Billy Talent
Billy Talent III



by rollnchew USER (5 Reviews)
July 29th, 2009 | 7 replies

Release Date: 2009 | Tracklist

Review Summary: Billy Talents 3rd offering is nothing on the other 2. Slow, heavy mediocrity laced with moments of brilliance - average.

Most bands 3rd albums are the ones that they struggle on. They start saying things like "Our fans will be shocked when they hear this" and "We went in a lot of different directions... there a lot more piano." Talk like this tells the album will be terrible and loyal fans will run screaming from it. In recent years bands like MCR and Aiden have done this.

Billy Talent III certainly isn't a complete disaster of experimentation but is very different from its predecessors. Things have gotten very murky in the Billy Talent camp...

First off the whole album is at a slower tempo - gone have the almost manic speeds of songs like 'The Ex'. They've been replaced by plodding, heavy and, quite frankly, slightly boring ones, like 1st single 'Rusted From The Rain'. The riffs are heavier and darker, giving the album an almost morbid feel.

Opener 'Devil On My Shoulder' hints at this change but still sounds like textbook 'Talent. There are moments of genius as well - 'Tears Into Wine' and 'Pocketful of Dreams' are the stand out tracks of the album, while 'The Dead Can't Testify' and 'Turn Your Back' wait to be discovered.

Both 'Tears Into Wine' and 'Pocketful Of Dreams' have amazing, sing-a-long choruses that are bound to become live favourites but the real reason that they stand out like a guy dressed as a banana at a funeral is the fact that they have a quicker beat and seem to be so much more alive than anything else on the track list.

'Turn Your Back' is more direct than 'Worker Bee's' and would have been a great way to end the album as 'Sudden Movements' is the ultimate misnomer as no kind of movement, let alone sudden ones, in it and 'Definition of Destiny' is completely unremarkable and forgetable.

'The Dead Can't Testify' is an outsider anthem in the form of a witch-hunt with a driving riff that tops it off perfectly. Billy Talent have alsways been famous for their original lyrics and narration points but unfortunately this is one of few examples on the new record.

'Saint Veronika' and 'White Sparrows' seem painfully cliched despite being fairly good songs and listening to them sums up what you think as you listen to the album. Yeah, it's Billy Talent... but where's the originality, the quirkiness and whatever it was that made Billy Talent so special.

user ratings (577)
other reviews of this album
1 of
  • Knott- EMERITUS (2)
    It would be nice if Billy Talent actually DID SOMETHING....

    DrGonzo1937 CONTRIBUTOR (1.5)
    Billy Talent III shows a band full of ambitious change, but end up almost entirely losing ...

    X3ni92 (3.5)
    Billy Talent is a huge success in Canada, but how successful is III?...

    Acre (2.5)
    Billy Talent III aim for the mainstream, and run themselves off the road in the process....

  • AtavanHalen (1.5)
    Hold your breath and count to four....

    Vilen1025 (2.5)
    Billy Talent III is a fusion of different elements. Their new sounds boast a fuller guitar...

Comments:Add a Comment 
July 29th 2009


Decent review, although you couldve picked an album that had fewer reviews.

Staff Reviewer
July 29th 2009


Album Rating: 3.5

3 other reviews isn't too bad shindip. You got to start somewhere.

The review isn't bad, but it's annoying at stages. I don't understand the reference to MCR in the intro paragraph. Are you suggesting they lost fans because 'WTTBParade' was different? Are you suggesting the album wasn't different? Are you suggesting it's a bad album? Because if you are, you'd be flat out wrong.

I could have thought of better examples of "manic" than 'The Ex'.

The banana line is silly.

And the big ommission is that you fail to mention D'Sa's guiatr-work, which is still top-notch here.

Having said all that (apologies for sounding harsh), it's actually got the shell of a decent review.

July 29th 2009


Album Rating: 2.0

i love the banana line :D

Staff Reviewer
July 29th 2009


Album Rating: 3.5

That's because you're a banana Adam.

July 29th 2009


Album Rating: 2.0

When I die I want a banana-themed funeral!

Staff Reviewer
July 29th 2009


Album Rating: 3.5

I can already picture B1 reading the eulogy while B2 drives the hearse.

July 30th 2009


Album Rating: 2.5

hey thnx for all the nice things said.

daveyboy- the reason for the mcr comment was that the black parade was so different i know many people who used to love mcr but dont anymore. i actually like the black parade but prefer the other 2 albums.

i agree manic was completely the wrong word to use. i have no excuse for that one...

D'Sa's guitar is still top notch i just forgot and the moment i posted this remebered that i should have mentioned it.

However i am extremly proud to have started a craze for banana themed funerals. they are the future people. accept it.

You have to be logged in to post a comment. Login | Create a Profile


Bands: A B C D E F G H I J K L M N O P Q R S T U V W X Y Z

Site Copyright 2005-2017
All Album Reviews Displayed With Permission of Authors | Terms of Use | Privacy Policy