by AnyColour74 USER (29 Reviews)
November 26th, 2009 | 28 replies

Release Date: 2001 | Tracklist

Review Summary: At the peak of the ambient phase of their career, Amnesiac, while another triumph for Yorke and company, is a misunderstood album, and a criminally underrated one at that

Allow me to bore you with an utterly dull story from my repertoire of boring memories and such: It was a clear, sunny day in the summer of 2001, and I was on my way to one of the most dreaded locations in the universe, the dentist. As I was arguing with my mother about exactly why I needed to get my teeth checked out on this particular day, why couldn’t we just go tomorrow, the opening notes of Radiohead’s Amnesiac blared from the car’s speakers. I was suddenly put into a trance. This didn’t sound like the normal Lennon/McCartney guitar riffs and vocals I was used to hearing 24/7. This was…..different. Who was this band, and what had they done with the Beatles, my Beatles? After a small temper tantrum thrown by yours truly, it was explained to me that the music being played was by a new yet very talented band, and that this song was called Packt Like Sardines In A Crushd Tin Box. "What a weird song title, and a weird band!" I thought to my nine year old self. Little did I know that I would slowly but surely fall deeply in love with these five musicians from Oxfordshire, England who call themselves Radiohead.

As a loyal follower and constant listener of Thom Yorke and co, I am proud to admit that Packt Like Sardines In A Crushd Tin Box was the first Radiohead song I ever heard. I often think back to that day proudly, looking back as if I had won an award for helping an old lady cross the street or the like. And yet, I had no idea how dark and brooding of an album Amnesiac truly is. Often referred to as Kid B since most of the songs were written and recorded over the same period the band labored over their (second) magnum opus Kid A, in no way is Amnesiac the second rate album the label Kid B alludes to it as being. While a brilliant album, Amnesiac is a misunderstood, misinterpreted album. It was born under punches; immediately after its release it was beaten around by critics. Given labels such as “Worst Radiohead album since Pablo Honey”, this and other negative brands were slapped onto the band that, according to Rolling Stone Magazine, “had to destroy rock n roll in order to save themselves” (see August 2001 issue). Thinking that they were justified, these critics forgot the cardinal rule of the Radiohead religion: one must always give a new Radiohead album time to fully sink in before giving it a label/rating. Sure, it was different from the previous record, but isn’t that what Radiohead does with all of their albums?

While anyone can come to the conclusion that Amnesiac’s closest relative in the Radiohead repertoire is Kid A, it is no way Kid B. Whereas Kid A flows well from one track to the next, the same cannot be said for Amnesiac. If you’re a lover of the Optimistic-into-In Limbo transition found smack-dab in the middle of all the action on Kid A, unfortunately you won’t find any such transformation from one track to the next on Amnesiac. The transitions between songs are generally uncomfortable and awkward. Is this a bad thing? Not necessarily. The change from a warm, mellow, computer-beat driven track such as Packt into a more ominous yet majestic piano track, Pyramid Song, can be an unexpected yet welcome surprise for the listener. Similarly, a lackadaisical track such as Morning Bell/Amnesiac followed up by the overly-paranoid Dollars and Cents makes for one of the many highlights of Amnesiac. In addition, experimentation can be found in larger doses on Amnesiac, contributing to the album’s rich diversity. The dizzying Pulk/Pull Revolving Doors, guitar-oriented Hunting Bears, computer-generated Like Spinning Plates and the brass and woodwind driven Life In A Glasshouse can easily be associated as some of the most experimental Radiohead songs, while the aforementioned Packt and Morning Bell/Amnesiac furthers Radiohead’s trek into unchartered musical territory.

The diversity of the album can be contributed to each members continued dabbing and furthered advancement of knowledge of their respective instruments. Colin Greenwood undoubtedly offers up his darkest yet catchiest bass line in Dollars and Cents (sorry National Anthem lovers, that was Tchock on the bass, not Cozzie). Yorke shows off his knowledge of the piano on the epic Pyramid Song, as well as the eerie crescendo of a song You and Whose Army? (He also plays piano on the live version of Like Spinning Plates. Refer to I Might Be Wrong: Live Recordings for your listening pleasure, if you so choose). Although the guitar work of Johnny Greenwood and Ed O’Brien is more impressive on The Bends and OK Computer, tracks such as I Might Be Wrong, Knives Out and Morning Bell/Amnesiac is where the layered guitar work of O’Brien and the younger Greenwood reminds listeners exactly why Radiohead’s instrumentation is difficult to beat. Phil Selway is an enigma on Amnesiac, on some tracks his drumming is a non-factor (Morning Bell/Amnesiac) while on others, it is as all percussion should be, the driving force of the song (Pyramid Song). With Yorke’s hauntingly beautiful vocals in top shape for songs like Pyramid Song and Like Spinning Plates, it will be sure to give the listener goosebumps.

The beautiful thing about Amnesiac is that there isn’t one single stand out track. With one listen, a listener’s favorite song may be guitar and computer-driven I Might Be Wrong, with the next listen it could very well be the ambient Hunting Bears. Contributing to this factor are Yorke’s ideas of isolation and anxiety, which are found when one closely studies the album’s lyrics (and artwork, which depicts a weeping Minotaur). Packt’s lyrics’ are a sort of plea to the listener, convincing them that “I’m a reasonable man” in hopes that they will “get off my case”. The opening lines of Like Spinning Plates, dealing with the similar theme of helplessness shared with most of the other tracks, whispers “While you make pretty speeches, I’m being cut to shreds”. While critics often claim that the album has a few noticeable missteps, it lies on the listener as to whether this belief is true or not. It comes as no surprise that the non-Radiohead oriented fans and critics won’t like Pulk/Pull Revolving Doors and Hunting Bears. Where the critics end, the job of the listener begins. While one may not understand the more ambient and experimental songs with the first listen, time, like with all Radiohead songs/albums, will eventually lead them to garner a greater understanding and appreciation of the intricacies and advanced music quality of Amnesiac.

Last summer, I was privileged enough to see Radiohead perform twice within the span of four days. While I was pleased to hear them play some of my favorite songs (Kid A, Go Slowly, Planet Telex to name a few), the band played only one song from Amnesiac over the course of the two evenings, Pyramid Song. This segues me to the main point of the review: why isn’t there more love for Amnesiac? Although Radiohead’s most experimental album, it is not that huge of a departure for the band. And though it was given the insurmountable task of following two of the best albums of the previous ten years, tracks such as You and Whose Army?, Knives Out, Dollars and Cents, and Like Spinning Plates seem to lead Amnesiac to a deserved victory for the band. From the eclectic, exciting opener Packt Like Sardines In A Crushd Tin Box, to the woeful, New Orleans funeral-styled closer Life In A Glasshouse, one can only wonder why Amnesiac is so unappreciated by the music community. And yet, it is this exact reason why Amnesiac is so good.

Recent reviews by this author
Miles Davis Someday My Prince Will ComeThe Beatles With the Beatles
The Who The Who by NumbersRooney Rooney
The Zutons Who Killed The ZutonsArlo Guthrie The Best Of Arlo Guthrie
user ratings (5057)
other reviews of this album
1 of

Comments:Add a Comment 
November 27th 2009


Album Rating: 4.0

Great review, tbh I like Amnesiac more than Kid A, although I just got Kid A.

November 27th 2009


I like "Amnesiac" a whole lot more than "Kid A", but it's not a five star album. For me, the best thing Radiohead has done by a long shot is "Hail to the Thief".

Nevertheless, you make strong points for the album, and the review is a good read.

November 27th 2009


Album Rating: 5.0

Nice review, the rating is dead on. Amnesiac is one of my most played albums of all time son.

Staff Reviewer
November 27th 2009


Good review, I disagree with the rating but different strokes...

November 27th 2009


Album Rating: 4.0

Neat review, I haven't listened to this but it is on my 50 next list.

November 27th 2009


Album Rating: 4.5

This is one of the few Radiohead albums that I don't have. Maybe I shall acquire a copy of it...

November 27th 2009


Album Rating: 4.5 | Sound Off

Pretty great review.

November 27th 2009


Album Rating: 3.5

I'll never understand people that 5 this.

November 27th 2009


Album Rating: 3.0 | Sound Off

Good review, even though I disagree

November 27th 2009


Album Rating: 4.5

Good work. Pulk is one of my favourite Radiohead songs.

November 27th 2009


Album Rating: 3.5

Pyramid Song is godly, not that huge a fan of the album otherwise.

November 27th 2009


Great album. A very unique, claustrophobic sound here. The only thing I could name as being even remotely similar is Boards of Canada's Geogaddi.

November 27th 2009


Album Rating: 5.0


November 27th 2009


Album Rating: 5.0

this album rules. hands down best rh record.

love the review.

November 27th 2009


Awesome review; I agree completely. Amnesiac needs more love!

November 27th 2009


Album Rating: 5.0

I don't think hands down is accurate.

November 27th 2009


Album Rating: 3.5

this is my least favorite RH record. Pablo Honey doesn't count

November 27th 2009


Nice review and well done.

I've noticed an increase in love for this album over the past year.

November 27th 2009


Album Rating: 5.0

Thanks for the kind words folks. Seeing as this is my first review in just about three years, and that there are already six other reviews for it, I'm glad that this has been received positively. Just felt like I had to get my five cents about it in.

November 28th 2009


Album Rating: 3.5

nice review

You have to be logged in to post a comment. Login | Create a Profile


Bands: A B C D E F G H I J K L M N O P Q R S T U V W X Y Z

Site Copyright 2005-2023
All Album Reviews Displayed With Permission of Authors | Terms of Use | Privacy Policy