Cradle of Filth
Thornography


3.5
great

Review

by FilthyBorgir USER (5 Reviews)
November 21st, 2010 | 22 replies


Release Date: 2006 | Tracklist

Review Summary: Thornography is very Heavy Metal oriented probably the best "gateway album" into Cradle of Filth.

Either you love them or hate them; they seem to never please people that come across their music. Yes, Cradle of Filth does change their sound after every new release whether it is instrumentally, vocally, change in the symphonies, ect…, and by doing so they’re always called a sellout band. Plus if they didn’t change their sound with every release in some sort of way the same people will go and accuse them of not being creative and so on and so on.

All in all it's an awesome album, but the sad part of Thornography is that the very beginning of the album really depicts themselves away from their symphonic sides of their talent. But the symphonies get back at the very end of the album strongly, and there are a few piano riffs here and there. The stand out of the symphonies is all in the instrumental piece “Rise of the Pentagram” and “Under Huntress Moon”.

Thornography is also one of Cradle of Filth’s one of the most guitar oriented album they’ve ever released. You’ll know what I mean when hear the more melodic songs in the album such as “The Foetus of A New Day Kicking”, "The Byronic Man", and “Cemetery and Sundown”. Paul even gets to work on some pretty good solos such as the one on “Tonight in Flames”. Now, with the Bass guitar it’s really vivid because Paul and Charles play some low tuned power chords throughout the album, and by those power chords being tuned low results in the hearing of blast beats complimenting the Bass. Even the Bass parts are melodic in its own way, prime example would have to be a few parts in “Dirge Inferno” and “Tonight in Flames” were there is perfect stopping on the guitars that allows you (the listener) to hear Dave play a very technical bass riff.

Now with the drums, after the recording, Adrian Erlandsson left the band so he could pay more attention to his side project bands. Cradle of Filth then got Martin Skaroupka to tour with them after wards; we don’t really see Martin’s true ability to play the drums until Godspeed on the Devil’s Thunder. The drums more or less keep a consistent beat in most songs, what I mean by that is that the parts aren’t really trying to show off until the instrumental piece “Rise of the Pentagram”. Like I said earlier the blast beats compliment the Bass parts and there’s a lot of perfect timing on those blast beats.

Vocally as it goes Dani Filth doesn’t use his signature vocal style as much, not totally sure why maybe he had vocal issues in those recording day for Thornography. He predominantly uses a death growl in all of the songs; he sometimes uses his high pitched screech. In “The Foetus of A New Day Kicking” there’s something special about the song with Dani’s vocals he actually uses clean vocals in the song during the chorus and it’s not bad either. There are also a couple of guest appearances. One of them is Ville Valo who is featured at the very end of “The Byronic Man” it’s very short lived, so if you don’t like his vocals your ears are just plugged by your fingers for about a minute. Dirty Harry is the other featured appearance in the Heaven 17 cover “Temptation”. I didn’t think the cover was bad but it’s not going to be worth your time if you’re not a fan of her vocals.

In the end of it all Thornography may not be Cradle of Filth’s more popular album to many people that have heard their other work before. But it’s probably the best first time Cradle of Filth experience. The reason why I would call this the best first time Cradle of Filth experience or “gateway album” to their other albums, because it’s more of a heavy metal album than compared to a Symphonic Black metal album. I hate to say it but its sound is more of a mainstream metal album. So, if you’ve never heard any of Cradle of Filth’s work before this album might be a good start.

In actuality I believe this album is a 3.3.


user ratings (692)
2.9
good
other reviews of this album
Hawks (4.5)
Simply one of the most underrated, under appreciated metal albums ever made....

jameskukucka (4.5)
"Thornography," is the seventh full-length release from the symphonic extreme metal band Cradle of F...

Shadows (4)
Once again, Cradle of Filth has proven that they never write the same album twice, breaking creative...



Comments:Add a Comment 
FilthyBorgir
November 21st 2010


1334 Comments

Album Rating: 4.0

3rd review. Tell me what you think.

Hawks
November 21st 2010


75358 Comments

Album Rating: 4.5

Nice to see you cleaned it up a bit. Pretty good review overall.

FilthyBorgir
November 21st 2010


1334 Comments

Album Rating: 4.0

Thanks man, I thought it was a good Improvement.

Hawks
November 21st 2010


75358 Comments

Album Rating: 4.5

As for the album, it's my favorite of their post-Midian stuff, which most people disagree with.

AngelofDeath
Emeritus
November 21st 2010


16276 Comments


Summary doesn't make a lot of sense. Should probably be "Thornography is very heavy metal oriented and probably the best 'gateway album' into Cradle of Filth." Review's not bad though.

FilthyBorgir
November 21st 2010


1334 Comments

Album Rating: 4.0

@Hawks It was my "gateway album"

@AngelofDeath thanks for pointing that out I'll try to fix it.

Hawks
November 21st 2010


75358 Comments

Album Rating: 4.5

Yeah it was my gateway album too.

FilthyBorgir
November 21st 2010


1334 Comments

Album Rating: 4.0

Followed along by Godspeed for me. But my first song was Nymphetamine (fix).

Hawks
November 21st 2010


75358 Comments

Album Rating: 4.5

The first time I ever heard Cradle was the live video of From the Cradle to Enslave.

FilthyBorgir
November 21st 2010


1334 Comments

Album Rating: 4.0

Sweet.

ShadowRemains
November 21st 2010


26801 Comments

Album Rating: 1.5

.....

Terrifyer
November 21st 2010


3403 Comments


cool stories bros

Oneiron
November 22nd 2010


204 Comments

Album Rating: 1.5

This album sucks. It's bland, and boring. They rip riffs from other bands, Dani's voice is at its worst here, and the drumming sounds uninspired and lifeless.

Jips
November 22nd 2010


1147 Comments


first cradle i heard was Nymphetamine when i was a freshman in HS... i thought it was fucking terrible(wasnt really an extreme metal fan then)...

then i got hooked on dusk and her embrace as i was getting into BM...

havent really listened to their newer stuff... is it really worth a listen?

FilthyBorgir
November 22nd 2010


1334 Comments

Album Rating: 4.0

Both new and old CoF is all worth the listen

Hawks
November 22nd 2010


75358 Comments

Album Rating: 4.5

Most people will tell you it's not worth it, but it's all good stuff. People just like to hate them because it's cool.

FilthyBorgir
November 22nd 2010


1334 Comments

Album Rating: 4.0

Or maybe they think they're a "sellout" because they make every album different.

Terrifyer
November 22nd 2010


3403 Comments


fuck da haters yo







but this one kinda sucks

FilthyBorgir
November 22nd 2010


1334 Comments

Album Rating: 4.0

I hate haters, but I'm guilty for hating Justin Bieber.

Irving
Emeritus
November 29th 2010


7497 Comments


Review is solid in terms of matter and structure and organization, but its biggest crime is being waaaaaay too conversational. To put it bluntly, a review really shouldn't be sounding like this when I read it in my head. Also consider adding some background info for the benefit of us non-metalheads (like me haha).

That said, there is some inherent improvement which I'm sensing in your writing. Do keep at it dude. I look forward to reading your fourth =)



You have to be logged in to post a comment. Login | Create a Profile





FAQ // STAFF & CONTRIBUTORS // SITE FORUM // CONTACT US

Bands: A B C D E F G H I J K L M N O P Q R S T U V W X Y Z


Site Copyright 2005-2019 Sputnikmusic.com
All Album Reviews Displayed With Permission of Authors | Terms of Use | Privacy Policy