Emery
I'm Only A Man


3.5
great

Review

by heyadam USER (21 Reviews)
March 30th, 2010 | 25 replies


Release Date: 2007 | Tracklist

Review Summary: Experimenting with a new sound, Emery seemed to have pulled it off......for the most part. Just get passed the cliche riffs and a couple low points on the album and you have a solid, different sound from Emery.

Ok this is my first review, so please help me with suggestions and comments.

Since 2004, Emery has been a breath of fresh air in the dying genre of post-hardcore. With their 2007 release, "I'm Only A Man", they created a new buzz about them, that wasn't too good. Cries of "sell outs" plauged the band, and a lot of hate from the critics disapointed them. But musically, they took a new direction that upset people, but still worked.

The opening track, "Rock N' Rule" to me is one of the weakest points of the album. Although some creative guitar sounds came out of this song, it was too sporadic and unorganized to be a highlight of the album. Now one thing that always has made Emery great, has been the vocals. Both Toby and Devin have great voices, and when sung in harmony create truly memoriable moments in their songs. (See "Fractions" off of "the Weak's End). A great example of this is the bridge to the second, and most controversial song on the album, "the Party Song". The only reason I say it is controversial, is because some fans felt that Emery sold out with this song. Since when is good song writing selling-out? Yes it is catchy, and radio worthy, but that doesn't mean they have sold out. The third song "World Away" opens up with a riff that sounds like Paramore decided to borrow it for their fourth release "Brand New Eyes" (the name of the song escapes me). "After the Devil Beats His Wife" adds a middle eastern like guitar sound in the bridge, often found in SOAD songs, this song is a strong point in the album.

Now the next song, "Can't Stop the Killer", is easily one of the best songs on the album. The dynamics are slow and building but gives the song a more epic effect. Once it hits the bridge, it utilizes an electronica sound that really adds a fresh perspective into their sound. The lyrics also add a lot to this song. "RUN, RUN, RUN FROM THE MAN WITH THE GUN IN HIS HAND. AND DARLING I WOULD SHOOT YOU, BEFORE I WOULD EVER LET YOU LEAVE.....OH DEAR GOD" is definitely a vocal high point on the album. The next song, "Story of A Man With A Bad Heart" is a good transistory song from "Can't Stop the Killer". It is not the most creative song on the album, but it is definitely a good one. Toby's ending tirade is somewhat haunting and was definitely a good ending to the song.

Song number 7, "Don't Bore Us Get To the Chorus" is by far the best song on the entire album. From the opening operatic chants of "Never gonna go away!" to the very electronic and funky beats of the chorus, to the sessions of screams at the end, this song is the most memorable and the most listenable. "What Makes a Man a Man" is one of the lowest points of the album. It tends to drag on and if anything should be either a few tracks before, or a few after "Don't Bore Us...." because the listener is still really excited from the previous track, only to be let down by this one. The next song however, delivers. "The Movie Song" is a cleverly written sardonic view on the former mistakes of either Toby or Devin(whomever wrote the song). It's got simple but effective riffs, and very poppy chants of "Whoa oh oh" throughout the chorus. Now for the last song "You Think Your Nickel Slick (But I've Got You're Penny Change)". This song is average, its neither awful or mind blowing. The guitar parts have been used on previous songs, and the bridge is nothing new. All in all, I think this song was a bit of a weak one to end it with. It's by no means a bad song though.

Emery experimented with a new sound on this album, and I think they did mostly a good job with it. A few low points on the album may make it unappealing to some, but I think if people would listen to it a few times this is the type of album that will start to grow on you.


Pros:
Lyrics and Vocals
New sounds
"Don't Bore Us, Get To the Chorus"

Cons:
Some overused riffs
Some weak transitions
"Rock N' Rule"



Recent reviews by this author
Twice With YOU-thTwice Between 1 and 2
No Party For Cao Dong 瓦合Masakatsu Takagi Ookami Kodomo no Ame to Yuki OST
Masakatsu Takagi Kagayakiwowaka Unhappy Refrain
user ratings (548)
3
good
other reviews of this album
atrink (3.5)
Emery seems to have written a mixed bag of an album. There are many spectacular songs to find on I...

Eko (3)
Emery swings for the fences, but only manages a little blooper that just falls for a hit....

Cuban Pete (2)
Emery try too hard to progress by going too many directions, not developing a single one of them....

sparklamb698 (3)
Hmm...so Emery picked the "Revolution" card instead of the "Evolution" card...but the album just doe...



Comments:Add a Comment 
Comatorium.
March 30th 2010


5046 Comments


eh.

atrink
March 30th 2010


2855 Comments

Album Rating: 3.5

At the end of the second full paragraph it should say middle eastern not middle Easter

heyadam
March 30th 2010


4395 Comments

Album Rating: 4.0

yeah i saw that as i was re-reading it, my bad

atrink
March 30th 2010


2855 Comments

Album Rating: 3.5

And it's a little confusing you say can't stop the killer is easily one of the best songs bu then the next paragraph you say BY FAR don't bore us get to the choirs is the best song.



But other then that pretty solid first review

heyadam
March 30th 2010


4395 Comments

Album Rating: 4.0

ok i will keep that in mind, those two to me are the two best songs on the album....and I didn't wont to break up each song into its own paragraph....thanks for the input though

LiquidVelvet
March 30th 2010


640 Comments


You Think You're Nickel Slick, After The Devil Beats His Wife, and From Crib To Coffin are my favourites.
Also, you didn't even mention the TEN MINUTE closer....why not?

heyadam
March 30th 2010


4395 Comments

Album Rating: 4.0

10 minute closer???? the standard album ends with "You think you're nickel slick"...... which is 3:45 seconds long...what 10 minute closer are you talking about?

Alucard125
March 30th 2010


669 Comments


Summary needs to be changed to "pulled it off", rather than 'of'. Otherwise pretty good.

heyadam
March 30th 2010


4395 Comments

Album Rating: 4.0

thanks, hey i'm pretty new to sputnik...how do you edit your reviews?

heyadam
March 30th 2010


4395 Comments

Album Rating: 4.0

nvm, I found out lol

atrink
March 30th 2010


2855 Comments

Album Rating: 3.5

From crib to coffin is the ten minute closer And it's actually pretty good. I think you might have downloaded a bad torrent ;)

heyadam
March 30th 2010


4395 Comments

Album Rating: 4.0

oh crap haha, well i liked the album and the band enough to actually buy "I'm Only A Man" to support them, I just never listened to the actual album all the way through because I do have the torrent

TheAbstruseMeaning
March 30th 2010


36 Comments

Album Rating: 4.0

Yea From Crib to Coffin is one of my favorite songs on here. You should edit your review after you listen to it. The only thing I disagree with you about really is "What Makes A Man A Man", I thought that was an album highlight.

bloc
March 30th 2010


70119 Comments


Rock N Rule and The Party Song kick ass.

heyadam
March 30th 2010


4395 Comments

Album Rating: 4.0

I understand, reviews are sort of hard in that matter because I have different opinions then everybody else. And vice versa. I definitely will edit my review after I listen to "From Crib to Coffin" though for sure, and to me, I think it was more of the placement of "What Makes A Man A Man" then the actual song....I mean it followed "Don't Bore Us....." and that song is definitely the best on the album

TheAbstruseMeaning
March 30th 2010


36 Comments

Album Rating: 4.0

Oh yeah, any review is just opinion. Really good first review by the way. Placement of 'What Makes a Man a Man' could definitely have been better, I agree.

heyadam
March 30th 2010


4395 Comments

Album Rating: 4.0

thanks man, i'm definitely going to edit it now that I realize I have missed a track, but yeah I shouldn't have said its a bad song per se, its just hard to follow up "Don't Bore Us...." with a softer and more mellow song

atrink
March 31st 2010


2855 Comments

Album Rating: 3.5

oh yeah and take that first sentence out of the review. it makes it look unprofessional. you can always put that as the first comment so that's what people read before they comment

heyadam
April 1st 2010


4395 Comments

Album Rating: 4.0

alright man thanks, I will do that. I just think that it should be known that it is my first attempt at a review so for now i'll just keep it because i can't comment first again. But thanks for the tips



p.s. I heard Emery is filming a dvd now!

atrink
April 1st 2010


2855 Comments

Album Rating: 3.5

Don't worry about it. It's just advice for the future.



But yeah I heard that. I'm stoked the question DVD was pretty sweet and the three times I've seen em they've been awesome so the DVD should be solid



You have to be logged in to post a comment. Login | Create a Profile





STAFF & CONTRIBUTORS // CONTACT US

Bands: A B C D E F G H I J K L M N O P Q R S T U V W X Y Z


Site Copyright 2005-2023 Sputnikmusic.com
All Album Reviews Displayed With Permission of Authors | Terms of Use | Privacy Policy