Fighting With Wire
Man Vs Monster



by mitch91 USER (12 Reviews)
August 17th, 2009 | 7 replies

Release Date: 2008 | Tracklist

Review Summary: 'Man vs Monster' is what the Foo Fighters' last 4 albums should have been...

Man vs Monster

Fighting With Wire
Cahir O’Doherty – vocals, guitar
Jamie King – bass, vocals
Craig McLean – drums, vocals

I think it is fair to say that Dave Grohl is one of the biggest rock stars alive at this present time, being the drummer from Nirvana and the frontman of the Foo Fighters and all that. But people who know anything about the Foo Fighters’ back catalogue will probably feel it is fair to say the band haven’t released a truly great album since 1997’s ‘The Colour and the Shape’. The four albums (five if you count the acoustic disc of ‘In Your Honour’) following have contained on average 3.5 good songs, with the rest being filler tracks ranging from ‘nearly good’ to ‘meh’ to ‘crap’. Given these facts it is perhaps difficult to see why Grohl is such a star, and why so many other bands are often over-looked. Judging by the low number of ratings on this site (3 at time of writing) it seems Fighting With Wire is one of those bands.

Hailing from Derry in Northern Ireland, Fighting With Wire have produced with their first album what Grohl and co have been attempting for 12 years: a brilliant alt-rock record. Judging by the amount of Foo’s references it is safe for you to assume the band share some sonic similarities with them, but in many areas they are (vastly) superior. Each track on Man vs Monster buzzes with energy, evident from the start in the almost Billy Talent–sounding “Cut the Transmission”. Even the slower/quieter sections of the album somehow benefit from this; whereas other bands sound as if they are going through the motions churning out a token ballad, album closer “This Body Is In Danger” grips you immediately with it’s sincerity, slowly builds up to a full-band climax before fading out again.

Another thing that really stands out is the production. Something that many bands in this genre can fall afoul of is over-production as they opt for a more mainstream sound, sacrificing their aggressive edge. Luckily there are no such issues on Man vs Monster, and for me the production is perfect; each member of the band can be clearly heard, yet the guitars remain fairly forceful throughout. In addition to this the overall sound has been left pretty rough around the edges, something that other more mainstream artists often lack.

The second thing that is apparent from the off is the vocals. Cahir O’Doherty seems to possess a voice that combines elements of Dave Grohl, Simon Neil (Biffy Clyro) and at times Ben Kowalewicz (Billy Talent). He can go from standard singing to a more gruff style and even yelps and screams, all within the same song. Unfortunaley this means he may be a victim of the ‘Kowalewicz effect’, where listeners are turned off by a unique and individual style because it’s ‘a bit different’. It’s a good job that the songs are so damn good then. Going back to the Foo’s reference, those 3.5 songs per album that are good are usually the singles; fairly heavy tracks (for radio-rock) with catchy singalong choruses. On Man vs Monster every track has a chorus with the potential to remain in your head for the whole day. Combine this with powerful, although not ground-breaking, riffs and a strong rhythm section and you have the winning formula. In fact, the high quality of every song means it’s hard for me to pick out any as highlights: each song is a possible single *cliché ends*.

It came as no surprise to me when I found out the band are signed to Atlantic internationally, hopefully meaning they gain some much deserved recognition. As long as Fighting With Wire avoid the influence major labels can have on sophomore records, they have the talent to be up there with the Foo Fighters of this world.

Recent reviews by this author
Crazy Arm The Southern WildMuncie Girls Sleepless
Apologies, I Have None LondonCrazy Arm Union City Breath
Fighting Fiction A Lesser of Two EvilsThe Flatliners Cavalcade
user ratings (24)

Comments:Add a Comment 
August 17th 2009


Album Rating: 4.0

Comments welcome guys

August 17th 2009


Decent review, though too many Grohl references

August 17th 2009


Album Rating: 4.0

Well it was the theme of the review, and i figured most people would've never heard of Fighting With Wire so that's the best comparison.

August 17th 2009


Album Rating: 3.0

Fairly good review, the Foo Fighters references are relevant in the sound of the album and it's nice to see some production being mentioned. Could probably have done with a little more identification of why certain tracks are good, perhaps some lyric examples when you talk about the 'sincerity' of the last track, just to give someone who's actually listening to the album or the singles a couple of reference points.

Glad to see the album get a review though I'd only put it at good perhaps shading to great (prefer Cahir O'Doherty's older band, Jetplane Landing). Originally I really enjoyed it but by now I only really listen to 'Everybody Needs A Nemesis', 'Into the Ground' and 'Sugar', the rest just fade into the background. Still better than most radio fare though and one of the better British bands around.

August 17th 2009


Album Rating: 4.0

Very good album however being Irish I really hate the singers put on American accent! Really bothers me. He should sing in his own accent.

August 18th 2009


Album Rating: 4.0

I found it quite hard to pick out individual songs because they're all in the same mould of rock with catchy choruses. And I don't really like putting lyrics in a review unless its for a good reason, I don't think you can get a grasp of sincerity just from reading them.

But thanks for the comments, I'll definately take them on board for next time.

August 19th 2009


Album Rating: 4.0

Very good album however being Irish I really hate the singers put on American accent! Really bothers me. He should sing in his own accent


I did think that a bit, although there are some instances when you get a whiff of N. Irish. His accent is never going to be as strong as Simon Neil's Scottish accent though!

You have to be logged in to post a comment. Login | Create a Profile


Bands: A B C D E F G H I J K L M N O P Q R S T U V W X Y Z

Site Copyright 2005-2017
All Album Reviews Displayed With Permission of Authors | Terms of Use | Privacy Policy