by Zebra USER (177 Reviews)
October 25th, 2005 | 82 replies

Release Date: 1984 | Tracklist

R.E.M. has been around since 1981, that’s when they released there debut album Murmur. There next album is Reckoning which is there sophomore album and I would like to say that they avoid the sophomore slump. R.E.M. has released a total of 13 albums and out of all of them this is my favorite R.E.M. album. I’m a big fan of this band and this is my favorite album, just ahead of New Adventures In Hi-Fi. The thing that makes this album a cut above all other R.E.M. albums is that it is catchy, accessible, no weak tracks, and great lyrics. Every other R.E.M. album I own has at least one weak track, but Reckoning has no weak tracks. Reckoning consists of catchy jangle pop tunes, catchy melodies, thoughtful lyrics, and the best part is that none of these songs sound the same. If you want an easy way to get into R.E.M. Reckoning is defiantly the place to start.

This album is one of those albums that never gets tiring. While these songs are simple and catchy they still avoid coming off as boring and cheesy. There are no real popular radio hits and this album, but that doesn’t matter because all of these songs stand well on there own. “Harborcoat”is one of the catchy most accessible songs that R.E.M. has ever produced. It’s jangle pop, laid back feel is makes this song fun to sing along to. “Don’t Go Back To Rockville” is an alt/folk/country rock song that is completely different from the first track. “Little America” is a very well done raw rock song that ends the album, I like this because R.E.M. usually ends there album with soft folk tunes. “Camera” is the longest and most depressing song off the album. It is slow melancholy and gives you a break from the regular jangle pop tunes. My favorite song “Second Guessing” is a catchy rocker that actually has good pump up value and once you get the song stuck in your head you can’t get it out. This is an alt/rock album that has amazing guitar riffs, melodies, lyrics, and replay value. R.E.M. mixes a this album up by putting in some alt/country songs that don’t keep things from being monotonous. The slower tracks are not filler, they give this album depth and are very well done. The drumming and guitar playing stands out, the guitar plays catchy riffs and contributes to the melody while the drums do the same. Reckoning is defiantly a good album if you want catchy rock tunes, with a few slower folk songs. The melodies are incredible and R.E.M. keeps things accessible. The thing that makes Reckoning stand out is it’s ability to get three and four songs stuck in your head at a time. Even the slower tracks have catchy hooks that keep you coming back for more. While other R.E.M. albums made me yawn, Reckoning intrigues me because of how they can create catchy tracks and still have enough depth to make me want to listen to this album more.

I guess you could call this a pop album. In my opinion this is an alt/rock album for sure, but because some of these songs have a jangle pop feel people refer to this as a pop album. Reckoning features beautiful backing vocals, amazing melodies, and chiming guitars. Stripe’s lyrics are at there best “When the bull’s on his hooves, when you gather friends by the tower
If you try to refuse, will they judge your worth by the hour"” Stripe has the ability to combine some darker lyrics in with catchy rock songs. All of these songs have a ton of emotion, especially “Time After Time (Annelise)” and “Don’t Go Back To Rockville.” This album isn’t depressing at all and it’s not a dark album either, the lyrics can be dark and sometimes depressing but the music is not. Stripe also avoids mumbling as much as he did on Murmur. You can usually hear his vocals clearly and it only took me a few times to get into his vocals. Reckoning is a very easy album to get into. The songs are catchy, the vocals are crisp and clear and the music isn’t that complex. If you’re looking for some deep folk tunes try Automatic For The People. Reckoning is quite upbeat and doesn’t get dark and depressing unlike other R.E.M. albums.

There isn’t a wide variety of instruments used. A guitar, and drums dominate most of this album. While these two instruments don’t sound like they would make the album fun they actually do. The guitar is a huge standout because it appears in virtually every song and it has a huge roll. The guitar riffs are brilliant and dominate the sound of “Seven Chinese Brothers” and “Harborcoat.” Even on the slower tunes the guitar is providing a raw, rough sound that is great when mixing with Stripes stale vocal delivery. The drums are not really a standout but they give the album a rougher edge. There are no pounding drum beats but the drums take a huge roll in the music. This music isn’t complex, hard rocking or soft. Reckoning is an album that consists of catchy alt/rock and jangle pop tunes, there isn’t anything dark or hard rocking about it. While some people may be turned off by this I think it’s great. Reckoning is really accessible and it just never gets old. While some of these songs are really poppy and catchy it is tied together by the deeper, slow paced tracks.

There isn’t a lot more I can say about this album. Catchy guitar riffs, deep lyrics, and amazing melodies. There is nothing complex about Reckoning, it is a simple alt/rock album. While I usually enjoy more complex, electronic, experimental albums Reckoning is one of my favorite alt/rock/pop albums of all time. Even though I say pop songs, these songs aren’t overly poppy by any means. You could say that Green Day is a pop band, that being said R.E.M. is a more alt/rock band IMO because they sound nothing like what is considered “pop” music. The real pleasure that this album brings is replay value. Catchy songs and replay value usually don’t go together very well, but Reckoning succeeds when it comes to that. The few darker songs that this album features keeps things from getting overly repetitive and gives Reckoning some depth. If you enjoy alt/rock, or jangle pop music this album is nothing less than perfect. Even if you aren’t a jangle pop fan this album is still fantastic. I don’t usually like music like this but Reckoning is a huge acception. R.E.M. was one of the greatest underground rock bands in the 80's and Reckoning is what makes that statement true. Reckoning is in my top five favorite alt/rock/pop albums of all time. While Reckoning may not be as popular as other R.E.M. albums it is just as good, if not better.

Overall Rating - 5/5

Album Art : http://athensmusic.net/images/images/coverart/rem_reckoning.jpg

Pros :
Catchy tracks
Slower folk influenced tracks are brilliant

.....If you don’t like jangle-pop or alt/rock music than don’t get this

Recommended Tracks :
“Seven Chinese Brothers”
“Don’t Go Back To Rockville”

Recent reviews by this author
The Dead C Secret EarthJohn Coltrane Lush Life
Crystal Castles Crystal CastlesUlaan Khol I
Four Tet RingerHarmonia Musik von Harmonia
user ratings (539)
other reviews of this album
ToxicBadger (4.5)
R.E.M. follow up Murmur with another classic record...

Jack Fraser (4)
Reckoning is a rock-solid and consistent collection of indie rock songs that tentatively advances th...

Comments:Add a Comment 
October 25th 2005


Man am I lucky, my two favorite reviewers reviews back to back.

Anways, this has made me want to give murmur another chance.

Excellent work as usual.

October 25th 2005


yay im a fav of cheeto's

great review Zebra, i've never heard of this album before, Ive only heard Murmer, Document and Automatic for the People, all three are good.

October 25th 2005


Album Rating: 4.5

^^^I'll edit, thanks.

Thanks for the comments and feedback guys. This Message Edited On 10.25.05

December 1st 2005


Album Rating: 5.0

Great review of my second favorite album by them (I like Life's Rich Pageant better). I guess it's fitting that I live in the town they're from...

The Jungler
March 19th 2006


Great Reveiw

Harborcoat is amazing.This Message Edited On 03.19.06

April 22nd 2006


Album Rating: 4.0

I like this album. It's a nice step forward from the first and you can hear the band developing. The tunes are strong and well performed, and the first four really get things started nicely. I feel Camera and Time After Time are a couple of missteps, but that is nitpicking. And (Don't Go Back To) Rockville in one of the best things REM has ever done, IMO...Very nice review, too...This Message Edited On 04.22.06

Two-Headed Boy
July 16th 2006


Album Rating: 4.5

This is probably my new favorite R.E.M. album.

July 14th 2008


Album Rating: 5.0

my second favorite r.e.m. album behind automatic for the people

October 27th 2008



fix it :p

June 28th 2009


Album Rating: 5.0

nope, now this IS my favorite of theres

October 20th 2010


Album Rating: 4.5

Bump. Because it's an amazing album, and a well written review. "Harborcoat" is amazing.

Digging: Death Angel - Humanicide

Staff Reviewer
October 20th 2010


harborcoat is my favorite r.e.m. song

February 3rd 2011


Album Rating: 4.0

Strong album. To me much better than Murmur.

Much songs are good...or better.

My favorites: South Central Rain (I'm Sorry), Pretty Persuasion and Camera.

May 17th 2011


camera is very joy division/ slint sounding in the verses

May 17th 2011


Album Rating: 4.0

9 is the only song on here I really like but it is one of my favorites. I just can't dig their older stuff (I know I know... sacrilege).

September 1st 2012


"even if AFTP has some crazy good standouts"

All songs

September 1st 2012


Album Rating: 4.0

i dunno man murmer is damn good

September 3rd 2012


Album Rating: 4.5

They're both classics

February 18th 2013


good rem

Digging: Deathspell Omega - The Furnaces of Palingenesia

February 19th 2013


really wish they would have made more songs like (don't go back to) rockville

You have to be logged in to post a comment. Login | Create a Profile


Bands: A B C D E F G H I J K L M N O P Q R S T U V W X Y Z

Site Copyright 2005-2017 Sputnikmusic.com
All Album Reviews Displayed With Permission of Authors | Terms of Use | Privacy Policy