The Classic Crime
The Silver Cord



by qscott777 USER (7 Reviews)
September 17th, 2008 | 12 replies

Release Date: 2008 | Tracklist

Review Summary: The Silver Cord is a well constructed piece of work from a musically maturing band.

We all try to better ourselves. We all like to think we’re stronger, wiser, and more experienced than we were years ago. So why is it that so often we stay the same more than we would have expected? In my review of this band’s debut album, Albatross, I mentioned the departure from pop punk, both on the part of this band, and my own taste in music. And even though I’m so determined to progress, I still find myself listening to the same type of music as I did years ago. And The Classic Crime seems to share that mindset. Although much of the material on The Silver Cord explores new ground, I find it plainly obvious that these songs came from the same minds. However, I think maturity is not determined simply by genre. It’s the album I expected from the band that produced Albatross, only respectably longer, better written, and quite a bit darker.

Musically, as I mentioned, these songs are not completely different than those on Albatross. The technicality in the individual parts has increased quite a bit. The guitar parts seem to be doing pretty much the same thing as before. There seems like there’s a little more going on. But there’s still some palm-muted verses, and absurd amount of picked arpeggios in the slow songs, and loud power chords blanketing the intros and choruses. This leads to songs like “The Way That You Are” and “Salt in the Snow” sounding a lot like they belonged on Albatross.

To my surprise, there are a couple solos on this album…nothing to get too excited about, but they’re there. And the solo in “Gravedigging” isn't bad at all. Some songs have a lot more creativity in them. The time signatures in “Just a Man” shift back and forth from 5/8 to 6/8 to keep things interesting. The parts in “Abracadavers” and “Medisin” are well written, and they provide for a dark, yet profound overtone. The instrumental parts in those songs are probably my favorite on the album. But the clean guitar during the softer parts can be found on almost every song and I get very bored with that. The intros for “The Ascent” and “The Beginning” are painfully similar.

The bass parts have not changed a whole lot. They stand out more on this record than the last. Particularly on the songs that would never have appeared on Albatross. But it still falls into the background on the heavier and the more “pop” songs. I’m not usually listening to the bass, so it’s nice when it actually stands out, but that is rare. The drums also haven’t changed a lot. But they weren’t bad on the last album. The bass and drum parts stand out most on songs such as "5805," that don't have a ballad feel to them.

The vocals leave a little to be desired. They are not bad. I'd even pointed them out as being a strong point of Albatross. I just expected a lot more after hearing their acoustic EP. Matt MacDonald is a talented vocalist. I was impressed by the flexibility he showed on that disc. I liked use of falsetto and hoped to see it more on this album. I think he only uses it on “Closer Than We Think.” He can also use a lot of emotion when he wants: see “Gravediggers.” Again, the vocals aren’t bad. They’re even good…but I know they could be better.

One of the big improvement’s I’d noticed right away was the lyrics. On Albatross, their lyrics became cheesy, quite often. It was obvious they had a lot of religious influence, and it reminded me of worship music. The material they use on this album is interesting. Not a lot of bands write about these subjects in this manner. The Classic Crime addresses mortality head on, as a human. If a band talks about death, it usually becomes very…pardon me…emo. I’m bored with those bands. This album offers something new. It offers a realistic perspective through these songs. There’s a lot of personal reflection, brought on by the thought of death. My favorite song on The Silver Cord is “Medisin,” partially due to the lyrics.
“Oh no, no I'll never listen or do what I'm told
At twenty-four you'd think I'd hold my speech.
Instead I'll mix you a cocktail, some truth and some slander
and never practice what I preach.”
The lyrics reflect the darker tone in the album as well, again while maintaining the same origins. They're writing about the same subjects, just from a different perspective.

The Classic Crime matured a lot on this album. For the most part, they’re doing the same thing they were doing before, only better…or at least differently. And that gives us variety. This album had fifteen tracks on it, which is a pleasant surprise. The songs are different enough to keep things interesting during most of it, even though I usually skip the first and last tracks. As a whole, it is a very well constructed piece of work. It’s worth picking up.

Recent reviews by this author
Rags and Ribbons The Glass MassesNural Entitlement
Abandon Kansas We're All Going SomewhereBarcelona Absolutes
Your Best Friend Your Best FriendThe Classic Crime Albatross
user ratings (209)

Comments:Add a Comment 
September 17th 2008


Cool review, but try cut out the colloquial language ("And the solo in “Gravedigging” is kinda neat"). Your paragraph on the vocals bummed me out a bit - read it out aloud to check if it flows.

One last thing: try to add the album art, just so it looks nicer and stands out more on the front page.This Message Edited On 09.17.08

September 17th 2008


Album Rating: 3.0


I like saying "kinda neat". It was the best way I could think to describe it...

September 17th 2008




Contributing Reviewer
November 10th 2008


Good review. Decent album.

June 8th 2010


Album Rating: 4.5

little late to comment, but this is one of the better reviews ive read by a non staff reviewer. real nice job.

June 3rd 2012


Don't remember if I liked this or not.

August 6th 2012


Album Rating: 4.0

Seattle rockers The Classic Crime may not be breaking new ground here, but continue their ascension with 2nd LP 'The Silver Cord'. This darker - yet still uplifting - 54 minute album displays an expansive sound which suggests significant growth & depth. Matt MacDonald's sincere & passionate vocals are again prominent, while the top-notch lyrics come together to form a satisfying thematical arc. The greatest improvement may come via the almost quirky energy & dynamics of the dual guitar attack, lending most tunes understated melodies which enhance replay value. Recommended Tracks: Gravedigging, Salt in the Snow, The Way That You Are & Closer Than We Think.

March 1st 2016


Album Rating: 4.0

I always find myself coming back to this album. I kinda matured through high school with it, and it's still the apex of this band for me. God and Drugs, along with the last few songs to close it out, really made this album for me.

January 2nd 2017


Album Rating: 4.0

Good album, still holds up

The choruses on here are awesome

July 14th 2017


Album Rating: 5.0

One of my favorite albums. Even now it takes the sting out of How to Be Human sucking so much.

Digging: Two People - Second Body

March 21st 2019


Album Rating: 5.0

Ohmyglory, this still fucking is awesome all these years later.

May 4th 2020


Album Rating: 5.0

yeah I had to bump this to a 5 a while back. The Beginning is a spellbinding track and a personal all-time favorite, but there's not a bad song on here...time to give this a relisten as I process Patterns in the Static

5/5: Gravedigging, Salt In The Snow, Medisin, Closer Than We Think, The Beginning (honestly like a 10/5 for me personally)

4.5/5: Just a Man, God and Drugs

4/5: Everything, Sing, The Way That You Are, 5805, Abracadavers

3.5/5: R&R, The End, The Ascent

You have to be logged in to post a comment. Login | Create a Profile


Bands: A B C D E F G H I J K L M N O P Q R S T U V W X Y Z

Site Copyright 2005-2019
All Album Reviews Displayed With Permission of Authors | Terms of Use | Privacy Policy