">
 

Primus
Miscellaneous Debris


4.5
superb

Review

by JAStewart USER (12 Reviews)
September 7th, 2005 | 33 replies


Release Date: 1992 | Tracklist


Miscellanous Debris is a 5 track EP of covers written and recorded between 1992's Sailing The Seas Of Cheese and 1994's Pork Soda. Released in 1993, this EP has covers of the bands favourite artists; Peter Gabriel, XTC, The Residents, The Meters, Pink Floyd. Les plays a 6-string fretless bass on all songs.

1. Intruder (Peter Gabriel Cover)

Awesome Drum intro, Primus captured the eerie effect of this song perfectly. Obviously Les cant sing in such a pure english accent, but thats not important. This version does not have the xylophone solo, instead it has Ler's going crazy on the guitar which is like a combination of feedback of perhaps a slide of some form? Fantastic Cover
5/5

2. Making Plans For Nigel (XTC Cover)

This is one of my favourite Primus songs (covers). It is about twice the speed. I prefer this version to XTC's simply as its faster. Les's non-stop distorted bass runs through then entire track, and he even gets a very short bass solo in there too. The guitar riff in this track is just plain awesome. It is indeed a jumpy song for sure. The song is a bit shorter than the origional, presumabely because it is a lot faster. I like this song, even though Les minus's the british vocals style like in The Family And The Fishing Net, it doesn't let the track down at all, if anything, it improves it.
5/5

3. Sinister Exaggerator (The Residents Cover)

Very awesome, very evil, very creepy song about an exaggerator. This will probably be a non-residents fan least favourite track, but I love it. The vocals are seperated into three or four layers, a croaky voice, a 'normal' voice, a high pitched voice and a really low voice, which is just terrifying! Ler's guitar is tremolo picking notes which don't fit together into a scale and are minor and dissonant to each other. Something that is different about this version is that during the outro, you har Les tab high notes on his fretless, which doesn't occur on the Residents version.
4.5/5

4. Tippi Toes (The Meters Covers)

Short but sweet funk song. The bass line to this track is killer. Though this is not the complete version of the meters song, tippi toes it still kicks ass. The part that this misses is the Organ part, understandably as it is hard to recreate that with guitar . This song is perhaps one of the most simple things Primus have ever recorded. The guitar line is muted but static while the bass uses the actave at D for funk.

5/5

5. Have A Cigar (Pink Floyd)

My least favourite song on the EP simply as I find Pink Floyd boring. This is an emmaculate cover, note perfect, though I don't like it. Particularily Les's voice, i'm just not a fan whatsoever.

3/5



Recent reviews by this author
Primus They Can't All Be ZingersThat 1 Guy Songs In the Key of Beotch
Lo*Chine That Joke Ain't Funky No More [EP]The Residents Buster & Glen
Primus RhinoplastyThe Residents Duck Stab
user ratings (158)
3.5
great
other reviews of this album
PostMesmeric (3.5)
IV: One of the band's most underrated releases acts as an awesome prologue to the "Pork Soda" era of...



Comments:Add a Comment 
Damrod
Moderator
September 7th 2005


1093 Comments


I'm sorry, but in this form the review is under par. You'll have to add more detail, or it will have to be deleted

Thor
September 7th 2005


10354 Comments


^^^
I was just about to say the same thing, this review doesn't really tell you enough about the album. You might want to edit this.

Shadows
Moderator
September 7th 2005


2530 Comments


My least favourite song on the EP simply as I find Pink Floyd boring. This is an emmaculate cover, note perfect, though I don't like it.
I don't even know what this means. :confused:


Shadows
Moderator
September 7th 2005


2530 Comments


I caught the boring part, but this just didn't make any sense to me:

"This is an emmaculate cover, note perfect, though I don't like it."

Thai Noodles2
September 8th 2005


4 Comments


Well Well Well, if it isn't mr.procurer v player

Storm In A Teacup
November 17th 2005


45711 Comments


[quote=review]3/5 - my rating
5/5 - everyone else.[/quote]

WTF?

Does that make sense to anyone? This review is probably one of the worst on the site.

cjstunna
December 29th 2005


119 Comments

Album Rating: 2.5

Decent review. This album is a must for any fan of early Primus. Have a Cigar is amazing. Although its 11 bucks for a 5 song EP I was able to justify since its very rare, and I'm a big fan of PrimusThis Message Edited On 12.28.05

YDload
December 29th 2005


1207 Comments


This review is bad, but "Have A Cigar" is a great cover. Far more interesting than the original just because I love Les' over-indulgence on the bass. He really goes all the way in fitting most of the song's melodies on his instrument.

Two-Headed Boy
January 21st 2006


4527 Comments


covers written and recorded between 1992's Sailing The Seas Of Cheese

you can't write a cover song, silly :D
anyway, nice review. easy on the eyes.

Thor
January 21st 2006


10354 Comments


A mod needs to delete this review. It's pathetic.

JAStewart
January 22nd 2006


180 Comments

Album Rating: 4.5

you can't write a cove song


Well actually, Primus changed a few bits here and there so technically they re-wrote them

MrKite
November 26th 2006


5020 Comments


Primus Sucks!

nirvana1989_nb
November 26th 2006


98 Comments


Primus are lame. I just listenend to like 3 of their songs on their site, (i wanted to broaden my musical horizons) now i wish i hadn't! I won't comment on the review coz my one and only review stank at first! Now its ok.

TheMisterBungle
November 26th 2006


861 Comments


Primus is awesome.

nirvana1989_nb
November 26th 2006


98 Comments


I'll take your word for it. 3 Songs is not enough i spose to dismiss a band...

TheMisterBungle
November 26th 2006


861 Comments


They are a really strange band so they get some getting used to.
These guys are ace musicians too.This Message Edited On 11.26.06

nirvana1989_nb
November 26th 2006


98 Comments


OK if i ever get really bored, and i'm with my posse il get stoned and check out Primus? Maybe i will connect with the band in the intoxicated vegetable state that is induced by pot.

TheMisterBungle
November 26th 2006


861 Comments


If that what works for you, then you go do that.
Just enjoy the great works of Primus one way or another.

MrKite
November 26th 2006


5020 Comments


I loved them as soon as I heard them. Les is the man. He's got to be one of the best bassists ever.

nirvana1989_nb
November 26th 2006


98 Comments


I'm gonna live off fortified wine and camembert with morrissey in an african snow globe under the dining table of Les Claypools moms house.



You have to be logged in to post a comment. Login | Create a Profile





STAFF & CONTRIBUTORS // CONTACT US

Bands: A B C D E F G H I J K L M N O P Q R S T U V W X Y Z


Site Copyright 2005-2023 Sputnikmusic.com
All Album Reviews Displayed With Permission of Authors | Terms of Use | Privacy Policy