">
 

As I Lay Dying
An Ocean Between Us


4.0
excellent

Review

by thrashman77 USER (1 Reviews)
October 27th, 2009 | 26 replies


Release Date: 2007 | Tracklist


Metalcore. Quite a genre that has grown rapidly lately. Soon after years, the genre copied itself, and now it’s becoming quite bland in some bands. One band that realized this was As I Lay Dying. They wanted to included new musical influences to there upcoming album so that they wouldn't be that simple and boring. Where they successful? HELL YES

The first track, separation, is a beautiful, short instrumental containing duel guitar that its ending prepares u for the upcoming track. I personally listen to it every time before i go to nothing left-the next track. it only takes a few seconds to hear Jordan Mancino double bass drumming, which is quite brutal and fast. Guitars on this one... i personally did not think the riff was that impressive or right for the songs, but the solos raged throughout the song, and who doesn't like raging solos? Tims voice has not changed that much over time, still strong, brutal, but hard to understand. new bassist clean vocals get the job done through, and do well with his screams at the chorus.

Title track is next. You see less metalcore drumming and more thrashy speedy style for mancino on this one, showing that he is in fact a fair match for Dave Lombardo. The riff is simple, but accessible and fun to listen to as it gets higher in verses. You see the bassist can sing and sound well even without the help of screams from Tim. This is overall a great song, though after chorus is simple and there no solo, (sobs). Within destruction is next, the song is PURE THRASH. I am surprised this is even on a metalcore album, the guitar, the drums; everything but maybe the vocals is thrash, which in my opinion is more good then bad. There are no clean vocals on this track, making this one of the more intense and brutal songs. Forsaken is just the opposite, having a melodic guitar intro, and having more singing on a typical track on this album. This is one of my favorites, due to the impressive vocals on both screaming and clean, speedy drums, and melodic guitar work, and if your not getting the album i suggest this track. Comfort betrays is quite brutal, due to its absence on clean vocals. Drums on this track are just insane, this riff is probably the best of the album, and even matches within destruction on brutality. I never wanted slows done the pace, the instruments are far less complicated. why? It shows off vocals work. And WOW. both singers do there best vocal performance on here, the bassists voice is perfect, tims voice is beyond perfect on his screams, and of course manincos double bass work during the end is quite impressive to. Bury us all shows off mancino ability even more, his blast beats are quite impressive, but besides that this is a very average track. The most popular track and most likely the best track is next, the sound of truth. The guitar riff on chorus... It’s insane, and is probably the best metalcore riff i have ever heard besides trivium's song ascendancy. but the solo, WOW, best solo on the album, most likely the best guitar work this band has ever done I don't care if you don't even like this band for the love of god listen to this solo. Vocals, excellent performance. And of course as usual drums are great, his double bass thundering throughout the song, and of course the catchiness of the chorus is always a good thing to have as well. The next tracks (not counting the instrumental departed) are very... Filler, and just are way to similar to the others, the instrumental was OK, but I never liked cheesy val halen tapping

So overall, awesome album, as i lay dying went beyond the metalcore wall and used thrash influences, more clean vocals, and very diverse tracks to make this a very successful album. But unfortunately it suffered from guitar riffs being stale and repetitive and Tims inability to change the tone of his screams. If u are just getting into metalcore, let this album be your tour guide into this wonderful genre


user ratings (2507)
3.7
great
other reviews of this album
1 of
  • Robert Garland STAFF (3.5)
    Whilst improving record to record, As I Lay Dying show fans an enjoyable album but do not ...

    ToWhatEnd (4)
    A step in a new direction for the band in which they develop a new twist on their classic ...

    kalkal50 (3)
    AILD are crawling out of a homogenous shell....

    ironman4444 (4.5)
    ...

  • jebatarjunakee (4)
    Tim Lambesis and his men kick it up a notch or two in this splendid record....

    Thor (3)
    As I Lay Dying show signs of improvement with this album and take a few chances, but not e...

    Metabolica (4)
    AILD have made an evolved turn for the better combining their trademark melodic metalcore ...

    Donul (4.5)
    It seems like there is an ocean between AILD and most of the other bands in the genre......



Comments:Add a Comment 
XulOnerom
October 27th 2009


1818 Comments


(e.g. write out "you" and not "u").


This.

Also, learn to capitalize correctly. Seriously, what do kids do in schools nowadays??


thrashman77
October 27th 2009


36 Comments

Album Rating: 4.0

oh alright. what about the materiel?

shortone323
October 27th 2009


883 Comments

Album Rating: 3.0

If you fixed the capitalizaton, which is honestly unacceptable considering you're typing on a computer, there's still a lot of generalization and hyperbolic claims here. Can't really go into detail because it's hard to read.

thrashman77
October 27th 2009


36 Comments

Album Rating: 4.0

Um... oh. i just fixed capitalization

Deviant.
Staff Reviewer
October 27th 2009


32288 Comments

Album Rating: 3.0

Still missed some, but it's an improvement

Inveigh
October 27th 2009


27009 Comments

Album Rating: 3.0

also, in your recommended albums you listed Slayer's "Raining Blood." The album is actually titled Reign in Blood. FYI.



I think this is AILD's best overall disc, although FWC and SAS are sentimental favorites because I was much more into this band when those came out.

thrashman77
October 27th 2009


36 Comments

Album Rating: 4.0

wow i cannot believe my user name is thrash man and i made that mistake... ugg i feel like such an idiot.... its my first review so i guess i can improve on next ones

thrashman77
October 27th 2009


36 Comments

Album Rating: 4.0

wow i cannot believe my user name is thrash man and i made that mistake... ugg i feel like such an idiot.... its my first review so i guess i can improve on next ones

Inveigh
October 27th 2009


27009 Comments

Album Rating: 3.0

that's the idea bro, don't worry about it. Just thought I'd point that out.

Deviant.
Staff Reviewer
October 27th 2009


32288 Comments

Album Rating: 3.0

^No need to put yourself down like that man, we're just trying to help

thrashman77
October 27th 2009


36 Comments

Album Rating: 4.0

no, that why i said i wanted this criticism, so i wont mistake the greatest thrash albums name next time when i make a review, so thx

Kronzo
October 28th 2009


1304 Comments


Thats what i've been noticing too ^

Kronzo
October 28th 2009


1304 Comments


it works though I guess. However, It gets repetitive when repeated over and over and over. It's gotten quite cliche...

Kronzo
October 28th 2009


1304 Comments


Double post sry.

JWT155
October 28th 2009


15036 Comments

Album Rating: 4.0

Great album, Shadows are Security is still my favorite though.

XulOnerom
October 28th 2009


1818 Comments


I still see some mistakes in capitalization (and some "u" instead of "you"). Are you writing the reviews directly on the site??? I suggest you write them in Word and then copypaste them here (that's what I do). It'll tell you when you make mistakes, and sometimes even automatically correct them (especially capitalization). I'd also avoid using adjectives such as "brutal" or "raging" for descriptions; they are cliche and don't really describe anything.

I don't think anything AILD has ever done is worthy of more than a 2, but it's your review, not mine

Captain North
October 28th 2009


6793 Comments

Album Rating: 3.0

I wouldn't call the tracks diverse.

Undead
October 28th 2009


145 Comments

Album Rating: 3.5

Neither would I, but its a great album nonetheless.



Proof read your review next time man. Or get someone to do it for you. Or use Word.

Fxxkit13
October 28th 2009


1567 Comments


Good album

R6Rider
October 28th 2009


5282 Comments

Album Rating: 3.5

I still need to burn this on my ipod



You have to be logged in to post a comment. Login | Create a Profile





STAFF & CONTRIBUTORS // CONTACT US

Bands: A B C D E F G H I J K L M N O P Q R S T U V W X Y Z


Site Copyright 2005-2023 Sputnikmusic.com
All Album Reviews Displayed With Permission of Authors | Terms of Use | Privacy Policy