratings (1827)
other reviews of this album
1 of
  • Athom EMERITUS (4)
    Truth be told, it's getting a bit ridiculous how they're able to consistently be this damn...

    MTObsidian (4)
    While the lyrics might leave you wanting, the overall superior musicality and feel of this...

    jitteryzeitgeist (4)
    Make no mistake about it: Scurrilous is good. It's very, very good....

    TheLetter4 (4)
    Prog-metal’s Heroes come back more vigorous and aggressive than ever....

  • MetallicmanD1 (5)
    Protest the Hero return with a masterpiece that rivals even their best offerings so far....

    niccos16 (3.5)
    Progression- For Better or Worse, Whatever as Always...

    Waior (2)
    Cut and paste....

    GLaDOS (3.5)
    A solid release for any fans of power metal, progressive metal, technical metal or just Pr...

Comments:Add a Comment 
March 31st 2011


So I finally decided to post this... Took me too goddamn long, and it still feels unfinished.
Positive criticism is appreciated etc...

Digging: Chelsea Wolfe - Hiss Spun

March 31st 2011


Album Rating: 2.0

Well done review, though not a fan of these guys.

"Quite on the contrary" - should be quite the contrary

March 31st 2011


All right, thanks man!

March 31st 2011


Album Rating: 2.0

np, pos'd

March 31st 2011


Album Rating: 2.5


March 31st 2011


he manages to bring so much variation into the record .

Great review Ty, pos.

March 31st 2011


Album Rating: 3.0

very detailed and well written review Tyr!!!

as for the lyrics, C'est La Vie is maybe their best song yet

March 31st 2011


Album Rating: 2.0

Hated this album.

March 31st 2011


yeah this album isn't very good.

March 31st 2011


I'm with Crysis, this album really sucks. Good review, Thomas, I like what you did with this.

March 31st 2011


The vocals ruined it for me this time.

March 31st 2011


Album Rating: 2.5

I actually enjoyed this review, felt it said something new in comparison to the plethora of other reviews the albums garnered.


March 31st 2011


Album Rating: 5.0

fantastic review!

March 31st 2011


Album Rating: 2.0 | Sound Off

where are you from?

March 31st 2011


Album Rating: 2.5 | Sound Off

termites and c'est la vie are all you need

March 31st 2011


Hated this album.

March 31st 2011


Album Rating: 3.5

"a fully realised musical project rather than simply gripping you with strongly technical riffs and complicated musical arrangements"



great review, album grew off me a bit.

Staff Reviewer
March 31st 2011


Album Rating: 4.0 | Sound Off

Tyraelxy, this is by far your best review yet. Holy cow. Very impressed. Pos.

April 1st 2011


where are you from?

I hail from Belgium!
The vocals ruined it for me this time.

I am a sucker for Rody's vocals so yeah...

Thanks to all you guys for your ongoing support and especially to Gyromania, it really means a lot. Oh and Aids I fixed that niggle, thanks man!

April 1st 2011


Good review. I'm gonna go with my instincts and not check this out. The few tracks I've heard from this band haven't impressed me at all so I'm just gonna steer clear of this.

Digging: Swallow the Sun - The Morning Never Came

You have to be logged in to post a comment. Login | Create a Profile


Bands: A B C D E F G H I J K L M N O P Q R S T U V W X Y Z

Site Copyright 2005-2017
All Album Reviews Displayed With Permission of Authors | Terms of Use | Privacy Policy