And Then There Were None
The Hope We Forgot Exists



by TerminalC USER (10 Reviews)
April 7th, 2009 | 8 replies

Release Date: 2006 | Tracklist

Review Summary: Rekindled My Hope In The Genre

"The Hope We Forgot Exists" is the second release from Salem New Hampshire metalcore act And Then There Were None. Now before we proceed any further I'll come right out and say it, yes, And Then There Were None (who shall now be referred to as ATTWN) is a christian metalcore band. I know, I know, its been done before, probably more times than anyone can count, and badly at that. But ATTWN isn't another Underoath clone waiting to hit it big.

Do you like screaming AND singing in your music" Do you enjoy brutal breakdowns, and love two-stepping more than a fat kid loves cake" If you answered yes to both questions then look no further, this is the band for you. ATTWN utilizes a tried and true formula, yet manages to create a sound that oddly is neither stolen or stale.

With a standard yet solid guitar effort ATTWN drives their rather short songs forward, forsaking longer song lengths for more streamlined efforts, cutting the fat essentially. The bass is slightly more audible than on most modern metal efforts, but mostly serves to compliment the guitar efforts while the guitarist is busy sneaking in guitar solos that can almost gone unnoticed, not for lack of originality, but because they meld seamlessly with the rest of the music. The drums pound away behind the layer of guitars and vocals, providing a constant and inescapable beat which begs, nay demands, two-stepping. The vocals, both clean and harsh, have surprisingly well audible syllables, that is to say, you can actually understand the words for once.

Which brings us to a point we reach with every christian metalcore band, the lyrics. I'll be the first to admit the lyrics are the stereotypical, "we love God" and "rise above the adversity" dribble of the genre but the true talent is in the delivery. When vocalist Matt Rhodes screams "how can you try to justify a life that has no meaning"" you had damn well answer his question. The clean vocals, as always, come in just in time for a super-catchy chorus we can all bounce along to before being thrust back into the breakdowns, but is that such a bad thing" There was a reason metalcore became popular in the first place, believe it or not it's because not all metalcore bands suck.

The only flaws of the album are its rather short running length, just a hair over 20 minutes, and a rather low production quality. But if the only place you have to record is a basement then make the best of it, ATTWN surely did. And sure, this isn't an almighty creative powerhouse of an album, but how often does that actually happen" ATTWN knows what genre they like and they play their hearts out, they don't need to cross musical boundaries or create a groundbreaking masterpiece just to be good, they made a solid effort that is good at what it is, metalcore at it's finest.

Ultimately "The Hope We Forgot Exists" provides a solid and rather enjoyable listen. While lacking in length and originality the band compensates through energy and solid song writing. It probably won't convert anyone to the genre, but if you enjoy this type of music and tire of recycled mallcore bands then look no further.

Recommended Tracks
Reason To Believe

Recent reviews by this author
Motion City Soundtrack Panic StationsHit the Lights Summer Bones
This Good Robot The Light is Taking Me to PiecesThis Good Robot The Human I Am
The Audition Great DangerThe Forecast The Forecast

user ratings (13)

Comments:Add a Comment 
April 7th 2009


Album Rating: 4.0

I'm a longtime lurker, first time reviewer, so don't rip into me too badly. However, constructive criticism is much appreciated, it's the only way to improve after all!

April 7th 2009


its rather short.......

and wait they released a techno dance album after this? that cant be a good sign

April 7th 2009


This sounds likely your standard metalcore band. The review didn't do much to sway me into purchasing it. It reads somewhat fanboyish. Not terrible for a first effort though.

April 7th 2009


Album Rating: 4.5

I absolutely loved this album and the energy this band shows on the album is only a fraction of the energy they have in their set. Each show they put on was better then their last. For an underground New England Metalcore band they were in a league of their own. Now of course they switched to Euro-Techno with 'Who Speaks for Planet Earth?' and they currently show no signs of going back to metalcore. Truly sad that Matt Rhodes and the rest of the band wasted their god given talent on techno but hey life likes to throw curve balls. This will always be a classic album for me. Their album before this one, 'It Was The End' is good too, not quite as polished but still packed full of energy and good breakdowns.

April 7th 2009


Album Rating: 4.0

have i told you that i love you lately? dude, post a review of "who speaks for planet earth" because i don't want to do it

April 7th 2009


Gah the lyrics just kill it for me.

June 10th 2009


I posted a review for "Who Speaks For Planet Earth?"

June 10th 2009


btw, this is a good review, but i wholeheartedly disagree. I think this sounds like As I Lay Dying with shitty production quality. That is to say, about a 2, maybe a 2.5 at the most. Enjoyable for a few listens, but past that not really worth a lot...

You have to be logged in to post a comment. Login | Create a Profile


Bands: A B C D E F G H I J K L M N O P Q R S T U V W X Y Z

Site Copyright 2005-2017
All Album Reviews Displayed With Permission of Authors | Terms of Use | Privacy Policy