Trophy Scars
Darkness, Oh Hell


2.5
average

Review

by ConsiderPhlebas USER (34 Reviews)
November 4th, 2010 | 43 replies


Release Date: 2010 | Tracklist

Review Summary: Eclectic, immediate and ultimately rather weak

[i]Darknenks partly to their European record label, Poison the Well sent ripples of excitement around the world with their debut ep, [i]Distance Makes the Heart Grow Fnye West cares about himself, about money, about pussy, religion and black people. Unfortvoice ties together the deceptively simple instrumentation, and from the opening beat of 'Hands' to the anthemic close of the title track, Running Out of Places to Go goes about its business with its feet on the table and a smile on its face. You could call it unassuming, but with this type of quality, unassuming is a sign ofside, and that is glossy, uber-melodic music with a heavyweight punch. And Chiodos certainly deliver on those fronts. The rather awkwardly titled Illuminaudio is a huge, polished affair - one bristling with a newfound, and sorely needed, energy. Any fears that new singer Brandon Bolmer would throw an unwelcome spanner in the works have been proved dramatically wrong; it might b Me’, to the thundering, monolithic ‘Not Within Arms Length’, it was obvious that Poison the Well had found their feet. The integration of post-hardcore aesthetics, melodies and structures took them away from their previous, more metal incarnation, providing a rounded, full sound that they would develop even further in later releases. But for now they were still firmly metalcore, and the spark caused by The Opposite of December resonates throughout the genre to this day.

The album is tightly, crisply constructed. From the first meaty clatter of ‘12/23/93’, it’s obvious that the drumming on display here is a real presence, a firm bedrock underpinning everything else on display. The guitars beat out blunt, energetic rhythms, seamlessly interspersed with melodic streams that temper the anger and frustration of the music with genuine beauty. It hasn’t aged pen, but Trophy Scars’ latest offering suffers from some incredibly feeble, amateurish moments – ones that might have been forgivable in a new band’s work, but not for people so far into their career. And oh-my-life is it derivative.

At its heart, Darkness, Oh Hell is a foot-stomping monster, played from the hip in a smoky, drunken haze. It’s overly-dramatic, even theatrical in tone, but when it works, it works. Jerry Jonesnes that might have been forgivable in a new band’s work, but not for people so far into their career. And oh-my-life is it derivative.

At its heart, Darkness, Oh Hell is a foot-stomping monster, played from the hip in a smoky, drunken haze. It’s overly-dramatic, even theatrical in tone, but when it works, it works. Jerry Jonesnes that might have been forgivable in a new band’s work, but not for people so far into their career. And oh-my-life is it derivative.

At its heart, Darkness, Oh Hell is a foot-stomping monster, played from the hip in a smoky, drunken haze. It’s overly-dramatic, even theatrical in tone, but when it works, it works. Jerry Jonesnes that might have been forgivable in a new band’s work, but not for people so far into their career. And oh-my-life is it derivative.

At its heart, Darkness, Oh Hell is a foot-stomping monster, played from the hip in a smoky, drunken haze. It’s overly-dramatic, even theatrical in tone, but when it works, it works. Jerry Jonesnes that might have been forgivable in a new band’s work, but not for people so far into their career. And oh-my-life is it derivative.

At its heart, Darkness, Oh Hell is a foot-stomping monster, played from the hip in a smoky, drunken haze. It’s overly-dramatic, even theatrical in tone, but when it works, it works. Jerry Jones growls over crisp, bluesy riffs, the brass section throws in well-timed stabs and it all sounds very grown-up, like in the swaggering ‘Darkness’ annes that might have been forgivable in a new band’s work, but not for people so far into their career. And oh-my-life is it derivative.

At its heart, Darkness, Oh Hell is a foot-stomping monster, played from the hip in a smoky, drunken haze. It’s overly-dramatic, even theatrical in tone, but when it works, it works. Jerry Jonesnes that might have been forgivable in a new band’s work, but not for people so far into their career. And oh-my-life is it derivative.

At its heart, Darkness, Oh Hell is a foot-stomping monster, played from the hip in a smoky, drunken haze. It’s overly-dramatic, even theatrical in tone, but when it works, it works. Jerry Joneslectic mosaic of the music gels together here, for the most part, only rarely seeming messy – it’s just the weakness of the content that drags it down. If they incorporate quality control into their repertoire, though, the world might be in for a shock.



Recent reviews by this author
Gallops Yours Sincerely, Dr. HardcoreThe Swellers Running Out of Places to Go
One Direction Up All NightThe Weakerthans Left and Leaving
Frank Turner England Keep My BonesJaya the Cat More Late Night Transmissions With Jaya the Cat
user ratings (787)
4.2
excellent
other reviews of this album
1 of


Comments:Add a Comment 
ConsiderPhlebas
November 5th 2010


6157 Comments


I liked it at first

ConsiderPhlebas
November 5th 2010


6157 Comments


I sense that you disagree, Chan

Bitchfork
November 5th 2010


7581 Comments


I love you so fucking much for this because I agree with every word that you said but the review reads more like a three and since that is your rating I suggest you change the review's rating.



ConsiderPhlebas
November 5th 2010


6157 Comments


My problem with the rating is it changes with every listen - when I can ignore the bad bits it's a 4, when I can't it's a 2. I just went for average because that seemed to sum it up, in a way, but I see what you mean.

Bitchfork
November 5th 2010


7581 Comments


Yeah and 2+4=6/2=3

That's how I feel with a lot of hardcore-based releases but when that happens I know that the good bits aren't worth the terrible parts because if they make my opinion swing that much on every listen (usually in a more negative direction each time I hate it) then it's just so flawed that at the best it's potential unrealized.

Sowing
Moderator
November 5th 2010


45533 Comments

Album Rating: 4.0

solid 3.0 meh

Bitchfork
November 5th 2010


7581 Comments


Taylor Swift>Trophy Scars

Irving
Emeritus
November 5th 2010


7496 Comments


Sowing > Trophy Scars

Bitchfork
November 5th 2010


7581 Comments


I wouldn't go that far.

PinkBlackberry
November 5th 2010


2346 Comments


I really can't do the vocals.

Early TScars is fucking boss. They didn't have that ...raspy OC/YC alexisonfire vocals...now...It's just...I can't do it

Aids
November 5th 2010


24910 Comments

Album Rating: 5.0

Pffffffffffffffff

dixoncocks
November 5th 2010


3247 Comments


does anyone else hear modest mouse when he doesn't do his odd screaming?

Bitchfork
November 5th 2010


7581 Comments


no

Enotron
November 5th 2010


7695 Comments

Album Rating: 4.5 | Sound Off

great review

coleba
November 5th 2010


808 Comments


Is this srsly this good? Don't lie to me.

HighandDriving
November 5th 2010


3288 Comments

Album Rating: 3.0

Good review, nice to see a more accurate rating.



Love this line: played from the hip in a smoky, drunken haze.

greg84
Emeritus
November 5th 2010


7654 Comments

Album Rating: 4.0

Awesome EP. I can't agree with the review at all like most people on here thankfully.

BigHans
November 5th 2010


30959 Comments

Album Rating: 3.5

Awesome work bro. Listening to this now, not terrible but its not really my thing.

BigHans
November 5th 2010


30959 Comments

Album Rating: 3.5

Was gonna give it a 3 but the last song was awesome so bumped it a little.

Comatorium.
November 5th 2010


5523 Comments

Album Rating: 4.5 | Sound Off

pfffffffffffffffff [2]



pos. you fuck.



You have to be logged in to post a comment. Login | Create a Profile





STAFF & CONTRIBUTORS // CONTACT US

Bands: A B C D E F G H I J K L M N O P Q R S T U V W X Y Z


Site Copyright 2005-2023 Sputnikmusic.com
All Album Reviews Displayed With Permission of Authors | Terms of Use | Privacy Policy