Idlewild
100 Broken Windows


5.0
classic

Review

by robin EMERITUS
December 6th, 2008 | 33 replies


Release Date: 2000 | Tracklist

Review Summary: Cold-blooded patriotism

Idlewild are proud of their home nation. Every time he strums a chord in any given half-hearted genre shuffle for his band, it’s so clear to see that Roddy Woomble is one of Scotland’s truest patriots – perhaps it was once humble and restricted to small bouts of overpowering Scottish accent, but eventually it simply became an unmistakable admiration. He tried to bend the rules of the band’s third foray, The Remote Part, when Scotland’s very own poet Laureate Edwin Morgan opted to collaborate with Idlewild, squeezing an angry poem about the land’s literature into a completely unrelated song. Then, Woomble’s band made an attempt at writing Scottish folk in a conventional rock sound as their albums progressed, and eventually it all ended with recognition, the band donating a new creation to Songs of The Book, a modern day attempt at Scottish folklore. Thanks to Woomble, this is the band’s truest, proudest characteristic, and what better way to be recognised than with your country behind you"

But thankfully, their sophomore effort needed an introduction to absolutely everyone, because there was nothing to live up to; Hope Is Important, the bands debut album, was a jumbled mess that really only succeeded in presenting Idlewild’s schisms. What was there to this record" There was pure hardcore punk with the most mediocre distain, with the band screaming through one minute of the most pointless introduction ever created. There was also sentiment as half way through and a few sessions of thinking later they wrote “I’m Happy To Be Here Tonight”, a weary acoustic outpour that sounded exactly like they would have wanted it to – coming out of a distant and ancient castle. In between these outcasts was a slob’s cut and paste job, with choruses and verses simply being positioned until the album faded away, never to be remembered again. This was the band’s blessing: nobody needs to remember this album (what a mix up!) until they have actually remembered what its wiser counterpart 100 Broken Windows, did.

In recent years, the path faced with post-punk revival acts such as Interpol, Franz Ferdinand, Editors et al has become as frequent as possibly necessary. Yet there are even other alt rockers with the same desire to impel ‘real’ punk aggression into their typical offshoot of rock music, albeit keeping it to an accessible limit. Before the new millennium, anyone who had listened to the interpretation and definition by Manic Street Preachers of punk rock by means of The Holy Bible would have known that this would not be a particularly unique trend. Whether or not Idlewild travelled into the future and gauged any of this is unsure, but their happy millennium album, 100 Broken Windows, essentially restrained the unplanned, somehow wrong sounds they had one crafted and traded it in for something quite special.

And while it’s easy to label Woomble’s alternative rock as ‘punk based’, what it really becomes is aggressive music floating amidst thoughtful music. For instance, the resemblance of a two-chord outfit on “I Don’t Have A Map” is there as Rod Jones cranks up the guitar and vibrates the room with distortion, and there’s even more evidence to fit the pedantic when Woomble is so close to screaming his lungs out as he sings You can’t cope without the contact! one last time. But what makes the track so delightfully brilliant – so enjoyable – is that the band stop and think, realise their limits, and create something that, to the wider world, is devoid of boundary. Again, the near-yells on “Idea Track” create something that has always mystified me – the idea of blending pop-punk with Britpop into one package. And this beautiful result of a chaotic, one-syllable anthem, sums up the connotations abound in the ‘punk’ side of 100 Broken Windows – they’re always hiding, and as they’re mixed with unpredictable, atonal piano, they’re just one small contribution to making it a masterpiece.

Still, sometimes it’s even better for the band to tread down another path of outburst. Instead of reaching for the distressing, blasting vocals, the band are fusing absolutely anything they can get their hand on, bidding farewell to integrity and making some of the catchiest music ever. “These Wooden Ideas” draws in fuzzy, psychedelic keyboard that overlaps with moody guitar lines, and Woomble is left, the senile, crafty singer he is, to almost respond to the silent listener, retorting arguments with I bet you don’t know how to spell contradiction/I bet you don’t know how to sell conviction. It’s moments like these, where a sneakily long bridge is suddenly shattered with possibly the best chorus in history, that the band invoke their truest form of rock. Again, this power comes through when the band want to dig into their historical niches and end up squealing a sing-along verse of Gertrude Stein said “THAT’S ENOUGH!” in the fleshed-out, epic grunge nobility of “Roesability”. All these moments signify a lack of regard for musical prowess and a distinct adoration for simply thrashing their guitars, drums and vocals against one another, and it makes 100 Broken Windows, with its enclosed unhappy happenstance of echoes, one of the most claustrophobic, intense albums to listen in on.

100 Broken Windows never really had a circumstance to rely on in terms of making it truly special and provoking, which makes it even more remarkable as an album anyone can connect to emotionally. Lyrically, Woomble has scribbled out a brainstorm that looks nonsensical on paper, but suits every mood it touches. He references absolutely no-one in “The Bronze Medal”, crying out materialistic loathing with It felt cold inside/so we threw the television on the fire and rambling about coming third – but even when it should be so untouchable, it suits the abnormal piano ballad perfectly and becomes attaching. And even amidst each candid track’s lyrical weirdness, Idlewild can connect each and every amplified guitar note, piano chord and (just once), bagpipe line. In the end, it’s summed up in “The Bronze Medal” when, finally, Woomble knows what he wants to say, and becomes coherent enough to delicately sing It was always meant to be like this/when you’re somewhere that’s as cold as this. By the time this half-hum is over, there is simply one thing to understand about 100 Broken Windows: personality. It is an album about identity in so many abstract ways; the phobias of “Actually Its Darkness”, the imagination of humans that can be conveyed in “These Wooden Ideas”, and the full embodiment of human character in the albums disheartening, heavy closer. Everyone of Idlewild’s blurry ballads in 100 Broken Windows are almost suffocating in their emotional resonance, but more importantly, at the same time as they’re helping you discover what the album and band means to you, you’re also reminded – through the accent, the poetry, the avid instruments, whatever – that they’re true patriots. Enjoy forty minutes of Scotland’s uproar.



Recent reviews by this author
Matt Douglas Affirmation (with Discomfort)Kacey Musgraves Golden Hour
Angelo De Augustine Swim Inside the MoonJeff Rosenstock Worry.
Okkervil River AwayOren Ambarchi, Kassel Jaeger, James Rushford Pale Calling
user ratings (92)
Chart.
4.2
excellent
other reviews of this album
theredwonder (5)
...



Comments:Add a Comment 
robin
Emeritus
December 6th 2008


4522 Comments


i didn't have any credibility anyway, so yeah.

ClearTheLane
December 6th 2008


990 Comments


hey again, this was a very good review. Tbh it's very hard for me to believe that this really is a classic, although u did clearly explain why it is in your opinion. I've only heard it The Remote Part and it was pretty good.

robin
Emeritus
December 6th 2008


4522 Comments


the remote part sucks, really. ive always thought this beat it tenfold. you should definetely give it a listen. thanks.

by the way, fun fact for everyone: the guy from have a nice life digs this album

rasputin
December 6th 2008


14968 Comments


Fantastic review.

kingsoby1
Emeritus
December 6th 2008


4970 Comments


good review bruh, ill have to check it out

spoon_of_grimbo
December 6th 2008


2241 Comments

Album Rating: 5.0

i love the sorta rambling, grabbing-at-various-ideas-and-throwing-them-in style of this review, as that's the exact feel of the album itself! best review i've read in ages, and of a fucking brilliant album too! probably joint with The Remote Part as my favourite Idlewild album (although tbh i like everything they've done).



pianotuna, you still interested in the b-sides? i've got pretty much every b-side they've done (aside from a couple of acoustic versions and remixes), as well as the Captain EP. leave me your email if you want them, and i'll see what i can do about rapid-sharing them or something.

spoon_of_grimbo
December 6th 2008


2241 Comments

Album Rating: 5.0

also, if you like this album, check out "semi-detached" by Therapy?, which has a kinda similar feel for a lot of it (although without the scottishness, as Therapy? are irish).

DaveyBoy
Staff Reviewer
December 6th 2008


22486 Comments


Fantastic review Robin. I've been meaning to give Idlewild a close listen to for a while now and I think your review backs up that this band really does need a "close" listen. Good stuff. Pos.

robin
Emeritus
December 7th 2008


4522 Comments


spoonofgrimbo, i'd love the b-sides and captain. that'd be great. and i'll give therapy a listen.

thanks to everyone else, also. This Message Edited On 03.29.09

Kiran
Emeritus
December 10th 2008


6027 Comments

Album Rating: 3.0

A friend linked me to the video of These Wooden Ideas and the song is really good. Unfortunately, this falls behind a long list of albums I have to catch up on.

robin
Emeritus
December 10th 2008


4522 Comments


definetely.

the b-sides that spoonofgrimbo sent me off this are so good as well, they really need to do more acoustic versions for this album.

spoon_of_grimbo
January 2nd 2009


2241 Comments

Album Rating: 5.0

just upped my rating for this to a 5. seriously, one of my favourite albums ever.



i actually found a fansite that had a few bootlegs, live, and acoustic songs from this album, but sadly they'd received a cease and desist, which meant none of the downloads were working... although those files must be out there somewhere!

Electric City
Emeritus
January 6th 2009


15762 Comments


kind of unimpressed =/

robin
Emeritus
January 7th 2009


4522 Comments


why.

i need to make some edits in this review, spontaneously placed commas

spoon_of_grimbo
January 7th 2009


2241 Comments

Album Rating: 5.0

really EC? give it another chance, once it clicks with you, you'll love it. i can't comprehend how anyone couldn't find this album amazing.



also, the more i listen to "idea track" the more i think it might be the weirdest and yet most beautiful song ever.

robin
Emeritus
January 9th 2009


4522 Comments


that track really shouldnt fit in with the album considering it's pretty much a one-line, one-idea song, but it's probably one of my favourites for its outro(s). :p

handoman
January 27th 2009


2386 Comments


so im listening to this right now...its pretty good so far...not sure its a 5 tho

Kiran
Emeritus
January 28th 2009


6027 Comments

Album Rating: 3.0

A bit underwhelmed by the album as a whole although there are a few great songs.

Bsmith7
March 28th 2009


252 Comments

Album Rating: 4.5

I had more trouble finding this than I have ever had finding an album before.

robin
Emeritus
March 29th 2009


4522 Comments


shouldn't be too hard to find if you mean a physical copy. i picked my copy up from hmv.



You have to be logged in to post a comment. Login | Create a Profile





STAFF & CONTRIBUTORS // SITE FORUM // CONTACT US

Bands: A B C D E F G H I J K L M N O P Q R S T U V W X Y Z


Site Copyright 2005-2017 Sputnikmusic.com
All Album Reviews Displayed With Permission of Authors | Terms of Use | Privacy Policy